INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2347
www.rsisinternational.org
Factors Affecting Uptake of Tetanus Toxoid Vaccine among Women
of Childbearing Age in Low-And-Middle-Income Countries: A
Systematic Review
*Tarimobowei Egberipou
1,4,5
, Sylva Ligeiaziba
2
, Charles Tobin-West
3
1
School of Public Health, University of Port Harcourt, Rivers State, Nigeria
2
Department of Statistics, Bayelsa Medical University, Yenagoa, Bayelsa State, Nigeria
3
Department of Preventive and Social Medicine, University of Port Harcourt, Rivers State, Nigeria
4
Department of Public Health, Bayelsa Medical University, Yenagoa, Bayelsa State, Nigeria
5
Department of Medical and Dental Services, Hospitals Management Board, Yenagoa, Bayelsa State,
Nigeria
*Corresponding Author
DOI: https://doi.org/10.51244/IJRSI.2025.1215PH000173
Received: 04 October 2025; Accepted: 10 October 2025; Published: 08 November 2025
ABSTRACT
Tetanus is a life-threatening infection caused by Clostridium tetani, particularly affecting high-risk groups in
low- and middle-income countries in sub-Saharan Africa, Africa, and Asia. This is often due to unhygienic
birth practices. Vaccination with tetanus toxoid-containing vaccine during and around pregnancy provides
protection. A literature review from 1995 to 2024 was conducted in PubMed/MEDLINE, African Journals
Online, and Google Scholar following PRISMA guidelines to identify relevant publications. Thirteen studies
met the inclusion criteria and were assessed for evidence quality using an expanded PRISMA checklist. The
studies identified key factors influencing poor vaccination uptake among women of childbearing age,
including age(25-35years: AOR; 0.510-0.925), marital status (Married: AOR; 0.400-1.038), parity (3-4
Children: AOR; 0.200-5.050), antenatal care visits (Four or more: AOR; 0.048-1.710), place of delivery
(Health facility: AOR; 1.130-23.380), distance to health facilities (<30 minutes: AOR;1.050-4.600), media
exposure (Yes: AOR;1.968-2.820), wealth index (Rich: AOR; 0.630-7.230 or poor), educational level
(Secondary: AOR; 0.600-6.200), and knowledge of tetanus and the vaccine (Yes: AOR; 0.900-3.450). Health
education, engagement of women, and targeted vaccination of high-risk groups are essential strategies to
improve vaccination rates.
Index terms: Tetanus toxoid containing vaccine, women of childbearing age, Low-and-Middle-Income-
Countries.
INTRODUCTION
Tetanus, is often a life-threatening infection, characteristically presenting with muscle spasms and nervous
dysfunction, due to the impregnation of wounds with the bacterium Clostridium Tetani [2], [4], [8], [9], [23].
Though it can affect all age groups, neonates and pregnant women, in countries typically located in the global
south, are at greater risk of infection especially due to unhygienic practices during delivery and/or confinement
at birth [1] - [3].
It is a commonly diagnosed affectation of these groups in countries designated as “high risk”, by the World
Health Organization. These countries, such as Nigeria, are mostly Low-and-Middle-Income countries in sub-
Saharan Africa, Africa, and Asia where tetanus remains mostly under-reported and a menace [23]. This
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2348
www.rsisinternational.org
situation is reported to be mainly due to poor information on the disease, low level of education among women
and sundry groups, home deliveries, and unskilled attendance during confinement. Other commonly adduced
reasons include poor access to health care and/or facilities, limited access to antenatal care in and around
pregnancy, and poor health information management systems [23].
However, vaccination with the tetanus toxoid-containing vaccine in and around pregnancy is considered a
veritable and effective protective measure against the disease [2], [23]. In this regard, therefore, the expert
advice is that to protect against tetanus, before, during, and after pregnancy or childbirth, women of
childbearing age and pregnant women should take several doses of the tetanus toxoid vaccine based on an
internationally prescribed schedule [6], [22], [23]. To this end, it is recommended that a total of five tetanus
toxoid vaccine doses be administered to previously unimmunized persons or those with questionable
immunization status [5] [7], [22], [23].
In consonance thereof, it is surmised that protection against tetanus in women of childbearing age and neonates
is guaranteed if women of childbearing age or pregnant women receive at least two doses of tetanus toxoid-
containing vaccine with the last dose being within the last three years; three doses of tetanus toxoid containing
vaccine with the last dose being within the last five years; four doses of tetanus toxoid containing vaccine with
the last dose being within the last ten years; or receive at least five doses or greater of tetanus toxoid containing
vaccine through the course of their lives [10], [22], [23].
