The Influence of Bilingualism English and Somali on Medium  
Instruction in Higher Secondary Schools in Borama and Hargiesa  
District Somaliland  
Mr. Abdiqani Ismail Ibrahim  
Director of Department Research Commission for Higher Education  
Received: 03 October 2025; Accepted: 09 October 2025; Published: 18 December 2025  
ABSTRACT  
This study aimed to investigate the challenges encountered by teachers and students in secondary schools in  
Borama and Hargeisa districts of Somaliland, where English serves as the medium of instruction. It focused on  
assessing the competencies of teachers and the essential abilities of students required for effective learning in an  
English-based environment. The research adopted a cross-sectional design using quantitative methods and  
employed survey techniques through self-administered structured questionnaires. Non-probability sampling  
methods, including convenience and purposive sampling, were utilized to select 150 teachers and 458 students  
as participants. The collected data underwent thorough analysis using Excel and SPSS software, emphasizing  
descriptive statistics like frequency distributions to present the findings effectively. The findings of the study  
indicated that male teachers outnumbered female teachers in secondary schools, and there was a similar trend of  
more female students than male students. Most teachers possessed significant experience ranging from 11 to 21  
years, and their educational qualifications were primarily at the university level, specializing in subject teaching  
at the secondary level. However, concerns were raised regarding the necessity to address salary issues for  
teachers. The study also observed instances where teachers alternated between Somali and English languages  
during presentations, with consensus among both teachers and students. Additionally, students expressed a need  
for supplementary materials in libraries to enhance their learning processes and homework, thereby improving  
their English proficiency. Notably, students who predominantly used their mother tongue during the learning  
process exhibited poorer performance in English.  
INTRODUCTION  
The National Commission for Higher Education (NCHE) is responsible for ensuring the quality of higher  
education and promoting research carried out by the office and universities based for the long-term goal. Based  
on this, the NCHE conducted a research project in some public secondary schools in two districts that are  
Hargiesa and Borama the purpose of see the influence of English on the student of secondary level or English  
used by the instructors/teachers on the students of secondary level. As well as the teaching method or the teacher's  
presentation and the student's understanding during the learning process.  
1.1 Brief History of Education in Somaliland  
The spread of Islam and the Arabic language, along with the exposure of Somali traders, seamen, soldiers, and  
religious pilgrims to various forms of education, meant that small settled communities on the coast were  
introduced to a blend of Western and Islamic education long before European colonizers arrived in Somalia  
(Cassanelli and Farah, 2007). However, for the majority of Somalis leading nomadic livelihoods, education  
remained an informal community affair involving the interaction between elders and youth on subjects covering  
clan history, religion, battle, and other knowledge and skills essential for survival (Abdi, 1998; Hussein, 2007).  
In 1929, British officials attempted a new strategy by providing small grants to Somali sheikhs in selected private  
Islamic schools under the condition that they teach reading, writing, arithmetic (in Arabic), and religion. The  
government also funded young men to study at Gordon College in Sudan, with five Somalis enrolled in 1933.  
By then, the Somaliland National Society, a local self-improvement association, had already begun advocating  
Page 1371  
for modern education that included English subjects, indicating that Muslim Somalis took initiative in this area  
even before WWII (Cassanelli and Farah, 2007). The British Protectorate of Somaliland, in 1942, established  
three elementary schools in Hargeisa, Berbera, and Burao. By 1945, 400 Somali boys were attending seven  
elementary schools in the Protectorate, with assistance also provided to nineteen private Quranic schools  
teaching Arabic and arithmetic. Plans were made for starting secondary education, and by 1950, two intermediate  
schools were in operation (Cassanelli and Farah, 2007).  
After Independence in 1960, the challenges for the education system increased, including integrating different  
school systems, teaching methods, and curriculums. The Ministry of Education aimed to turn all elementary  
schools into four-year programs, followed by four years each of intermediate and secondary schooling. It was  
decided that English should replace Italian as the medium of instruction in the third year of primary school. In  
1965, Arabic was chosen as the medium of instruction for elementary years, while English would be used in  
intermediate and secondary levels (Cassanelli and Farah, 2007). With the shift to socialism in 1970, Somali  
education took a new direction. A Somali language script was established in 1972, followed by national literacy  
campaigns in 1973 and 1974. Education was made free and compulsory for children aged six to fourteen by  
1975, with lessons conducted in Somali to cover more ground. Challenges remained, but efforts were made to  
improve the educational system.  
Somaliland has a rich historical background, from pre-independence treaties to the Declaration of Re-assertion  
of Sovereignty in 1991. The region covers 137,600 km² and shares borders with Ethiopia, Djibouti, and Somalia.  
Hargeisa serves as the political and commercial capital, with six main regions and emerging regional areas.  
Somali is the official language, and Islam plays a significant role in everyday life (ME&S, 2020). Despite  
challenges, Somaliland has made strides in revitalizing its schools since 1991. However, the education system's  
capacity and quality need improvement. Efforts are underway, with the Ministry of Education focusing on  
community awareness and local participation. Schools are being renovated, and a curriculum has been developed  
to lay a foundation for systematic education. The medium of instruction varies based on school levels, with  
Somali in primary schools and English in secondary schools (Moh’ed, 2017).  
