Scale: 4.20-5.00 (Very Effective); 3.40-4.19 (Effective); 2.60-3.39 (Somewhat Effective); 1.80-2.59 (Least
Effective); 1.00-1.79 (Not Effective)
After the Use of the Fill My Bag Strategy Based on Checklist Observation
A pertinent study supporting the findings presented in Table 4 regarding the effectiveness of the "Fill My Bag
Strategy" is the research conducted by Dogani (2023) titled Active Learning and Effective Teaching Strategies.
This study provides a detailed overview of active learning approaches and their application in educational
settings. The findings highlight that active learning strategies—such as peer learning, role-play, think-pair-
share, class debates, and simulations—significantly enhance student engagement, motivation, and critical
thinking skills. The study emphasizes that traditional lecture-based instruction often results in passive learning,
whereas active learning promotes higher student performance and retention. These insights align closely with
the outcomes observed after implementing the "Fill My Bag Strategy," where learners demonstrated notable
improvements across various constructs, including engagement, vocabulary development, reading
comprehension, writing expression, and collaboration skills. Parenthetical: (Dogani, 2023)
Similarly, a study by Kim and Pekrun (2014), titled Emotions and Motivation in Learning, investigates how
engaging instructional strategies influence students’ motivation and emotional involvement in the classroom.
Their research shows that active and participatory learning approaches significantly boost intrinsic motivation
and positive emotions toward academic tasks, leading to better engagement and performance. The findings
suggest that strategies promoting interaction, reflection, and hands-on activities create a more stimulating
learning environment. This supports the success of the "Fill My Bag Strategy" in improving engagement
among Grade 8 English learners by fostering both motivation and active participation. (Kim & Pekrun, 2014)
Table 4 presents the learners’ participation after the implementation of the Fill My Bag Strategy as assessed
through checklist observation. The overall effectiveness of the strategy was rated as (M = 3.615, SD = 0.247),
which falls under the category of “Effective.” Among the constructs assessed, Learners’ Engagement in the
Fill My Bag obtained the highest mean (M = “.000, SD =”0.464), followed closely by Reading Comprehension
and Analysis (M = 3.993, SD = 0.528) and Vocabulary Development and Word Understanding (M = 3.941, SD
= 0.534). Next in rank were Writing Expression Skills (M = 3.911, SD = 0.564) and Collaboration and
Communication Skills (M = 3.682, SD = 0.279)—all of which were likewise rated as “Effective.”
These results indicate a substantial improvement in learners’ participation and performance across all
constructs following the strategy’s implementation. The highest mean score in Learners’ Engagement suggests
that the strategy effectively encouraged active involvement in classroom activities. Gains in Reading
Comprehension, Vocabulary, and Writing show that both receptive and productive language skills were
strengthened. Although Collaboration and Communication Skills had the lowest mean (M = 3.682), they still
fell within the "Effective" range, suggesting that while interpersonal skills improved, further focused
interventions may help enhance these competencies. The relatively low standard deviations across all
constructs reflect consistency in the positive outcomes experienced by learners.
These findings carry valuable implications for educators, instructional leaders, and curriculum developers.
Teachers are encouraged to continue using and refining the Fill My Bag Strategy, particularly by incorporating
more peer interaction elements to further strengthen Collaboration and Communication Skills. School
administrators can support broader adoption through training workshops and resource provision. To address
the slightly lower performance in collaborative competencies, suggested activities include structured group
projects, role-playing tasks, and peer-feedback exercises that encourage sustained interpersonal engagement.
Additionally, reflection journals, vocabulary-building games, and creative writing prompts can be used to
reinforce language skills further. Overall, these findings underscore the importance of interactive, student-
centered strategies in promoting comprehensive language development and holistic learner engagement.