Specifically, vaccination with tetanus toxoid-containing vaccine has been volunteered as being responsible for
the marked decrease in mortality from the disease over the course of the twenty years spanning the period 1990
to 2019, particularly in Low-and-Middle Income countries of sub-Saharan Africa where unwholesome delivery
practices largely define confinement at birth [9], [10], [23]. This is especially informative and demanding of
action or mitigation as the target date for elimination of tetanus in these climes, following the World Health
Assembly declaration for elimination of the disease, has been missed on three occasions; specifically, the years
1995, 2005, and 2015 [21].
Therefore, the foregoing considerations give impetus for this study which aims to interrogate the factors
affecting the uptake of tetanus toxoid-containing vaccines among women of child-bearing age in Low-and-
Middle Countries, using sub-Saharan Africa as a focal point, with a view to improving, significantly, the
coverage of target group vaccinations. This is more so as attempts at the elimination of maternal and neonatal
tetanus in low-and-middle-income-countries have focused mostly on targeted vaccination of women of
childbearing age and/or pregnant women.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Search strategy
A systematic approach was used to conduct the literature review in PubMed/MEDLINE and African Journals
Online databases, following PRISMA guidelines, to identify publications on factors affecting the uptake of
tetanus toxoid vaccine among women of childbearing age in Low-and-Middle-Income countries spanning the
period 1995 to 2024. Manual bibliographic searches for relevant papers, as well as searches on Google, Google
Scholar, and other journal hosting sites, were also carried out. These revealed studies in the grey literature.
The keywords and/or MeSH terms for the literature search did include the following: Determinants” OR
“factors” AND associated with” OR “influencing” OR affecting” OR contributing toAND utilization”
OR “uptake” AND “tetanus toxoid” OR “vaccine AND “reproductive age women OR “women of
Childbearing age” OR “young adult women” AND underdeveloped” OR developing” OR “Low- and-
Middle- Income Countries”.
The search was conducted for the aforementioned time frame to elucidate the critical issues bedevilling the
effort of the World Health Organization (WHO), governments, and partners in the elimination of maternal and
neonatal tetanus in low-and-middle-income countries especially those classified as high risk. See the PRISMA
diagram (Figure 1) below.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2349
www.rsisinternational.org
Quality of Evidence
Using the expanded PRISMA checklist (2020), an overall assessment of the quality of evidence, of selected
studies, as well as compliance with the same was carried out by indicating ‘Yes’ and “No’ answers to the
interrogations and /or requirements, in the designated areas of inquiry derived therefrom, for quality of
evidence viz: Usefulness and relevance of study (Title, abstract, introduction), appropriateness of and
assessment of summary outcomes (methodology), incisiveness and specificity of findings (results, analysis,
and reporting), results use and decision modelling (discussion and findings). For a complete presentation see
Table 1 below.
Inclusion Criteria
Key articles reporting factors affecting the uptake of tetanus toxoid vaccine among women of childbearing age
in Low-and-Middle-Income-Countries were included based on the following criteria:
1. Original studies published in English.
2. Studies on immunization with tetanus toxoid vaccine in target group irrespective of study design.
3. Studies reporting on the uptake of tetanus toxoid vaccine in the target population in low-and-middle-
income countries.
4. Studies reporting on factors affecting the uptake of tetanus toxoid vaccine in the target group in low-
and-middle-income countries.
5. Studies which considered factors affecting immunization with tetanus toxoid vaccine in the following
categories:
i. Demand side factors (Target group related/Economic/Sociocultural/Education)
ii. Supply-side factors (Health system related/Logistics/Access/Utilization).
iii. Miscellaneous factors (Information/ Media/Peer groups).
6. Studies that satisfied the criteria for quality of evidence (as delineated in the assessment for quality of
evidence Table 1).
Exclusion Criteria
1. All studies not meeting the above inclusion criteria were excluded.
2. Editorials, editorial reviews, and comments, emanating therefrom, were excluded.
Data Extraction
Following the search, duplicate citations were excluded and/or removed. Thereafter, screening of article titles
and abstracts followed by an examination of full-text articles against the inclusion criteria was carried out
independently by two authors (TE) and (SL). Selected papers were then retrieved and full-length versions were
read through and through. The following information was extracted from the selected papers:
a. Study population and area where the study was carried out.
b. Methodological approach and follow-up period.
c. Key findings of the study, as regards the following, by year and country.
i. Factors affecting uptake of tetanus toxoid vaccine in target group.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2350
www.rsisinternational.org
ii. Strategies for and progress towards elimination of maternal and neonatal tetanus through
vaccination of target group.
iii. Outcomes and related factors for immunization of target group with tetanus toxoid vaccine.
d. Health system nuances that contribute to the outcomes of vaccination of the target group.
Articles that used multiple methodologies were included in more than one category. Any disagreements, in
extracted data, between the authors were resolved by consensus or by arbitration of a third review author
(CTW).
