Provenance of the Ebenebe Sandstone: Evidence from X-Ray Fluorescence and Paleocurrent Studies
1Uchechukwu Stephanie Ezeani., 2Onyinye, Lisa Eze., *3Gordian Chuks Obi., 4Ositadimma Igwebuike Chiaghanam
1,3,4Chukwuemeka Odumegwu Ojukwu University, Anambra State
2Enugu State University of Technology, Enugu State
*Corresponding Author
DOI: https://doi.org/10.51244/IJRSI.2025.12060013
Received: 11 May 2025; Accepted: 23 May 2025; Published: 27 June 2025
The Ebenebe Sandstone is the sandy member of the Paleocene Imo Formation. The sand body in Anambra State was subjected to x-ray fluorescence and paleocurrent analyses to establish the nature of the source rock, the paleoclimatic conditions of the source terrain, and the depositional environment. The research is to provide an insight into the Paleocene-Oligocene tectonic history and paleogeography of the Niger delta basin and the implications for the exploration and exploitation of sand and hydrocarbon resources in the region. Ten fresh and representative samples of the Ebenebe Sandstone were collected from Ugwuoba, Ifite-Awka, Isiagu and Ufuma outcrops respectively. The samples were subjected to X-ray Fluorescence analysis to determine the percentage concentrations of SiO2, TiO2, Al2O3, Fe2O3, MgO, Na2O, CaO, and K2O. At each location twenty sets of measurements of dips and azimuths of foreset planes of planar cross-beds were also taken for paleocurrent analysis. X-ray fluorescence studies revealed that the Ebenebe Sandstone is a silica-cemented quartz arenite composed of about 90.5% silica, with deleterious amounts of the oxides of aluminum, iron and titanium. Paleocurrent analysis revealed that the clastics were sourced from a pre-existing sedimentary terrain that lies to the east of the present study area. Chemical parameters further indicates that the terrain lies within a passive margin that experienced intense chemical weathering. It can therefore be concluded that the Ebenebe Sandstone was recycled from a pre-existing sedimentary terrain located to the east of the present study area that most probably became emergent as a result of the asymmetrical subsidence of the post-Santonian Anambra basin. These results thus provide new insight into the tectonic history of the Anambra-Niger delta basin complex.
Keywords: Ebenebe Sandstone, X-ray fluorescence, chemical indices, quartz arenite, asymmetrical subsidence, Niger Delta.
The Ebenebe Sandstone is the sandy component of the Paleocene Imo Formation of the Niger Delta (Table 1.1). It is a prominent sandstone deposits in Anambra State that holds great potentials as a source of commercial silica sand (Ezeani, 2025)1.
Earlier studies have shown that the Ebenebe Sandstone which occurs as a slightly north-south-oriented sand ridge, is encased by the marine shale components of the Imo Formation (Nwajide, 20132, Odunze and Obi, 20143; Fig. 1.1). Studies have also shown that the sand is texturally mature, coarse to fine-grained, and transported from its source by an east-west directed fluvial current (Ezeani, 2025)1, and deposited in a tide-dominated shelf environment (Ekwenye et al.,20144; Ohwona and Okoro, 20225). Paleocurrent analysis by Obi et al, (2001)6, Ekwenye et al. (2014) 4, Odunze and Obi (2014)3 has revealed that the sand ridge was shaped by a NW-SE oriented longshore currents.
Apart from these studies, not much is known about the relationship between the post-Maastrichtian tectonic history of the Anambra Basin and provenance of the sandstones in the Anambra-Niger delta basin complex.
The present study aims to interpret the provenance of the Ebenebe Sandstone using x-ray fluorescence method. This method, though less frequently used for the study of sandstone composition, is ideal for the determination of major and minor provenance-sensitive elements such as silicon (Si), aluminium (Al), magnesium (Mg), calcium (Ca), iron (Fe), potassium (K), sodium (Na), titanium (Ti), sulphur (S) and phosphorus (P) (Fairchild, 1988)7. The result is expected to provide insight into the Paleocene-Oligocene tectonic history and paleogeography of the Niger delta basin. This will have far reaching implications for the exploration and exploitation of solid minerals and hydrocarbon resources in the region.
Geological Setting
The tectonic history of southeastern Nigeria has been discussed by several workers (e.g. Reyment, 19658; Burke, 19969, Murat, 197210; and Benkhelil, 198911). More recent efforts have analyzed the relationship between the pre-Santonian geologic history of the Abakaliki-Benue Trough and tectono-sedimentologic evolution of the post-Santonian Anambra Basin. Prominent among these are the works of Hoque and Nwajide (1985)12, Ojoh, (1992)13, and Obi, et al., (2001)6. These works have shown that the stratigraphic evolution of the Anambra Basin during the Campanian-Maastrichtian period was controlled by episodic asymmetrical subsidence of the Anambra platform, along the landward extension of the Atlantic Chain fracture associated with the initial opening of the Benue Trough. The subsidence was in response to sediment load and post-Benue rift thermal contraction of the lithosphere (Popoff, 1990)14, and Binks and Fairhead, 1992)15.
