INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI |Volume XII Issue XI November 2025
Page 1496
www.rsisinternational.org
Sustainable Maintenance Management for Air Conditioning Systems
in Malaysian Shopping Complexes
Mohamad Haszirul Mohd Hashim
1*
, Nurul Izza Abdul Ghani
2*
, Syanaz Binti Nasar
3
1
Program of Building Surveying, Faculty of Built Enviroment, Universiti Teknologi MARA, Perak
Branch
2
Department of Civil Engineering, Politeknik Ungku Omar
2
Property Management Executive, Neighbourhood Property Management Sdn Bhd
*
Corresponding Author
DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.51244/IJRSI.2025.12110133
Received: 04 November 2025; Accepted: 12 November 2025; Published: 18 December 2025
ABSTRACT
Maintenance is a combination of several management methods without changing the basic features and
functions of service systems. Effective maintenance planning ensures optimal use of the structure and reduces
operating costs. This study investigates sustainable maintenance management practices for air conditioning
systems at shopping complexes, focusing on tenant satisfaction and overall building performance involving
forty (40) tenants representing diverse business categories such as retail, food and beverage (F&B), services,
and entertainment. Data were gathered through structured questionnaires assessing satisfaction with
maintenance work, air conditioning supply, and the relationship between these factors and business operations.
The findings reveal that 55 percent of tenants expressed moderate to high satisfaction with maintenance work,
while 60 percent were satisfied with the overall air conditioning supply and cooling performance. Retail and
F&B tenants recorded higher sensitivity to cooling quality due to the direct influence on customer comfort and
product conditions. The study concludes that adopting preventive and condition-based maintenance practices
can significantly enhance system reliability, tenant comfort, and energy efficiency. Recommendations are
proposed to establish a sustainable maintenance framework that integrates real-time monitoring, timely
scheduling, and continuous feedback mechanisms to optimize air conditioning system performance and
prolong equipment lifespan.
Keyword: Air Conditioning, Maintenance Management, Tenant Satisfaction, Sustainable Building, Shopping
Complex
INTRODUCTION
Air conditioning systems play a vital role in ensuring indoor comfort and supporting business operations in
tropical countries such as Malaysia, where high temperature and humidity levels are consistent throughout the
year. Shopping complexes depend heavily on these systems to provide an optimal environment for both tenants
and visitors. However, challenges related to maintenance management often lead to inefficiencies, such as
inconsistent cooling, higher energy consumption, and dissatisfied tenants.
In Malaysia, most maintenance activities within shopping complexes are reactive or based on fixed schedules
without proper monitoring or sustainability consideration (Mohamad Haszirul Mohd Hashim 2021). This
traditional approach often results in increased operating costs and reduced system efficiency (Hashim and
Ghani 2017.).
Sustainable maintenance management, on the other hand, emphasizes preventive and predictive strategies that
minimize energy usage while maximizing reliability and comfort. Maintenance is defined as a continuous
process carried out without altering the basic features and functions of a building system after its construction
is completed (Chong et al. 2019). Maintenance management integrates various activities to ensure that the
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI |Volume XII Issue XI November 2025
Page 1497
www.rsisinternational.org
building components and systems remain in optimal condition. However, some maintenance activities are
unpredictable and may involve certain risks (Ghani, Hashim, and Zamani 2023).
Maintenance Inspection
Sustainable maintenance management has emerged as a key approach in building operations, particularly in
energy-intensive systems such as air conditioning. According to (Simpeh et al. 2022), HVAC systems can
account for up to 60 percent of total energy consumption in commercial buildings, highlighting the importance
of effective maintenance. A well-managed maintenance system ensures not only the reliability of mechanical
performance but also contributes to sustainability through energy optimization and reduced carbon emissions.
Maintenance management strategies generally fall into four categories: reactive maintenance, preventive
maintenance, predictive maintenance, and condition-based maintenance (CBM). Sustainable maintenance
integrates these approaches by emphasizing preventive actions supported by data-driven decision-making to
enhance system performance while considering economic and environmental factors (Olanrewaju, Tan, and
Soh 2022).
Tenant satisfaction is another critical indicator of building management effectiveness. Previous research by
(Nasar and Mohd Hashim 2023) demonstrated that comfort level, temperature stability, and response time to
maintenance issues significantly influence overall tenant satisfaction. Sustainable maintenance frameworks
often incorporate user feedback as part of continuous improvement mechanisms to ensure service quality
aligns with occupant expectations (Grum 2017).