Data Management and Analysis
Retrieved data are presented as tables and charts; Egger’s regression test was carried out to assess for
publication bias.
The magnitude of the intervention, measured by the effect sizes of the studies, was reported within the context
of the independent variables against which the outcome was obtained.
Following this, discussion of the findings is entertained, highlighting key findings and proffering possible
reasons for these and solutions to same.
RESULTS
A total of thirteen primary studies were included in the systematic review. The studies were carried out in the
following Low-and-Middle-Income-Countries: Afghanistan, Angola, Central African Republic, Comoros,
Egypt, Ethiopia, Guinea, India, Kenya, Malawi, Mali, Nigeria, Pakistan, Papua New Guinea, Rwanda, Sierra-
Leone, Somalia, South Sudan, Sudan, Tanzania, Uganda, Yemen, Zambia and Zimbabwe. Also included was a
study conducted in one hundred and thirty-seven Low-and-Middle-Income-Countries (the aforementioned
countries inclusive). Five of the studies were conducted in urban areas, two of the studies in rural areas, and
seven studies in both urban and rural areas.
The period over which the studies were carried out ranged from a few weeks to five years. The types of studies
included in the review were all cross-sectional studies, though multiple methodologies were entertained at the
outset. The total number of study participants was one hundred and eight thousand, five hundred (108,500)
women of childbearing age. The sample size of the studies ranged from three hundred (300) women of child-
bearing age to seventy-three thousand seven hundred and thirty-five (73,735) women of childbearing age. The
principal sampling technique used in the studies was the multistage sampling technique employing mainly
simple random sampling and/or systematic sampling, with or without stratification, in the stages.
The common, immediate, and remote, factors volunteered as responsible for the elicited uptake of tetanus
toxoid-containing vaccine among the target group in the studies include the age of the woman (non-pregnant or
pregnant), marital status, educational level, wealth index, number and place of antenatal care/clinic (ANC)
visits, region of residence, distance to a health facility, place of delivery, access to media and/or mobile phone,
knowledge of MNT, information and/or knowledge of TTCV and health worker complacence. These findings
and effect sizes are outlined in Tables 2a and 2b, below. Furthermore, other summary findings of significance
for the included studies are outlined herewith:
1) Belay et al, 2022: The combined prevalence of PAB among rural women was 50.4%, and the associated
factors, in this regard are; Age 24 34 {AOR = 0.778, 95% CI (0.702,0.861)}, higher educational level {AOR
= 4.010, 95% CI (2.10,5.670)}, rich women {AOR = 3.097, 95% CI (2.680,3.583)}, mass media coverage
{AOR = 1.143, 95% CI (1.030,1.269)}, ANC > 3 visits {AOR = 0.676, 95% CI(0.482,0.978)}, Delivery at
health facility {AOR = 1.103, 95% CI(1.005, 1.210)}
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2351
www.rsisinternational.org
2) El-Adham et al, 2022: The key findings were, poor knowledge of TTCV/vaccination (50%), and lack of
information on the benefits of TTCV (75%), age at acceptance of TTCV was 25 35 years, as well as being
pregnant or primiparity.
3) Fenta et al, 2022: Quite significant in this study were, TT2+ uptake (41.6%), religion {orthodox -1; Muslim
AOR=0.580 (0.475,0.709); Protestant or other AOR=0.650 (0.514,0.822)}, and working status {employed
AOR 0.826(0.707,0.966)}.
4) Gelaw et al, 2022: The principal statistics were TT2+ uptake (71.2%), TT5 uptake (8.5%), knowledge of
TTCV vaccination (44%).
5) Gebremedhin et al, 2020: The findings of note were, TT2+ uptake, 51.8%(95% CI 47.7%-56.4%), TT5
uptake (14.8%), urban residence {AOR=6.1,95% CI (8.33,10.43)}, multiparity {AOR=2.3, 95% CI (1.7,6.4)},
Traveling < 30 minutes to health facility {AOR=4.6, 95% CI (1.34, 6.72)}.
6) Madubueze et al, 2022: The main findings were that uptake was majorly among women aged 15 34 years,
knowledge of TTCV of but 1.3%, TTCV uptake of 41.5%, with not being pregnant (23.5%) and lack of
information on TTCV (65.8%) being proffered as reasons for non-vaccination.
7) Mehanna et al, 2020: The key findings here were that 83.6% had poor knowledge of MNT and TTCV
(Barriers 58.9%; susceptibility 48%), TT2+ uptake of 27.7%.
8) Mohammed et al, 2022: Key in this study were, predominant age group {25-29 years (28.6%)}, rural
residence (73.7%), TT2+ uptake (>60%), mother’s education {AOR=1.70, 95%CI (1.25,2.32)}, higher wealth
index {AOR=1.89, 95%CI (1.45,2.54)}, 4 or more ANC visits {AOR=1.49, 95%CI (1.30,1.71)}.