1.2 The Study Problem  
Over the past 30 years, the English language has become integral to educational settings, particularly in  
secondary schools and higher education institutions. This language forms the basis of the syllabus and  
curriculum, and many students who began their secondary school education during this period are now teachers  
themselves in secondary schools. This study aimed to provide research-based baseline data on the impact of  
English as a medium of instruction on secondary-level students in Borama and Hargeisa districts of Somaliland,  
along with potential justification measures. The research findings have significant implications for both teachers'  
and learners' education, guiding critical interventions, curriculum design and implementation, as well as policy  
changes aimed at enhancing the quality of education delivery.  
This research aims to identify the challenges associated with the English language among students in secondary  
schools, including those who have graduated with the curriculum, tests, assignments, and examinations  
conducted in English. The language's role is crucial in shaping the quality of students' knowledge, as their  
education continues predominantly in English after secondary school. English holds a paramount position in the  
Somaliland school curriculum. For students to effectively comprehend their teachers across all subjects, a strong  
command of the English language is essential. English is often regarded as the gateway to mastering other  
subjects, highlighting its importance in the overall educational framework.  
1.3 Objectives of the Study  
The general research objective of this study was to describe the influence English of medium instruction on  
student of secondary level  
This study had the following objectives:  
1 To investigate problems students and teachers face in the use of English medium instruction at the  
secondary school level.  
Page 1372  
2 To determine the competencies the secondary school teachers require for teaching through English  
medium instruction at the secondary level.  
SOMALILAND TEACHER EDUCATION POLICY  
1.1.  
Language Policy and Teacher Education  
The language policy plays a critical role in education in any country. Over the years Arabic, English and  
Somali languages have been used as the medium of instruction in schools at one point or another. SNEP  
2017 states that Somali language is the language of instruction from grades 1 to 8, while English language  
is taught as a subject from grade 2 since 2006/2007 academic year.  
The level of English teaching in the country is underdeveloped to a point where sometimes it has to be  
supported through the medium of Somali language during lessons. To resolve this problem a special  
programme for the development of the English language teaching in schools will be developed with  
technical and financial support from development partners. This will be done to ensure that by the time  
primary school pupils leave school they are proficient in English for them to benefit from secondary school  
education, where the medium of instruction shall be English. This will also enable the citizens of  
Somaliland to participate effectively with other nations in trade and politics where the language of business  
is mainly English. Arabic will be the medium of instruction for Islamic studies and as a subject at all levels  
in the Somaliland schools system.  
The Somali language has a rich and extensive treasure in oral literature. The Somaliland children need to  
understand and appreciate this heritage. Therefore Somaliland oral literature will be taught as part of the  
Somali language. To facilitate this, the status of the Somali will be upgraded and a national orthography  
and syntax developed to systematize the language across the country and at different levels of education  
with support from Somali language scholars.  
To ensure effective implementation of the language policy at the primary school level, the language of  
instruction in teacher education, at both certificate and diploma teacher education levels, shall be the  
English language.  
1.2.  
Current context of teacher education  
Teacher education in Somaliland is categorized and located within the higher education institutions.  
However, there are major concerns from the stakeholders about the quality of teacher education and teacher  
professionalism in the Somaliland context. These concerns can be divided into two categories: (1) problems  
relating to the enabling infrastructure that supports teacher education and teacher professionalism. This  
includes a contested and uncoordinated governance system; unclear accreditation system of teacher  
education institutions; poor quality assurance system; inadequate funding; unclear outcomes; disparities in  
qualified teacher status in different universities; narrow paths into the teaching profession and lack of  
interest among graduates to pursue teacher education because of it is low status resulting from poor  
remuneration. The results of the above challenges have been an acute shortage of teachers at all levels. In  
addition to these challenges there are also: (2) problems that are specific to the teacher education  
programmes in the local universities, which have their roots in the historical nature and the social  
construction of the previous education and teacher education systems since Somaliland gained its  
independence in 1960 from the British. These limitations include:  
Poor selection criteria and low level quality of teacher education entrants:  
Teacher education students experience training and curriculum that is irrelevant to the new role of  
education.  
Poor partnership between universities and schools: currently all initial teacher education models in  
Somaliland are university based, apart from the teaching practice where students spend about eight  
weeks in schools.  
Page 1373  
Inadequate and uncoordinated professional development of teachers.  
Extreme gender imbalances  
1.3.  
Secondary teacher education  
General secondary education consists of forms 1 to 4. The aim of secondary education is to build on the  
primary education as a foundation for advanced academic, vocational and professional training. The  
curriculum for secondary education consists of integrated academic and practical subjects in order to  
develop problem-solving skills and cognitive abilities among students. The medium of instruction for all  
subjects at this level other than Somali; Arabic and Islamic studies shall be the English language. It is the  
utmost of the government priority to review secondary schools curriculum, syllabuses and textbooks, and  
run in-service courses for the implementation of the new syllabuses and training of teachers.  