The Paleogene stratigraphy of south-eastern Nigeria is composed of a general progradational succession that begins with the fluvio-deltaic sandstone, mudstone and thin limestone bands of the Nsukka Formation (Late Maastrichtian-Paleocene; Obi, 200016; Oboh-Ikuenobe et al., 200517). The Nsukka Formation is succeeded by the Imo Formation (Paleocene) consisting of blue-grey clays, shallow marine shale, limestone and calcareous sandstone (Reyment, 1965)8. Figure 1.1 shows that in the present study area the mud rock component of the Imo Formation encased the sandstone component called the Ebenebe Sandstone (Oboh-Ikuenobe et al., 200517; Odunze-Akasiugwu and Obi, 201918). According to Nwajide (2013)2, marine regression during the Eocene led to the accumulation of Ameki Formation and the Nanka Sand.
X-ray Fluorescence Study
Ten (10) fresh and representative samples of the Ebenebe Sandstone were collected from Ugwuoba, Ifite-Awka, Isiagu and Ufuma outcrops respectively (Fig. 1.1) and subjected to X-ray Fluorescence analysis to determine the percentage concentrations of SiO2, TiO2, Al2O3, Fe2O3, MgO, Na2O, CaO, and K2O. The samples were first crushed to reduce the grains to less than 63 microns using the Tema vibrating mill. About 5.0g of dry rock sample powder was weighed in a silica crucible, and ignited in the furnace at 10000c for 2 to 3 hours for the calcinations of impurities in the rock powder. The samples were then allowed to cool to room temperature in desiccators, and then weighed again to determine the weight of calcinated impurities such as H2O, H2O+ and CO2.
One gram (1.0g) of the rock powder was mixed with X-ray Flux-Type 66:34% (66.0%), Lithium Tetraborate: 34% Lithium metaborate) to lower the vitrification temperature of the rock powder. The weighed mixture was ignited in the pre-set furnace (Eggon 2 Automatic fuse bead maker) at 15000c for 10 minutes to form glass bead. Each glass bead was labelled and slotted into the computerized XRF (Epilson 5 Panalytical model) for major elemental analysis.
Paleocurrent Analysis
A total of eighty-two (82) sets of measurements of dips and azimuths of foreset planes of planar cross-beds were measured and subjected to paleocurrent analysis. Twenty (20) sets each were taken from Ugwuoba, Ifite Awka and Isiagu, and twenty-two (22) from Enuguabor-Ufuma (Fig. 1.1). To determine the paleocurrent parameters the azimuth data for each location were first grouped and then plotted as Rose diagrams.
The statistical method described by Steinmetz (1962)19 was followed to compute the paleocurrent parameters including the mean vector azimuth R, variance S2 and the vector strength S. The computational procedure is illustrated in Table 2.1. Strict attention was paid to the sign of natural trigonometric functions.
The validity of columns 6 through 8 was kept in check as suggested by Steinmetz (1962), by means of the identity:
b2 + a2 +c2 = 1.000 ± 0.003 (1)
The mean vector azimuth, (R), variance (S2) and the vector strength (the clustering of the directions about the mean vector azimuth) were determined quantitatively using the following relations given by Steinmetz (1962)19, Marsal (1987)20, and Collinson and Thompson, (1989)21:
Arc tan R = (Sa) / (Sb) (2)
S2 = S (Ai-R)2
n-1 (3)
S = (SsinA) 2 + (ScosA) 2 (4)
N
Where Ai stands for individual measurements, D = dip of the cross bed; Sin A and Cos A stand for the sines and cosines of individual azimuths readings; Sin D stands for the sine of the dip angle, R is the mean vector azimuth and n stands for the total number of readings.
Composition: The result of the analysis including the percentages of the raw oxides, and chemical indices of alteration (as defined by Nesbit et al., 199622), and the ratios of the oxides are shown in Table 3.1. The result reveals that quartz (SiO2) has the highest concentration that ranges from about 89% to approximately 92%, with an average of 90.57%. Next in abundance is Alumina Al2O3, (4.15%-6.74%), followed by Iron oxide, Fe2O3 (2.44%-3.80%).
