multi-dimensional concept. It typically includes citizenship behaviours, civic responsibility, public-mindedness,
tolerance, and community engagement.
Globally, it has been recognised that civic virtues are vital to the well-being of society, given the polarisation
that plagues our societies today. Moreover, the (Darnell and Kristján Kristjánsson, 2020) lack of civic virtues at
a global level has led to a decline in social trust. Government trust and institutional trust in America stood at
19% in 2015 (American Journal of Democracy,2024). Furthermore, civic engagement globally, as one of the
civic virtues, has led to lower electoral turnout and increased distrust in government (OECD Report, 2023).
Kimpell (2015) conducted a study on republican civic virtue, enlightened self-interest and Tocqueville.
Tocqueville’s claim in Democracy in America about the link between associations and a vibrant public sphere is
interpreted especially by neo-republicans in political theory as aligned with their argument that civic virtue can
and ought to be fostered in today’s democracies.
Studies by Kahne and Westheimer (2017) highlight the critical role of civic education in fostering civic virtues
among the youth. Their research emphasises that educational institutions are pivotal sites for instilling values of
civic responsibility and participation. They advocate for educational curricula that foster critical thinking,
dialogue, and community engagement as essential components of civic virtue development. The value of
responsibility in the textbooks embraces not only the meanings of self-obligation and accountability, but
responsibility is also defined as an individual’s sense of self-discipline in their behaviour that enables them to
avoid conflict and strive for harmonious social order. The other important values are “Respect”, “Helpful”,
“Hard-working” and “Caring”. This study provided an example of how a multi-ethnic nation state like Malaysia
promotes these moral values through its educational curriculum, for political legitimacy and forging national
unity, a component that was explored in the current study using a qualitative method.
Civic virtues are also a concern in Africa as the AU Agenda 2063 emphasises the virtues of civic engagement,
good governance and human rights in the achievement of the goals of the continent (The Africa We Want, 2015).
Recognizing the value of civic virtues, the AU promotes good governance, democracy and human rights as these
are essential for civic virtues to thrive. Adediran & Ogunleye (2024) contended that inappropriate civic values
among Nigerians have deeply eroded the fabric of Nigerian society, and the only remedy is to inculcate
fundamental patriotic values in the younger ones, who are the future leaders, through the learning of Civic
Education. It is pertinent to note that a successful process of solving the present challenges of our society through
the inculcation of civic virtues in our youths requires effective civic education in our schools.
Zembere (2018) conducted a study on democratic citizenship education in Zimbabwe’s higher education system
and its implications for teaching and learning. The study aimed to examine the impact of democratic citizenship
education on higher education in Zimbabwe between 1980 and 2015. Critical inquiry was employed as the
primary research design, drawing on social constructivism and transformation as frameworks that informed this
research. The research used deconstruction as a method, and this enabled the research to claim openness in
thinking about university education in Zimbabwe to unforeseeable in becoming being other than it is today, so
that university education can contend with issues of inequality, corruption, as well as electoral and ethnic
violence in whatever singularity.
In the Zambian context, civic virtue encompasses various aspects that promote the well-being and development
of society. According to Kafukulu (2018), civic virtues in Zambia include respect for authority, community
solidarity, and participation in volunteer work. Additionally, Simutanyi (2015) highlights the importance of
social cohesion, tolerance, and respect for diversity as essential components of civic virtue in Zambia's
multicultural society. These civic virtues are shaped by Zambia's cultural, historical, and socio-economic context,
and they encompass a range of settled dispositions that reflect the moral excellences necessary for contributing
positively to societal well-being and governance. Several studies illustrate the vital role that educational
institutions play in cultivating civic virtues.
Vincent (2018) examined the influence of values education and the interplay of religion in shaping civic virtues,
particularly through the lens of the teaching of 'fundamental British values.' The study pointed out that the