The majority of secondary school teachers are expected to be university graduates with specialization in at least  
two main teaching subjects upon graduation. So far ---- students have completed their diploma of education  
course with support from development partners. Indications are that it is very difficult to recruit students into  
education programmes at the university; because many would be students cannot afford the tuition fees.  
Secondly, students see no career prospects in teaching, since there is no secure employment structure for  
teachers. Further, even when they are employed by the Government there may be no regular salary. Funds are  
needed to finance scholarships to teacher education programmes to fill the current and future demand for teachers  
in Somaliland and to stabilize the employment of teachers at different levels.  
The teaching force at this level is very low in terms of numbers and quality.  
1.4.  
Review of Related Literature  
Educators have always been interested in understanding the factors that affect students’ learning and the school’s  
success in imparting to the students the knowledge and skills essential for their integration into society and the  
economy. Today, educators are widely recognizing that learning is not about knowledge delivery, but about a  
cognitive process of knowledge construction strongly affected by social, cultural and emotional factors. From  
this view of learning, we are increasingly expecting that the school would adapt more constructivist, student-  
centered instructional methods, such as problem-based learning and project-based learning in which students  
work in teams to investigate or solve real-life questions and problems (Savery, 2006; Hmelo-Silver, 2004;  
Blumenfeld et al., 1991).  
Historically, the study of teaching has been dominated by simple input-output models of instructional effects. In  
this paradigm, teaching behaviors are identified or created, students are exposed to these conditions, and student  
output is measured. Typically, student mental processes are assumed without direct measurement or entirely  
ignored. In this tradition, students have been largely viewed as the passive recipients of instruction. The activity  
theory presented in the following section was selected as the conceptual framework for this research because  
this theory examines teaching and learning in school as an activity system and provides a conceptual lens through  
which we can investigate the interaction between a range of social and cultural factors comprising this system  
in order to understand the quality of schooling (Dakers, 2011).  
1.5.  
The Medium of instruction Language Literature  
Studies indicate the medium of instruction has been a longstanding issue in the Pakistani context (Mustafa, 2011;  
Rassool & Mansoor, 2007; Mansoor, 2004; Rahman, 1996). There has been a good deal of debate regarding the  
merits and demerits of English Medium of Instruction (EMI) in the Pakistani context. Some oppose the use of  
EMI in schools based on its failure in the process of real learning and because of certain ideological positioning.  
The White Paper on Education (2006) opposed the adoption of EMI at the primary and secondary level. Those  
opposing EMI argue that this stands in the way of real learning on the part of students (Mustafa, 2013 & 2020).  
Besides, Dearden (2015) argues that more than EMI the educational infrastructure in most of the countries is a  
hurdle in the way of effective EMI provision and the lack of trained teachers and scarcity of clear guidelines are  
some of the issues that affect EMI. She points out that the failure of EMI should not be associated with student  
Page 1374  
learning as its success depends on several other factors. Skeptics also argue that EMI is not generally helpful  
either in content learning or in English language proficiency (Lei & Hu, 2014).  
However, other researchers argue that the problem is with the teachers and the methodology of EMI  
implementation (Manan & Dumanig, 2015). The present study is focused on the problems teachers and students  
faced in teaching and learning through the medium of English. The paper explores the problems associated with  
its successful implementation at the primary level. As Shamim (2008) says there is a need to assess the effects  
of EMI on the students because only a limited number of empirical studies are available in Pakistan about the  
EMI impact on students’ learning.  
METHODOLOGY  
2.1.  
Research Design  
This study was conducted through a cross-sectional survey design. This design describes and explains events  
without manipulation of variables: only description of the actual status was required. The absence of  
manipulation makes a survey the ideal design (Oso, 2016). A survey was detailed study of a geographical area  
to collect data on attitudes impressions, opinions, satisfaction level, by polling a section of the population  
(Mukhtar, 2015). This design was chosen because it was cost efficient due to time and resources, than the  
alternative longitudinal design which would require more time due to repeated data collection at several points  
in time (Oso, 2016). The study used the cross-sectional survey methods research design to explore the influence  
English of medium instruction on student of secondary level in Awdal and M. Jeex District.  
District  
No. School Name  
Form One Form Two Form Three Form Four Total  
Hargiesa District  
1
2
3
4
5
M.A. Ali  
547  
597  
493  
312  
287  
2,236  
275  
192  
660  
636  
627  
113  
147  
2,183  
444  
247  
150  
28  
750  
535  
472  
241  
160  
2,158  
336  
308  
142  
32  
511  
331  
204  
187  
99  
2,468  
2,099  
1,796  
853  
26-Jun  
Gacan Libaax  
Farah Omar  
Dayib Guray  
693  
Sub-Total (Hargiesa)  
Borama District  
1,332  
199  
203  
86  
7,909  
1,254  
950  
1
2
3
4
5
Ubaya  
Aaden Isaak  
Sh. Ali Jawhar 133  
511  
H. Hadhiye  
Faatih  
27  
10  
97  
30  
91  
116  
934  
76  
313  
Sub-Total (Borama)  
GRAND TOTAL  
657  
960  
574  
3,125  
11,034  
Table 1 Distribution of the Student by district Both Borama and Hargeisa secondary schools  
2.2. Sample and Sampling  
The study sample was six district Secondary schools in Somaliland. So I would select Random two district  
secondary schools was Borama and Hargeisa district. However, the student and teacher populations of the district  
Borama and Hargeisa were borama 5 secondary schools and 9 secondary schools, thus the student of target are  
7,909 in Hargeisa urban district and 3,125 student target of borama urban district, the total target student  
enrolment of secondary schools both two district are 11,034 student. The teacher of target are 243 in Hargeisa  
urban district and 117 teacher target of borama urban district. Whether were the issue will be the used of non-  
probability sampling approaches such as convenience/availability sampling for survey respondent.  