9) Morhason-Bello et al, 2022: In this study, the following were noted, TT2+ uptake (59.6%), husband’s
occupation {skilled 74% (68.8-78.7), unskilled & others 67.6% (67.5-72.2)}, decision making power of
mother {low 47.8% (44-51.7); high 70.2% (65.7-74.3)}, difference in age between partners; wife older or same
age 63.2% (46.1-77.6), husband 1-5years older 65% (60.3-69.4), husband 6-10years older 58% (54.3-61.2),
husband older by >10years 54.8% (50.8-58.8).
10) Tungeraza et al, 2020: The significant findings in this study were; No or one TTCV injection (50.3%),
TT2 or greater uptake (49.7%), early ANC booking {AOR=1.174, 95% CI (1.033,1.335), p=0.0014}, age
group of women: 20-34 years {AOR=1.453, 95%CI (1.155,1.778), p=0.001}, >34 years {AOR=1.379, 95%CI
(1.065,1.786), p=0.015}, adequate ANC visits {AOR=0.049, 95%CI (0.582,0.723), p<0.001}, zones - Ungija
Zanzibar Island {AOR=0.434, 95%CI (0.309,0.609)}, Pemba {AOR=0.340, 95% CI (0.226,0.512)}.
DISCUSSION
Tetanus continues to be a salient public health problem in sub-Saharan Africa and Nigeria, in particular, as
well as in many low-and-middle-income countries, more generally. This study has focused on x-raying the
factors responsible for the uptake of tetanus toxoid immunization among women of childbearing age in Low-
and-Middle-Income countries, most of which are in the global south, with sub-Saharan Africa as a focal point
with the intent of proffering solutions to observed barriers to elimination of tetanus in these climes.
The findings from the studies reveal that maternal age was associated with significant odds of uptake of
tetanus toxoid-containing vaccines and that, however, this association was dichotomous. Whereas, more
generally, uptake of tetanus toxoid-containing vaccine increased with age, consequent upon parity probably
due to experience from previous pregnancies, it was noted, however, that in some instances, such as women
with some or higher levels of education, the employed and those in the higher wealth quintiles, uptake was
higher among women of lower ages probably due to socioeconomic empowerment as well as increased
exposure and/or access to social media and information. The former position aligns with findings from other
studies in The Gambia, Tanzania, Pakistan, and Vietnam [3], [21], [22], [23] whilst the latter position is in
keeping with other studies carried out in Ghana [1].
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2352
www.rsisinternational.org
Also, parity of the mother was noted to significantly affect the uptake of the tetanus toxoid vaccine. In this
regard, uptake was noted to be higher in multiparous women compared to nulliparous probably due to
numerous opportunities for vaccination and experience from previous pregnancies. This was in keeping with
studies carried out in Ghana, Pakistan, Sudan, and Turkey [1], [11], but was quite opposite to the findings in
the study carried out in The Gambia [3] In consonance, thereof, it is pertinent to note that being married was a
critical and significant factor with respect to the uptake of tetanus toxoid-containing vaccine in some studies
whereas others reported this factor as being insignificant. The latter position corroborates research outcomes in
Ghana, Ethiopia, and Nigeria [1], [12], [16], [17], [20].
Furthermore, the educational level of the mother was found to significantly affect the uptake of tetanus toxoid-
containing vaccine: with uptake increasing with higher levels of education probably due to increased access to
and understanding of information on tetanus and tetanus toxoid-containing vaccine. Add to this the significant
factor of the educational level of the father, with better outcomes observed in households with both partners
highly educated. This could probably be due to sharing a common and clearer understanding of the
intervention and husbands giving moral support to their spouses. This was in keeping with findings from other
studies in The Gambia, Ghana, Egypt, Nigeria, and Ethiopia [1], [3], [13], [17].
In consonance with the foregoing, it was noted that access to and use of media (newspapers, radio, and
television) as well as social media and telephone was associated with significantly higher uptake of tetanus
toxoid-containing vaccine probably due to high volume, streaming, and variety of information on tetanus and
tetanus toxoid containing vaccine; further buttressing the place and importance of information on the
intervention as regards uptake. This was in keeping with findings from other studies in The Gambia, Nigeria,
and Ethiopia [3], [17].
It is further noted that maternal or family wealth index was a significant determinant of uptake of tetanus
toxoid-containing vaccine among the target group with women from wealthier households having higher
uptake of the vaccine compared to women of less affluent households probably due to greater access to expert
and better health care compared to other groups. This is in keeping with findings from other studies in The
Gambia, Ghana, Ethiopia, and Sudan [1], [3], [11], [17].