The primary objective of this study is to develop a sustainable maintenance management framework for air
conditioning systems in Malaysian shopping complexes. This research seeks to identify the current
maintenance practices employed in these facilities and to evaluate their effectiveness in terms of energy
efficiency, operational reliability, and environmental sustainability. Furthermore, the study aims to determine
the key challenges and barriers that hinder the adoption of sustainable maintenance strategies within the
Malaysian shopping complex context. By analyzing existing maintenance models and performance indicators,
the study also intends to propose practical recommendations and best practices that can enhance energy
efficiency, reduce maintenance costs, and minimize environmental impact. Ultimately, this research aspires to
contribute to the advancement of sustainable facility management by promoting responsible and cost-effective
maintenance of air conditioning systems in large commercial buildings. This research focuses on major
shopping complex to evaluate current maintenance management practices related to its air conditioning
systems. The study aims to assess tenant satisfaction levels regarding maintenance work and cooling supply,
analyze the influence of business type on satisfaction levels, and propose strategies for more sustainable
maintenance management in similar facilities. Despite various studies on building maintenance, limited
research has specifically explored sustainable maintenance practices for air conditioning systems in Malaysian
shopping complexes. This study addresses that gap by linking maintenance performance, energy efficiency,
and tenant satisfaction within a local case context.
METHODOLOGY
This research adopted a case study approach focusing on Angsana Ipoh Mall to gain a detailed understanding
of the maintenance management system in an operational environment. Quantitative data were collected
through structured questionnaires distributed to 40 tenants. The questionnaire was divided into three main
sections: tenant background, satisfaction with maintenance work, and satisfaction with air conditioning supply.
Tenants represented various business categories including retail, food and beverage (F&B), services, and
entertainment. Each respondent evaluated their satisfaction using a five-point Likert scale ranging from Very
Dissatisfied” (1) to “Very Satisfied” (5). Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics to identify trends and
levels of satisfaction across different business types. The case study design was selected to provide real-world
insights into maintenance performance and its impact on tenant comfort. The findings are therefore intended to
inform practical strategies for implementing sustainable maintenance management practices in similar
commercial settings across Malaysia.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI |Volume XII Issue XI November 2025
Page 1498
www.rsisinternational.org
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Tenant Profile
The study involved 40 tenants across four main business categories: 20.5 percent were retail-based (such as
clothing, convenience stores, and accessories), 29.5 percent were food and beverage outlets, 31.8 percent were
service-related businesses such as salons and financial service providers, and 13.6 percent were sales. Retail
tenants formed the majority, highlighting their dependence on reliable cooling systems for customer comfort
and merchandise preservation.
Figure 1 : Tenant Profile
Tenant Satisfaction with Maintenance Work
The results revealed that 9.1 percent of respondents were very satisfied with the mall’s maintenance services,
40.9 percent rated their satisfaction as moderate, while 11.4 percent were dissatisfied and 31.8 percent were
very dissatisfied. Overall, approximately 56.8 percent of tenants expressed positive satisfaction toward
maintenance work, suggesting that the mall’s maintenance team performs adequately but with room for
improvement.
Figure 2 : Tenant Satisfaction with Maintenance Work
Some tenants reported delays in repair response, particularly during peak operational hours. This finding
implies that while preventive maintenance is implemented, reactive practices are still common, causing
temporary discomfort and operational inconvenience. Sustainable maintenance should thus include better
scheduling, manpower allocation, and real-time monitoring to minimize such occurrences.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI |Volume XII Issue XI November 2025
Page 1499
www.rsisinternational.org
Tenant Satisfaction with Air Conditioning Supply
Regarding the performance of air conditioning supply, 9.1 percent of tenants indicated they were very
satisfied, another 13.6 percent were satisfied, 29.5 percent rated it as moderate, 11.4 percent were dissatisfied,
and 36.4 percent were very dissatisfied. This means that 52.2 percent of the tenants were generally satisfied
with the mall’s cooling system.
Figure 3: Tenant Satisfaction with Air Conditioning Supply
Retail and F&B tenants showed higher sensitivity toward cooling quality compared to other business types.
This is because their business performance and customer comfort directly depend on consistent temperature
control. Some food tenants also noted that insufficient cooling affected product freshness and indoor comfort
levels.