2.3.  
Sample Size  
The sample of this study consisted of 186 teachers secondary schools in borama and Hargeisa urban district, the  
Page 1375  
sample consisted of 370 student’s secondary schools of borama and Hargeisa urban district.  
The sample was determined by the table developed by Krejcie and Morgan in (1970), which has been widely  
used to determine sample sizes of finite populations (Oso, 2016). It recommends for students secondary schools  
a population of 11,034 and teachers secondary schools a population of 620 sample size of student 370 and sample  
size of teacher 186, at the level of confidence 95%, and 5% of margin error. It was developed as a five-point  
Liker type rating scale, allowing the respondents to indicate whether they “Strongly Agree” (SA) = 5, “Agree”  
(A) = 5, “Normal” (N) = 3 “Disagree” (D) = 2 or “Strongly Disagree” (SDA) = 1 with the statements in the  
instrument. These were the same boundaries that the researcher has set for this study. Hence the samples of  
student 458 and teacher 150 are selected for this study according to the recommendations.  
2.4.  
Data Analysis  
After data collection the data was checked for completeness and the data was examined in phases. Data was  
processed using Excel data analysis software and SPSS software; descriptive statistics, such as frequency and  
relative frequency distributions (percentages), were generated and used to show statistics. Group Statistical  
significance was assessed at 95%.  
2.5.  
Ethical Considerations  
Authorization for the study was sought from National Commission for Higher Education with the department of  
Research. Further permission was secured from the ministry of education and science special department of  
formal education. Informed verbal consent will be sought from the students and teacher of secondary schools.  
Privacy and confidentiality will be maintained throughout the process of the study. Finally, the materials used  
for data collection was to be kept under key and lock and will only be accessed by the research.  
RESULTS AND FINDINGS  
4.1  
Introduction  
This study investigation at the data obtained will assist the influence English of medium instruction on student  
of secondary level. Where there are factors that influence the state of something or cause it to assume some state  
for a certain period of time. The main focus of this the study has investigated specific objectives; including, (i)  
the specialization of student secondary schools, the main of purpose learning (ii) the teaching for secondary  
schools, the main of purpose teaching. The sample of this study is designed was 370 respondents student then  
458 questionnaire collected 88 student respondents are external and 181 respondents of teachers for the public  
secondary schools located in Borama and Hargeisa district Somaliland. And their total makes them 150  
respondents and data was collected from the entire respondent. But 31 of the respondents were missing the same  
teacher of secondary schools in sample size. By a cross sectional survey study conducted during December 2022.  
As reported below.  
4.2.  
Background Information  
Background information, also known as Demographic Characteristics, has been collected from respondents to  
allow the researcher to determine whether the study is relevant to their) the study sample was 10 of both the  
Borama and Hargiesa District secondary schools in Somaliland. The study collected data on the background  
factors of the respondents in terms of gender, teaching experience and education qualification. Demographic  
characteristics data are summarized using a percentage and presented as a result of these following subsections.  
No Schools  
District  
Hargiesa  
Borama  
Hargiesa  
Borama  
Hargiesa  
Borama  
Target teacher  
Sample Size Teacher Sample Size Student  
1
2
3
4
5
6
26 June  
43  
25  
66  
30  
63  
26  
16  
13  
21  
13  
18  
14  
45  
43  
50  
41  
50  
44  
Aaden Isaak  
Gacan Libax  
Ubaya  
M. A. Ali  
Sh. Ali Jawhar  
Page 1376  
7
8
9
10  
Haji Hadhiye  
Faatih  
Dayib Guray  
Gaandi  
Borama  
Borama  
Hargiesa  
Hargiesa  
13  
23  
32  
39  
14  
12  
14  
15  
44  
45  
46  
50  
360.00  
150.00  
458.00  
Table 2 Distribution of the Respondents of Both Borama and Hargeisa schools teacher  
The questionnaires distributed to the study sample was 10 of both the Borama and Hargiesa District secondary  
schools in Somaliland. School’s 10 out of 5 secondary was Borama and 5 secondary school’s was Hargiesa,  
representing response secondary rate 66 teacher and 18.33% expressive was Gacan Libaax secondary school  
Hargiesa district.  