Add to this the significance conjured by the distance
travelled to the health facility, regarding the uptake of the vaccine by the target group, and the relevance of
place of residence becomes quite pristine. The foregoing explains the higher uptake in urban compared to rural
areas probably due to differences in availability of transport vessels, mode of transport, cost of transportation,
and time of travel to health facility. This reveal corroborates outcomes from previous research on the subject
matter [1], [3].
The foregoing interpretation points out the critical issues bedevilling the intervention among women of
childbearing age, in these climes and informs the need for a concerted effort to tackle the situation, given the
circumstances, peculiarities, and facilities in-country.
CONCLUSION
Despite the aforementioned limitations, we propose that focus on health education, engagement of women,
targeted vaccination of high risk groups, expanding the availability and reach of social and other electronic
media as well as improving healthcare service delivery and access will significantly increase tetanus toxoid-
containing vaccine uptake. Furthermore, investments in infrastructure and processes which reduce the cost of
healthcare could further improve uptake of the vaccine. Lastly, the findings presented in this study can inform
and support the development and implementation of local policies on the vaccination of target groups with
tetanus toxoid-containing vaccines. These policies are crucial for the elimination of maternal and neonatal
tetanus.
Limitations of The Study
The study is encumbered with a few limitations principal among which is the inclusion of only primary studies
published in the English Language. Other limitations revolve around the extent and magnitude of the cause-
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2353
www.rsisinternational.org
and-effect relationship established by the included primary studies as well as the level of heterogeneity, where
present, between these primary studies.
Declaration of Competing Interests
The authors declare that there are no competing interests, of any nature, financial or otherwise, that have or
appeared to influence the findings in this work. Lastly, it is pertinent to note that the declared views are those
of the authors, entirely.
REFERENCES
1. Aboagye, R.G., Amu, H., Dowon, R.K., Bansah, P., Oaikhena, I.O., Bain, L.E., (2023). Prevalence and
correlates of tetanus toxoid uptake among women in sub-Saharan Africa: multilevel analysis of
demographic and health survey data. PLOS ONE; 18(12): e0296172.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0298174
2. Anatea, M. D., Mekonnen, T. H., Dachew, B. A., (2018). Determinants and perceptions of the
utilization of tetanus toxoid immunization among reproductive-age women in Dukem Town, Eastern
Ethiopia: a community-based cross-sectional study. Biomedical Centre for International Health and
Human Rights; 18: 27 36. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12914-018-0168-0
3. Barrow, A., Barrow, S., Jobe, A., (2022). Differentials in prevalence and correlates on uptake of
tetanus toxoid and intermittent preventive treatment with sulfadoxine-pyrimethamine during
pregnancy: A community-based cross-sectional study in The Gambia. SAGE Open Medicine; 10: 1
12.
4. Belay, A. T., Fenta, S. M., Agegn, S. B., Muluneh, M. W., (2022). Prevalence and risk factors
associated with rural women’s protected against tetanus in East Africa: Evidence from demographic
and health surveys of ten East African countries. PLOS ONE; 17(3): 1 15.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0265906
5. Deming MS, Roungou J-B, Kristiansen M, Heron I, Yango A, Guenengafo A, et al. Tetanus toxoid
coverage as an indicator of serological protection against neonatal tetanus. Bulletin of the World Health
Organization. 2002; 80:696703.
6. El-Adham, A. F., El-Nagar, A. E., Hashem, S. M., (2022). Determinants of tetanus toxoid vaccination
use among pregnant women. Tanta Scientific Nursing Journal; 27(4): 30 52.
7. Fenta, S. M., Fenta, H. M., (2023). Magnitude of Tetanus Toxoid Immunization and Associated Factors
among Pregnant Women in Ethiopia. The Open Public Health Journal; 16: 1 10.
8. Gashaw, A., Hunie, M., Amare, E., Zewdie, A., Abebe, M., Demeke, M., Kefelegn, S., Yehualashet,
D., Alemu, A., Adamu, Y., Gugsa, T., Tagele, A., (2023). Proportion of births protected against
neonatal tetanus and its associated factors among mothers who gave birth within the past 6 months in
Gozamn district, Northwest Ethiopia, 2022. Human Vaccines and Immunotherapeutics; 19: 2 10.
https://doi.org/10.1080/21645515.2023.2223066
9. Gebremedhin, T. S., Welay, F. T., Mengesha, M. B., Assefa, N. E., Werid, W. M., (2020). Tetanus
toxoid vaccination uptake and associated factors among mothers who gave birth in the last 12 months
in Errer District, Somali Regional State, Eastern Ethiopia. Biomedical Research International: 1 8.