These results suggest that air conditioning performance significantly influences tenant satisfaction and
potentially business profitability. Sustainable maintenance efforts that ensure consistent cooling performance
can therefore enhance both tenant retention and operational sustainability.
Relationship Between Maintenance and Tenant Satisfaction
A positive correlation (r = 0.63) was observed between satisfaction with maintenance work and satisfaction
with air conditioning supply. This relationship indicates that timely, effective maintenance practices directly
contribute to improved perception of air conditioning reliability. When tenants experience quick responses and
effective problem resolution, their confidence in building management increases, leading to higher satisfaction
levels overall.
Energy Performance
Energy data obtained from building management records showed that the air conditioning system consumed
approximately 55% of the mall’s total monthly electricity usage, equivalent to 430,000 kWh/month.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI |Volume XII Issue XI November 2025
Page 1500
www.rsisinternational.org
Sustainable Maintenance Recommendations
To achieve sustainable maintenance performance, several strategies are recommended based on the case study
findings. First, the adoption of condition-based maintenance using sensor monitoring could allow real-time
detection of temperature deviations and energy inefficiencies. Second, preventive maintenance schedules
should be optimized according to system usage patterns rather than fixed intervals. Third, tenant feedback
should be systematically recorded through digital platforms to ensure transparency and accountability. In
addition, regular energy audits and calibration of cooling systems should be conducted to minimize energy
wastage. Finally, continuous training for maintenance personnel is essential to promote awareness of
sustainability and operational excellence.
CONCLUSION
This study concludes that sustainable maintenance management plays a crucial role in enhancing air
conditioning system performance and tenant satisfaction in Malaysian shopping complexes. The findings from
Angsana Ipoh Mall indicate that while most tenants are moderately satisfied with current maintenance services,
there are clear opportunities for improvement through the integration of preventive and condition-based
maintenance strategies.
Sustainable practices such as real-time monitoring, feedback systems, and scheduled inspections can reduce
downtime, optimize energy consumption, and extend the lifespan of air conditioning equipment. More
importantly, such practices contribute to creating a comfortable indoor environment that supports business
continuity and customer satisfaction. The study therefore recommends that shopping complexes in Malaysia
adopt a structured sustainable maintenance framework to align building management with long-term energy
and comfort goals.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Chong, Alan Kim Wing, Abdul Hakim Mohammed, Mat Naim Abdullah, and Mohd Shahril Abdul
Rahman. 2019. “Maintenance Prioritization--a Review on Factors and Methods.” Journal of Facilities
Management 17(1): 1839.
2. Ghani, Nurul Izza Abdul, Mohamad Haszirul Mohd Hashim, and Wan Samsul Zamani. 2023.
“Literature Review on Problem of Defect Assessment Inspection for Building Maintenance
Management Planning.” Architecture 11(5): 227984.
3. Grum, Bojan Bojan. 2017. Impact of Facilities Maintenance on User Satisfaction.” Facilities 35(7/8):
40521.
4. Hashim, Sr Mohamad Haszirul Mohd, and Nurul Izza Abdul Ghani. Pendekatan Pembangunan Garis
Panduan Yang Seragam Dalam Penyenggaraan Bangunan.”
5. Mohamad Haszirul Mohd Hashim, Mohamad Haszirul. 2021. Pembangunan Komponen Penilaian
Pemeriksaan Kecacatan Bumbung Curam Untuk Bangunan Sekolah Di Malaysia.” Universiti Malaya.
6. Nasar, Syanaz, and Mohamad Haszirul Mohd Hashim. 2023. “Tenant Satisfaction Level on Air
Conditioning Performance at Shopping Mall.” In E-Proceeding 6th Undergraduate Seminar on Built
Environment and Technology (USBET) 2023, , 115667.
7. Olanrewaju, AbdulLateef, Yien Yen Tan, and See Ning Soh. 2022. Defect Characterisations in the
Malaysian Affordable Housing.” International Journal of Building Pathology and Adaptation 40(4):
53968.
8. Simpeh, Eric Kwame, Jon-Patrick George Pillay, Ruben Ndihokubwayo, and Dorothy Julian Nalumu.
2022. Improving Energy Efficiency of HVAC Systems in Buildings: A Review of Best Practices.”
International Journal of Building Pathology and Adaptation 40(2): 16582.