4.2.1 Distribution of the Respondents by Gender  
Respondents were asked to provide their gender; the issue of sex was necessary to determine the researcher if  
the sex for the teacher’s and student’s distribution of the respondents related to the study sample of was 10  
secondary schools both the Borama and Hargiesa District in Somaliland. The result obtained summarized in  
Figure 1.  
Teacher  
Student  
Male  
Female  
Male  
Female  
Frequency  
Percent  
127  
23  
210  
248  
84.70%  
15.30%  
46.00%  
54.00%  
Figure 1 Distribution of the Respondents by Gender  
Figure 1 displays the distribution of respondents in the study sample, consisting of 10 secondary schools in both  
Borama and Hargeisa Districts in Somaliland, categorized by teacher gender. It illustrates that the majority (127)  
of the respondents in secondary schools were males, while females comprised 23 teachers. This result indicates  
a higher presence of male teachers in secondary schools across Somaliland.  
Additionally, the figure also illustrates the distribution of student gender. It reveals that the majority of  
respondents in secondary schools were females (248), with males totaling 210 students. This outcome highlights  
a higher number of female students in secondary schools across Somaliland. Therefore, this research confirms  
the existence of a lower representation of female teachers compared to female students in secondary schools in  
Somaliland. This suggests an imbalance in gender representation, indicating the need for equitable deployment  
across educational institutions.  
4.2.2 Distribution of the Respondents by Level education of Student  
Respondents were asked to provide their student level education; the issue of class of student was necessary to  
determine the researcher if the class distribution of the respondents related to the study student sample of was  
10 secondary schools both the Borama and Hargiesa District in Somaliland. The result obtained summarized in  
Figure 2.  
Form I  
48  
10.50%  
Form II  
100  
21.80%  
Form III  
146  
32%  
Form IV  
164  
35.70%  
Frequency  
Percent  
Figure 2 Distribution of the Respondents by Age  
Figure 2 show the distribution of respondents by student’s level education. The researcher it shows that majority  
of the respondents student level of education (164) were class of student’s form four (IV). That secondly of the  
student level education respondents (146) were class of student’s form three (III). That third of the student level  
Page 1377  
education respondents (100) were class of student’s form two (II).While the lowest of the student level education  
respondents (48) were class of student’s form one (I).  
4.2.3 Distribution of the Respondents by Age of Student  
Respondents were asked to provide their age student; the issue of years of student was necessary to determine  
the researcher if the age distribution of the respondents related to the study student sample of was 10 secondary  
schools both the Borama and Hargiesa District in Somaliland. The result obtained summarized in Figure 3.  
13 - 18 Yrs.  
347  
75.80%  
19 - 24 Yrs.  
75  
16.20%  
20 -27 Yrs.  
25  
6%  
28 Above Yrs.  
11  
2%  
Frequency  
Percent  
Figure 3 Distribution of the Respondents by Age  
Figure 3 show the distribution of respondents by student’s age. The researcher selected the sample of student’s  
age mostly less than 28 years. It shows that majority of the respondents age (347) were age of student’s 13 - 18  
years. That secondly of the student respondents age (75) were age of student’s 19 -24 years. While the lowest of  
the student respondents age (11) were age of student’s 28 above years.  
4.2.4 Distribution of the Respondents by Experience  
Respondents were asked to provide their experience; the issue of years of teaching was necessary to determine  
the researcher if the experience distribution of the respondents related to the study teachers sample of was 10  
secondary schools both the Borama and Hargiesa District in Somaliland. The result obtained summarized in  
Figure 4.  
1- 5 yrs.  
30  
20.00%  
6-10 yrs.  
42  
28.00%  
11-20 yrs.  
42  
28%  
21 above yrs.  
36  
24%  
Frequency  
Percent  
Figure 4 Distribution of the Respondents by Experience  
Figure 4 show the distribution of respondents by teacher’s experience. The researcher selected the sample of  
experienced mostly less than 21 years of teacher’s. It shows that mostly of the respondents experience (42) were  
year of experience teacher’s 6 - 10 and 11 – 20 years. While the lowest of the respondent’s teacher experience  
ware (30) foe the 1 - 5 years. This study revealed that secondary school teachers have the knowledge and  
experience to teach, but they need to be taken care of in terms of salary.  
4.2.5 Distribution of the Respondents by Qualification  
Respondents were asked to provide their qualification; the issue of background education of teaching was  
necessary to determine the researcher if the qualification distribution of the respondents related to the study  
teachers sample of was 10 secondary schools both the Borama and Hargiesa District in Somaliland. The result  
obtained summarized in Figure 5.  
Diploma  
10  
7.00%  
Minor Degree  
11  
7.00%  
Major Degree  
74  
49%  
Master  
55  
37%  
Frequency  
Percent  
Figure 5 Distribution of the Respondents by Experience  
Figure 5, depicts the level of education of respondents. It shows that majority (49%) of the respondents 74 were  
have degree level education with the specialization subject to teaching. While the lowest (7%) of the respondents  
10 were have diploma level education with to teaching subject. According to the content of this lesson, in the  
section on the level of teacher knowledge, it has come out that the majority of teachers have a level of knowledge  
Page 1378  
that university level, and it has come out that the teachers in the secondary schools are the ones who have the  
knowledge of the subject they are teaching.  