https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/4023031
10. Giles, M. L.., Mantel, C., Munoz, F. M., Moran, A., Yusuf, N., Diaz, T., Ahun, M., Nic Lochlainn, L.
M., Wootton, E., Pathirana, J., Rendell, S., Tuncalp, O., Perut, M., Hombach, J., Merten, S., Lambach,
P., (2020). Vaccine implementation factors affecting maternal tetanus immunization in low- and
middle-income countries: Results of the Maternal Immunization and Antenatal Care Situational
Analysis (MIACSA) project. Vaccine; 38: 5268 5277. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.vaccine.2020.05.084
11. Ibrahim, Z. A., Sabahelzain, M. M., Elhadi, Y. A. M., Malande, O. O., Babiker, S. (2023). Predictors of
tetanus vaccine uptake among pregnant women in Khartoum State, Sudan: A hospital-based cross-
sectional study. Vaccines; 11: 1268 1276. https://doi.org/10.3390/vaccines11071268
12. Madubueze, U. C., Una, A. F. I., Okedo-Alex, I. N., Agha, V. M., Umeokonkwo, C. D., Eze, I. I.,
Utulu, R., Okeke, K. C., Agbo, U. N., Nwobashi, L. N., Alo, C., Azuogu, B. N., (2022). Awareness,
knowledge, risk perception and uptake of maternal vaccination in rural communities of Ebonyi State,
Nigeria. African Health Sciences; 22(2): 306 317. https://dx.doi.org/10.4314/ahs.v22i4.36
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2354
www.rsisinternational.org
13. Mehanna, A. A. (2021). Recommendation of tetanus toxoid vaccination for pregnant females in a
country that achieved elimination of maternal and neonatal tetanus. a commentary on the study:
Knowledge and health beliefs of reproductive-age women in Alexandria about tetanus toxoid
immunization. Archives of Obstetrics and Gynaecology; 2(1): 5 8.
14. Mehanna, A., Ali, M. H., Kharboush, I., (2020). Knowledge and health beliefs of reproductive-age
women in Alexandria about tetanus toxoid immunization. Journal of the Egyptian Public Health
Association; 95: 22 33. https://doi.org/10.1186/s42506-020-00049-8
15. Mohammed, S. O. O., Ahmed, E. M., (2022). Prevalence and determinants of antenatal tetanus
vaccination in Sudan: a crosssectional analysis of the Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey. Tropical
Medicine and Health; 50: 7 13. https://doi.org/10.1186/s41182-022-00398-4
16. Morhason-Bello, I., Kareem, Y. O., Illah, O., Akinyemi, J. O., Abdus-salam, R., Lawal, O., Bellow, O.,
Obajini, G., Adewole, I. F., (2022). Factors Associated with the Uptake of Antenatal Tetanus Toxoids
Containing Vaccine by First-Time Mothers in Nigeria: Findings from the 2018 Nigerian Demographic
Health Survey. Journal of Pregnancy: 1 12. https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/7607993
17. Muhammad-Idris, Z., Shehu, A., Isa, F., (2017). Assessment of tetanus toxoid coverage among
women of reproductive age in Kwarbai, Zaria,” Archives of Medicine and Surgery; 2(2): 4854.
18. Ngussie, J., Girma, B., Molla, A., Mareg, M., (2021). Tetanus Toxoid vaccination coverage and
associated factors among child bearing women in Ethiopia: A systematic Review and meta-analysis;
BioMedical Research International; 5529315: 10 pages. https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/5529315.
19. Nguyen TD, Dang AD, Van Damme P, Nguyen CV, Duong HT, Goossens H, et al. (2015). Coverage
of the expanded program on immunization in Vietnam: results from 2 cluster surveys and routine
reports. Human Vaccine Immunotherapy; 11:152633.
20. Raja, S., Mehraj, J., Guriro, S., Shaikh, M. A., (2019). Factors Contributing to Low Tetanus Toxoid
Vaccination Coverage among Young Adult Women in Khairpur District, Sindh. Indian Journal of
Science and Technology; 12(34):1 7.
21. Teshale, A.B., Tesema, B.A., (2020). Determinants of births protected against neonatal tetanus in
Ethiopia: a multilevel analysis using EDHS 2016 data,” PLoS One; 15(12): e0243071.
22. Tungaraza, M. B., Moshi, F. V., (2020). Predictors for uptake of tetanus toxoid vaccination during
pregnancy among women of reproductive age in Tanzania; An analysis of data from the 2015- 16
Tanzania Demographic and Health Survey and Malaria Indicators Survey. Research Square: 1 11.
23. Vouking, M. Z., Tadenfok, C. N., Ekani, J. M. E., (2017). Strategies to increase immunization coverage
of tetanus vaccine among women in Sub Saharan Africa: a systematic review. The Pan African Medical
Journal; 27(3): 25 28. http://www.panafrican-med-journal.com/content/series/27/3/25/full
24. World Health Organization (2018). Tetanus vaccines: WHO position paper, February 2017
Recommendations. Vaccine 2018; 36: 35733575.