The ratio of silica to alumina (SiO2/Al2O3) varies from about 36% to 43.5%, with an average of 39.2% (Table 3.1). The Table also shows that the average ratio of SiO2 to Al2O3 is high in all samples implying that there is minimal clay or detrital Aluminum Silicate within the Ebenebe Sandstones in the study area. It is also evident that the percentage of total alkali-earth oxides is low, thus suggesting that the Ebenebe Sandstone is dominantly cemented by silica.
Classification: Pettijohn (1963)23 and Pettijohn et al., (1972)24 classified sandstones based on their chemical composition. The classification scheme used the log of the ratio of SiO2 to Al2O3 to differentiate mature sandstones high in SiO2/Al2O3 ratios, and immature sandstones high in Na2O/K2O ratios (Table 3.2). Four classes are recognized by Pettijohn et al., (1972)24 namely (i) Arenites with log of SiO2 to Al2O3 ratio greater than 1.5, (ii) greywackes with log of SiO2 to Al2O3 ratio greater than 1.0 and log of K2O/Na2O less than zero; (iii) arkose, with log of SiO2 to Al2O3 ratio greater than 1.5 and log of K2O/Na2O greater than zero and log (Fe2O3+MgO)/(Na2O+K2O), and (iv) lithic arenite with log of SiO2 to Al2O3 ratio greater than 1.5, and either log K2O/Na2O less than 0 or log (Fe2O3+MgO)/Na2O greater than 0 (Table 3.2).
The log of the silica: alumina ratios computed for the Ebenebe Sandstone (Table 3.3) ranges from 1.56 to 1.64, with an average value of 1.59, but the Na2O/k2O ratio is consistently zero. Based on the computed log ratios of the chemical oxides (Table 3.3) and on the classification scheme of Pettijohn et al., (197224; Table 3.2), the Ebenebe Sandstone is classified as silica-cemented quartz arenite.
Herron (1988)25 used the plot of log (SiO2/Al2O3) against log (Fe2O3/K2O) to classify sandstones and shales. To confirm the above interpretation we employed the Herron’s (1988)25 plot. The plot of log (SiO2/Al2O3) against log (Fe2O3/K2O) for the Ebenebe Sandstone (Fig. 3.1) confirmed the quartz arenite interpretation.
Nature of the parent rock:
Roser and Korsch (1988)26 have demonstrated that the nature of the parent rock of sandstones can be interpreted using discriminant functions based on a plot of the log of the ratio Fe2O3/K2O against log SiO2/Al2O3 .The functions are defined as follows:
Discriminant function-1 (DF-1) =
[-1.773TiO2 +0.607Al2O3 +0.76Fe2O3]-[1.5MgO +0.616CaO +0.509 Na2O-1.224 K2O -9.09]
Discriminant function-2 (DF-2) =
[0.445TiO2 +0.07Al2O3 -0.25Fe2O3]-[1.42MgO +0.438CaO +1.475Na2O+1.426 K2O -6.861].
The method distinguishes sediment source into four provenance zones: (i) Quartzose sedimentary terrain, (ii) Intermediate igneous terrain, (iii) Felsic igneous rock terrain, and (iv) Mafic igneous terrain.
The nature of the parent rock for the Ebenebe Sandstone was interpreted using the discriminant functions as proposed by Roser and Korsch (1988)26. The mathematical computation of the functions is summarized in Table 3.4.
Plots of the log of the ratio Fe2O3/K2O against log SiO2/Al2O3 (discriminant functions -1 against discriminant functions -2) using the raw oxides (Fig. 3.2) show that all the samples of the Ebenebe Sandstone analysed in this study plotted within the quartzose sedimentary provenance thus suggesting that the Ebenebe Sandstone clastics were generated from a pre-existing sedimentary terrain
Paleotectonics of the Source Terrain: The use of geochemical parameters in provenance studies has largely focused on interpretation of tectonic setting. Crook (1974)27 demonstrated that the ratio of SiO2 and K2O/Na2O in sandstone can be employed in provenance studies to distinguish the tectonic setting of sandstones. Crook (1974)27 used the plot of the log of K2O/Na2O against SiO2 to discriminate oceanic island arc, active continental, and passive margins. This techniques was used in this study to interpret the tectonic setting of the region from where the Ebenebe Sandstone clastics were generated. Figure 3.3 shows that the samples plotted essentially within the passive margin.