4.3  
Language Using on Class  
The first hypothesis regarding demographic characteristics was that important language using on class of  
secondary schools both the Borama and Hargiesa District in Somaliland. To test the hypothesis, the teacher  
language using in class significantly explores the students of secondary schools. To verify whether differences  
in language and teacher and student using in class, ANOVA was done and the results presented.  
Table 3 language using on class  
Answer Majority  
Student’s (Somali)  
Teacher’s (Yes)  
Sample size  
266  
Sample mean  
1.42  
Sample SD  
0.49  
T
P
Decision  
38.6 0.00  
Reject Ho  
144  
1.96  
0.19  
Student’s Question  
Which language do teachers of other subjects use?  
Somali  
English  
266  
192  
Teacher’s Question  
Do you speak in mother tongue in class?  
Yes  
No  
144  
6
The result in Table 3 showed that on average, teacher’s secondary school sample mean (1.96) The teachers of  
secondary schools mostly speaking in mother tongue in class than their student’s secondary school study sample  
mean (1.42) counterparts. However, student’s and teacher’s (t = 38.6) was bigger because the probability or level  
of significant (p = 0. 0.00) was the smaller then α = 0.05 (p<0.00). The null hypothesis is rejecting or falsa.  
Hence there are significant linear relationships between the while teacher’s secondary school result questionnaire  
and student questionnaire. Which means that the teacher uses two languages such as Somali and English during  
the class.  
4.4  
Switch Language on Class  
The first hypothesis regarding demographic characteristics was that important switch language using on class of  
secondary schools both the Borama and Hargiesa District in Somaliland. To test the hypothesis, the teacher  
switch language using in class significantly explores the students of secondary schools. To verify whether  
differences in switch language on teacher using in class, ANOVA was done and the results presented.  
Table 4 Switch Language on Class  
Answer Majority  
Student’s (Yes)  
Teacher’s (Yes)  
Sample size  
370  
Sample mean  
1.80  
Sample SD  
0.39  
T
P
Decision  
18.38 0.00  
Reject Ho  
114  
1.81  
0.42  
Student’s Question  
Do teachers switch language during presentation in the class?  
Yes  
No  
370  
88  
Teacher’s Question  
Page 1379  
Do teachers switch language during the teaching-learning process?  
Yes  
No  
114  
36  
The result in Table 4 showed that on average, teacher’s secondary school sample mean (1.81)  
The teachers of secondary schools mostly switch language during the teaching learning process than their  
student’s secondary school study sample mean (1.80) counterparts. However, student’s and teacher’s (t = 18.38)  
was bigger because the probability or level of significant (p = 0. 0.00) was the smaller then α = 0.05 (p<0.00).  
The null hypothesis is rejecting or false. Hence are significant linear relationships between the while teachers  
and students of secondary school to agree switch language during the teaching learning process two language  
such as Somali and English. That shows the use of switching language is common in the high schools of the  
country, due to common paricaties of teachers to use more in Somali language.  
4.5  
Student Performance on English Language  
The first hypothesis regarding demographic characteristics was that important student performance on English  
language of secondary schools both the Borama and Hargiesa District in Somaliland. To test the hypothesis, the  
teacher English language using in class significantly explores the students’ performance of secondary schools.  
To verify whether differences in language on teacher using in learning process, ANOVA was done and the results  
presented.  
Table 5 Student Performance on English Language  
Answer Majority  
Student’s (SA/A)  
Teacher’s (SA/A)  
Sample size  
287  
Sample mean  
3.66  
Sample SD  
1.40  
T
P
Decision  
10.87 0.00  
Reject Ho  
100  
3.68  
1.29  
Student’s Question  
Teacher’s use of mother tongue affects student’s performance in English?  
SA/A  
N
287  
71  
DA/SDA  
100  
Teacher’s Question  
Use of mother tongue influences performance in English?  
SA/A  
N
100  
16  
DA/SDA  
34  
The result in Table 5 showed that on average, teacher’s secondary school sample mean (3.68) The teacher’s use  
teaching learning process of mother tongue mostly effects student’s performance in English for the secondary  
schools than their student’s secondary school study sample mean (3.66) counterparts. However, student’s and  
teacher’s (t = 10.87) was bigger because the probability or level of significant (p = 0. 0.00) was the smaller then  
α = 0.05 (p<0.00). The null hypothesis is rejecting or falsa. Hence there are significant linear relationships  
between the while teacher’s using during the teaching learning process English while the student English  
language performance as well.  
4.6  
Student use mother tongue on perform poorly English Language  
The first hypothesis regarding demographic characteristics was that important student use mother tongue on  
perform poorly English language of secondary schools both the Borama and Hargiesa District in Somaliland. To  
test the hypothesis, the student use mother tongue significantly explores perform poorly English language of  
Page 1380  
secondary schools. To verify whether differences in language on student’s using in learning process, ANOVA  
was done and the results presented.  