25. Yaya, S., Kota, K., Buh, A., Bishwajit, G., (2020). Prevalence and predictors of taking tetanus toxoid
vaccine in pregnancy: a cross sectional study of 8,722 women in Sierra Leone. Biomedical Centre for
Public Health; 20: 855 864. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-020-08985-y
26. Yusuf, N., Raza, A. A., Chang-Blanc, D., Ahmed, B., Hailegebriel, T., Luce, R. R., Tanifum, P.,
Masresha, B., Faton, M., Omer, M. D., Farrukh, A., Aung, K. D., Scobie, M., Tohme, R. A., (2021).
Progress and barriers towards maternal and neonatal tetanus elimination in the remaining 12 countries.
Lancet Global Health; 9: 1610 1617.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2355
www.rsisinternational.org
APPENDIX
Figure 1: PRISMA Diagram of Search Strategy.
Table 1 Quality Of Evidence Of Selected Studies
S/N
Study
A. Title, Abstract
and Introduction
(Is the study
likely to be useful
and relevant)
B. Methodology and
Data (Is the applied
method appropriate
and does it assess the
outcome measure )
D. Usefulness
of Results
(Are the
results useful
for decision
modelling)
E. Quality
Assessment
(Overall
quality
assessment
score of study)
1
Belay et al, 2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
2
Gelaw et al, 2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
3
Gebremedhin et al,
2020
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
4
Giles et al, 2020
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
5
El-Adham et al, 2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
6
Fenta et al, 2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
7
Madubueze et al,
2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
8
Mehanna et al, 2020
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
9
Mohammed et al,
2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2356
www.rsisinternational.org
10
Morhason-Bello et al,
2022
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
11
Raja et al, 2019
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
12
Tungareza et al, 2020
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
13
Yaya et al, 2020
Yes
Yes
Yes
High
Key (Questions under each section)
Section A
Section B
1. Is the title relevant to the topic?
1. Does the methodology address
key study constructs?
2. Do the rationale and objectives
address key study questions ?
2. Is the collected data based on
PICOS framework?
3. Is the study summary thorough and
explicit?
3. Is Egger's test for publication
bias unequivocal?
Section C
Section D
1. Are study findings concise and
context specific?
1. Do the study results serve as template for
decision modelling?
2. Are there no ambiguities left to
address?
Section E
1.Score of ≥75%
(sections AD)
2. Score of < 75% (sections A-D) = Low Quality Study
Table 2a Factors Affe Cting Uptake Of Tetanus Toxoid Containing Vaccine And Their Effect Sizes
Factor/Study
Gelaw et al, 2022 [2]
Gebremedhin et al, 2020
[3]
Morhasson-Bello et al, 2022
[10]
Madubueze et al, 2022
[7]
Tungareza et al,
2020 [12]
AOR
1
AOR
1
OR
2
OR
2
OR
2
Age group
< 25
years
Reference
NIIS
3
<20 years
Reference
15 - 24
years
Reference
<20 years
Referen
ce
25 - 35
years
0.51
≥ 20 years
2.78
24 - 34
years
0.8
20 -34
years
0.76
>35 years
0.58
35
years
1.2
≥ 35 years
0.39
Area of
residence
NIIS
3
Urban
4.3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Urban
Referen
ce
Rural
Reference
Rural
0.51
Wealth Index
Quintiles
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Poorest
Reference
NIIS
3
Poor
Referen
ce
Poorer
1.78
Middle
2.48
Middle
1.12
Richer
4.93
Richest
7.23
Rich
1.59
Marital status
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Never
Referen
ce
Married
0.4
Widow
0.42
Separated
0.54
Mothers
Education
Primary
& below
Reference
No
education
Reference
None
Reference
Primary
& below
Reference
No
Referen
ce
Secondar
y &
above
1.81
Some
education
2.16
Primary
2.55
Secondar
y &
above
0.6
Primary
1.31
Secondary
4.05
Secondary
1.68
High
9.5
Higher
3.98
Husbands
Education
NIIS
3
No
education
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Some
education
2.02
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2357
www.rsisinternational.org
Occupation of
wife
NIIS
3
House wife
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Govt.
employee
2.5
Merchant
0.8
Pastoralist
0.14
Occupation of
Husband
NIIS
3
Labourer
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Govt.