Source Rock Weathering: Nesbitt et al. (1996)22 have shown that the chemical composition of clastic sedimentary rocks depends largely on the degree of weathering in the source region. To interpret the degree of weathering in the Ebenebe Sandstone source region, the Chemical Index of Alteration (CIA) was calculated using the relation: [CIA=100*Al2O3/(Al2O3+CaO+K2O+Na2O)] as suggested by Nesbitt and Young (1982)28. The procedure measures the ratio of secondary aluminous minerals to feldspar, hence forms the basis for understanding the weathering intensity on source rocks (Elzien et al., 201429; Mgbenu, 201830; Echefu, 201931). Values of CIA below 50 indicate weak weathering or an un-weathered upper crust while values above 76 suggest intense weathering and/or a total removal of alkali and alkali-earth elements with an enrichment of alumina (Fedo et al., 199532; Dupuis et al., 200633).
The result (Table 3.1) shows that the Ebenebe Sandstone has an average chemical index of alteration of 89.32%. This high value indicates that the source region experienced intense chemical weathering.
Two other indices were also applied to gain more insight into the degree of weathering in the source region. These include the Mineralogical Index of Alteration (MIA) and the Plagioclase Index of Alteration (Harnois, 1988)34. The two indices are defined as follows:
CaO represents the calcium oxide within the silicate fraction).
MIA values 0%-20% indicate incipient weathering, 20-40% indicate weak weathering, 40-60% indicate moderate weathering, while 60-100% indicate intense to extreme degree of weathering (Harnois, 1988)34. The results (Table 3.1) show that MIA values range from 74.67% to 98.94%, giving an average of 78.63%. This confirms that the source region for the Ebenebe Sandstone experienced intense chemical weathering. This interpretation is consistent with the results obtained for the Plagioclase Index of Alteration (PIA). The Plagioclase Index of Alteration (PIA) values obtained in this study (Table 3.1) range from 49.34% to 97.94%, with an average of 90.49%. This further confirms that chemical weathering in the source region was intense.
Results and Interpretation of Paleocurrent Analysis
The grouped paleocurrent data for the Ebenebe Sandstone is presented in Table 3.5, while the Rose diagrams are shown in Figures 3.4 and 3.5. The computational procedure for the analysis of the paleocurrent data from Ugwuoba, Ifite Awka, Isiagu and Enuguabor-Ufuma are displayed in Tables 3.6 -3.9, while the derivation of the paleocurrent parameters is summarized in Table 3.10.
The following deductions are made from the rose diagrams. and from the computed parameters:
Discussion
Results of provenance studies of the sandstones of the Anambra and Niger delta basins (e.g., Hoque, 197736; Amajor, 198737, Hoque & Nwajide, 198512, Obi, 200016) have established that the provenance of the Maastrichtian-Eocene formations in the Anambra Basin is a mix of sediment sources, including the Oban Massif, the West African Massif, and recycled sedimentary rocks from the Anambra Basin and Afikpo Syncline. According to Obi et al, (2001)6, the Anambra Basin which was formed following the Santonian tectonic upheaval in the Benue Trough, continued to subside asymmetrically as Campanian-Eocene sedimentation progressed in the basin. An episode of strong subsidence occurred in the southern part of the Anambra platform about the Danian period, uplifting the proximal flank of the basin and dislocating the depocentre further southward to the Niger Delta. Consequently the uplifted western flanks of the Anambra basin composed of Maastrichtian sedimentary rocks served as the dispersal centre from which pre-Paleocene sediments were eroded and transported into the Niger Delta (Obi et al., 2001)6. Results of the present study are consistent with the above interpretations.
This study has shown that the Ebenebe Sandstone is a quartz arenite that was recycled from a pre-existing sedimentary terrain and deposited as a fluvio-deltaic deposit. The occurrence of bimodal and bipolar, often radiating palaeocurrent azimuthal patterns in the Ebenebe sandstones, is recognized as a reliable signature of deltaic sedimentation. Bimodal palaeocurrent systems with bipolar modes are common in settings where tidal processes are significant (Selley, 196835; Kreisa and Moiola 198638; Dalyrimple, 199239). In such settings the bipolar pattern defines the axis of the alternating ebb and flood currents that prevailed during the deposition of the sediment, the stronger current representing the flood stage (Dalyrimple 1992)39. In the present work, the bipolar pattern exhibited by the Ebenebe Sandstones coincides with the axis of the alternating seaward directed fluvial currents, and the landward directed ocean currents. The southerly directed components of the mutually opposed azimuthal patterns exhibited by the sandstones (Figs. 3.4. & 3.5) may also be attributed to seaward directed fluvial flows emanating from the pre-Paleocene provenance regions including the emergent Campanian-Maastricthian strata of the Anambra Basin.
Conclusions
This study was funded by the Obinenwu Foundation and TETFUND. We are grateful to Prof (Mrs) Shirley Odunze-Akasiugwu and an anonymous reviewer for their thorough and thoughtful reviews of the manuscript.