Table 6 Student use mother tongue on perform poorly English Language  
Answer Majority  
Student’s (SA/A)  
Teacher’s (SA/A)  
Sample size  
266  
Sample mean  
3.52  
Sample SD  
1.45  
T
P
Decision  
13.53 0.00  
Reject Ho  
108  
3.80  
1.39  
Student’s Question  
Students who use mother tongue perform poorly in English?  
SA/A  
N
266  
76  
DA/SDA  
116  
Teacher’s Question  
Students who use mother tongue perform poorly in English?  
SA/A  
N
108  
13  
DA/SDA  
31  
The result in Table 6 showed that on average, teacher’s secondary school sample mean (3.80) The teacher’s  
majority to support the student use mother tongue during learning process to perform poorly in English for the  
secondary level than their student’s secondary school study sample mean (3.52) counterparts. However, student’s  
and teacher’s (t = 13.53) was bigger because the probability or level of significant (p = 0. 0.00) was the smaller  
then α = 0.05 (p<0.00). The null hypothesis is rejecting or falsa. Hence there are significant linear relationships  
between the while student and teacher for secondary schools. The teacher and student’s, while they agree on that  
the student use mother tongue during learning process the language of English are very poorly. But the student  
use English language during learning process the performance of English as well.  
4.7  
Student Performance on Adequate Supplementary  
The first hypothesis regarding demographic characteristics was that important student performance on adequate  
supplementary material of secondary schools both the Borama and Hargiesa District in Somaliland. To test the  
hypothesis, the adequate supplementary materials significantly explores student performance English language  
of secondary level. To verify whether differences the teacher and student using in learning process, ANOVA  
was done and the results presented.  
Table 7 Student performance on adequate supplementary  
Answer Majority  
Student’s (SA/A)  
Teacher’s (SA/A)  
Sample size  
Sample mean  
3.61  
Sample SD  
1.34  
T
P
Decision  
274  
74  
11.77 0.00  
Reject Ho  
3.36  
1.30  
Student’s Question  
There are adequate supplementary reading books in the school?  
SA/A  
N
274  
89  
DA/SDA  
95  
Teacher’s Question  
Page 1381  
There are adequate supplementary reading material in the library?  
SA/A  
N
74  
34  
42  
DA/SDA  
The result in Table 7 showed that on average, student’s secondary school study sample mean (3.61) The student’s  
majority to support the needing adequate supplementary materials in library during learning process in English  
performance for the secondary level than their teacher’s secondary school sample mean (3.36) counterparts.  
However, student’s and teacher’s (t = 11.77) was bigger because the probability or level of significant (p = 0.  
0.00) was the smaller then α = 0.05 (p<0.00). The null hypothesis is rejecting or falsa. Hence there are significant  
linear relationships between student and teacher for secondary schools, while they agree on that the student  
needing adequate supplementary materials in library during learning process to encourage English performance.  
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS  
5.1  
Conclusion  
Based on the results of the study, it can be concluded that the influence of English as the medium of instruction  
on secondary-level students in Borama and Hargeisa, Somaliland, faces challenges related to teaching methods,  
teacher presentations, student understanding during the learning process, and the availability of adequate  
supplementary materials such as reading material in the library. Additionally, factors such as teaching gender,  
qualifications, and experience contribute to these challenges. Considering that the study location is  
predominantly urban with access to English language medium learning, these identified challenges are crucial  
for mediating effective teaching and learning of English as a second language.  
This study revealed that a majority of teachers found it challenging to provide effective English-medium  
instruction in the classroom environment. The results showed that there were more male teachers than female  
teachers in secondary schools in Borama and Hargeisa districts, and similarly, female students outnumbered  
male students in these schools. The study also indicated that teachers with more experience (11 to 21 years) and  
higher educational qualifications, including university-level degrees, specializations, and master's or bachelor's  
degrees, were more knowledgeable in subject teaching at the secondary level. However, addressing salary  
concerns for these experienced teachers is essential.  
The hypothesis regarding demographic characteristics focused on the significant use of language in secondary  
schools in both the Borama and Hargeisa Districts in Somaliland. To test this hypothesis, the study explored the  
language used by teachers in class and its impact on secondary school students. The results showed that teachers  
and students mostly agreed during presentations, where teachers alternated between Somali and English in the  
class environment. However, the study also revealed that using the mother tongue during the teaching-learning  
process and communication negatively affected students' English performance. Therefore, providing adequate  
supplementary materials in the library during the learning process and encouraging English performance through  
homework and study sessions are crucial steps to improve English proficiency.  
5.2  
Recommendations  
In reference to the conclusion presented in Section 5.1, the researcher has provided the following general and  
specific recommendations. One of the most crucial issues in schools is to ensure the provision of sufficient  
education of appropriate quality and quantity.  
The Ministry of Education and Science of Somaliland should issue a decree requiring secondary school teachers  
who teach subjects in a foreign language, such as English, to refrain from using their mother tongue during the  
teaching-learning process in the classroom and within the school environment. The English language proficiency  
of teachers should be strengthened through knowledge enhancement and training, with regular evaluation and  
follow-up to ensure effectiveness since teachers significantly influence the learning outcomes of secondary  
school students in Somaliland.  