employee
1.25
Farmer
0.01
Pastoralist
0.001
Ever been
pregnant
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
No
Reference
NIIS
3
Yes
8.3
Currently
pregnant
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
No
Reference
No
Reference
NIIS
3
Yes
1.64
Yes
8.3
Wanted
pregnancy
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
No
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Yes
0.75
Number of
Antenatal
Care Clinic
visits
No
Reference
No
Reference
None
Reference
NIIS
3
Adequate
Referen
ce
Yes
7
Yes
5.4
1 to 3
29.83
4 to 7
86.58
Inadequate
0.54
≥ 8
144.09
Place of
delivery
Home
Reference
NIIS
3
Home
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Health
Facility
1.13
Government
Hospital
23.28
Distance from
Health facility
< 30'
1.05
< 30'
4.6
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
> 30'
Reference
30' - 1 hour
0.8
> 1 hour
Reference
Adequate
Tetanus
vaccination
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Armed
conflict
intensity
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Number of
Children
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
≤ 3
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
4 to 6
1.12
≥ 7
0.72
Parity
Grand
primigrav
ida
Reference
Primipara
1.4
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Para 1
Referen
ce
Multipara
(2-4)
3.1
Para 2 -4
0.42
Grand
Multiparo
us
Reference
Grand
Multi
Reference
Para 5 +
0.2
Knowledge of
Tetanus
Toxoid
Containing
Vaccine
Poor
Reference
No
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Good
0.9
Yes
3.45
Attitude
towards
Tetanus
Toxoid
Containing
Vaccine
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Perception of
barrier to
vaccination
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Social media
exposure
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
No
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Yes
2.82
Own a mobile
phone
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
No
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Yes
3.93
1 - Adjusted Odds Ratio 2 - Odds Ratio 3 Not Included in Study
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2358
www.rsisinternational.org
Table 2b Factors Affecting Uptake Of Tetanus Toxoid Containing V Accine And Their Effect Sizes
Factor/Study
Mohammed et al,
2022 [9]
Mehanna et al, 2020
[8]
El-Adham et al,
2022 [5]
Fenta et al, 2022 [6]
Belay et al, 2022 [1]
AOR
1
AOR
1
OR
2
AOR
1
AOR
1
Age group
15 - 19
years
Reference
NIIS
3
NISS
3
NIIS
3
20 - 24
years
1.14
< 24years
Reference
25 -
29years
1.04
30 - 34
years
0.92
24 - 34
years
0.833
35 - 39
years
0.74
40 -44
years
0.64
≥ 35years
0.733
45 -49
years
0.75
Area of residence
Rural
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Urban
Reference
Urban
1.75
Rural
2.734
Wealth Index
Quintiles
Poorest
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Poor
Reference
Poor
Reference
Poorer
1.55
Middle
0.769
Middle
1.976
Middle
1.74
Richer
2.81
Rich
0.63
Rich
1.589
Richest
3.91
Marital status
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Single
Reference
Married
1.038
Cohabiting
0.78
Widowed
0.941
Divorced
1.055
Mothers Education
None
Reference
None
Reference
Good
Reference
None
Reference
None
Reference
Primary
1.81
Primary
0.5
Poor
0.435
Primary
0.534
Primary
0.792
Secondary
2.81
Secondary
6.2
Fair
0.77
Secondary
& above
0.455
Secondary
0.833
1 Adjusted Odds Ratio 2 - Odds Ratio 3 Not Included in Study
Higher
4.68
University
2.05
Higher
1.276
Husbands
Education
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
None
Reference
NIIS3
Primary
0.641
Secondary &
above
0.4
Occupation of
wife
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Housewife
Reference
Housewife
Reference
Employed
0.826
Employed
0.865
Other
0.968
Occupation of
Husband
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Wanted
pregnancy
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Number of
Antenatal Care
Clinic visits
≤ 4
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
None
Reference
None
Reference
> 4
1.71
1 to 3
0.056
1 to 3
1.113
4 & above
0.048
> 3
1.324
Place of birth
NIIS
3
Omdurman
Hospital
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Home
Reference
Al Saudi
Hospital
0.56
Health
facility
1.165
Distance from
Health facility
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Problem
Reference
No Problem
0.678
Number of
Children
NIIS
3
None
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
1 to 2
3.31
3 to 4
5.05
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RESEARCH AND SCIENTIFIC INNOVATION (IJRSI)
ISSN No. 2321-2705 | DOI: 10.51244/IJRSI | Volume XII Issue XV October 2025 | Special Issue on Public Health
Page 2359
www.rsisinternational.org
5 & above
10.56
Perception of
barrier to
vaccination
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
High
Reference
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
Low
2.69
Moderate
1.85
Own a mobile
phone
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
None
Reference
NIIS
3
Yes
0.621
Mass media
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
No
Reference
Yes
1.968
Listening to radio
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
None
Reference
NIIS
3
once a
week
0.666
At least once
a week
0.74
Watching
television
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
NIIS
3
None
Reference
NIIS
3
once a
week
0.556
At least once
a week
0.4