Page 1382  
All secondary school teachers should undergo training to provide an English medium instruction environment  
to secondary-level students. The training program should also include testing and evaluation skills using English  
medium instruction. To effectively implement English medium instruction at the secondary level, teachers  
should receive training in all four skills of the English language, with a particular focus on improving speaking  
skills.  
Guidelines should be developed to assist secondary-level teachers in teaching through English medium  
instruction. Both pre-service and in-service training should be provided for English medium education, and  
entry-level qualifications should be enhanced to recruit competent teachers for English medium instruction.  
Furthermore, efforts should be made to improve the academic qualifications of these teachers through capacity-  
building workshops and training programs. A new recruitment criterion for new teachers should include an  
official benchmark for language proficiency.  
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS  
First, I would like to thank to Allah who made the completion of this task possible. Firstly and lastly, all thanks  
go to Him. Without the help of Allah, this research project would not be accomplished successfully. The  
participation of numerous individuals, groups, and organizations/institutions who were involved in one way or  
another made this study feasible. The Director department of research of National Commission for Higher  
Education Somaliland (NCHE) owes them all a debt of gratitude and wishes to thank them for their contributions.  
First foremost of all thanks, teacher and student to learning/teaching the secondary schools in both two district  
of Hargiesa and Borama Somaliland.  
I acknowledge the Republic of Somaliland's special National Commission for Higher Education, for allowing  
team’s access to the places where data was collected and budget. Because of your thorough planning, you were  
able to contact and, when feasible, connect with the respondents who contributed the study's data. Above all, my  
deepest appreciation also goes out to the numerous people who participated in the study as responders. First and  
foremost, thank you to all of the grads who completed questionnaires and/or took part in the research. Without  
them, the research would not go further. All thanks go to anyone who has contributed the completion of this  
research project, directly or indirectly.  
REFERENCE  
1 Abdi, A. A. (1998). Education in Somalia: History, destruction, and calls for reconstruction.  
Comparative Education, 34(3), 327-340.  
2 Cassanelli, L., & Abdikadir, F. S. (2007). Somalia: Education in transition. Bildhaan, 7(1), 91-125.  
3 Dakers, J. (2011). Activity theory as a pedagogical framework for the delivery of technology education.  
In M. Barak, & M. Hacker (Eds,), Fostering human development through engineering and technology  
549-9_2  
4 Kim, J. (2011). Relationships among motivation, contextual factors, and achievement in on-offline  
blended English writing class. English Language & Literature Teaching, 17(4), 97-122.  
5 Krejcie and Morgan in (1970),  
6 Lei, J., & Hu, G. (2014). Is English-medium instruction effective in improving Chinese undergraduate  
students’ English competence? International Review of Applied Linguistics in Language Teaching,  
7 Mansoor, S. (2004). The medium of instruction dilemma: Implications for language planning in higher  
education. In S. Mansoor, S. Meraj, & A. Tahir (Eds.), Language policy, planning, & practice: A South  
Asian perspective. Karachi: Agha Khan University.  
8 ME&S, 2020, Ministry of Education and Science of Somaliland, Early Childhood Education Policy  
and Institutional Framework.  
9 Moh’ed, 2017, Ministry of Education and higher Education of Somaliland, annual report of 1991 to  
2017 years  
10 Mustafa, Z. (2011). Tyranny of language in education, the problems, and its solutions. Karachi: Ushba  
Publishing International.  
Page 1383  
11 Mustafa, Z. (2013). Parents' choices of language as the medium of instruction in schools. ASER.  
12 Mustafa, Z. (2020). Which language? Retrieved from  
13 Oso W. Y., (2016). Social science research principles and practice. Nairobi, Kenya: Jomo Kenyatta  
foundation.  
14 Rahman, T. (1996). Language and politics in Pakistan. Karachi: Oxford University Press.  
15 Rashid, A., Muzaffar, I., Butt, S., Awan, A. A., & Bashiruddin, A. (2013). Policy & Practice: Teaching  
and Learning English in Punjab Schools. Lahore: Society for Advancement of Education (SAHE).  
16 Rassool, N., & Mansoor. S. (2007). Contemporary issues in language, education, and development in  
Pakistan. In N. Rassool (Ed.), Global issues in language, education, and development: Perspectives  
from postcolonial countries. (pp. 218-244). Clevedon: Multilingual Matters.  
17 Saeed, A., Iqbal, T., & Azam, R. (2012). Perceptions of Teachers regarding English Medium  
Instructions at Secondary education in Punjab Province of Pakistan. Secondary Education Journal,  
1(1): 41-53  
18 Savery, J. R. (2006). Overview of problem based learning: Definitions and distinctions. The  
Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem-Based Learning, 1(1), 9-20. http://dx.doi.org/10.7771/1541-  
19 Shamim, F. (2008). Trends, issues, and challenges in English language education in Pakistan. Asia  
Pacific Journal of Education 28(3), 235-249.  
Page 1384