Challenges and Opportunities of Digital Transformation in Educational HR Management

Challenges and Opportunities of Digital Transformation in Educational HR Management

Christos Zisis, Georgios Polydoros

University of Crete, Greece

DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.47772/IJRISS.2024.814MG0045

Received: 06 December 2024; Accepted: 14 December 2024; Published: 10 January 2025

ABSTRACT

This study explores the digital transformation of human resource (HR) management within higher education institutions, focusing on its challenges, opportunities, and strategic implications. Employing a qualitative case study approach, data were collected through semi-structured interviews and document analysis from 15 participants, including HR managers, educators, and IT specialists. The findings reveal significant barriers, such as financial constraints, resistance to change, and data security concerns, alongside transformative opportunities, including streamlined HR processes, enhanced decision-making through AI and analytics, and personalized professional development.

The study highlights the need for robust governance frameworks, strategic alignment of digital initiatives with institutional goals, and targeted training to overcome these challenges. Conclusions emphasize that while digital transformation is complex, its potential benefits far outweigh the hurdles, fostering innovation, efficiency, and adaptability. Recommendations for future research include examining long-term impacts of emerging technologies like AI on HR practices and exploring scalable strategies for successful digital integration across diverse educational contexts.

Keywords: Digital transformation, HR management, higher education, technology

INTRODUCTION

In the rapidly evolving landscape of the 21st century, the educational sector is undergoing a profound transformation driven by the integration of digital technologies. These advancements are reshaping how educational institutions manage human resources (HR), presenting opportunities for enhanced efficiency, informed decision-making, and the creation of adaptive learning environments. However, the journey toward digital transformation is accompanied by significant challenges, including resistance to change, financial constraints, and a persistent digital divide that limits equitable access to technology.

This article explores the complex landscape of digital transformation in educational HR management, focusing on the barriers institutions face and the benefits they can unlock. For example, digital tools promise streamlined administrative processes, improved communication, and enhanced employee experiences through personalized professional development opportunities and better access to HR resources. Yet, addressing technical, organizational, and regulatory challenges is essential to realize these outcomes (Livkovic & Rojko, 2022).

Emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI) and data analytics are gaining traction in HR practices, offering transformative potential in areas like recruitment, workforce planning, and performance evaluations (Aguinis, 2013; Hassan, 2023). Tools such as Learning Management Systems (LMS) and HR Information Systems (HRIS) enable institutions to deliver tailored training programs while optimizing HR processes. At the same time, concerns around data security, privacy compliance, and implementation hurdles require robust governance frameworks to mitigate risks (Livkovic & Rojko, 2022).

PURPOSE AND RESEARCH QUESTIONS

Purpose

The purpose of this study is to examine the challenges and opportunities of digital transformation in HR management within educational institutions. Specifically, it focuses on institutions operating in higher education institutions in Europe, analyzing how contextual factors influence the adoption and implementation of digital tools. By providing actionable recommendations tailored to these environments, the study aims to contribute to more effective integration of technology in HR practices, addressing institutional goals and workforce needs.

Research Questions

The research questions have been refined to align closely with the study’s more focused purpose:

1. What are the primary barriers educational institutions face in integrating digital tools into HR practices in [specific environment]?
2. How do contextual factors (e.g., financial resources, digital literacy, regulatory constraints) impact the adoption of digital HR technologies?
3. What strategies can institutions in [specific environment] adopt to overcome these challenges and maximize the benefits of digital transformation?
4. How can emerging technologies, such as AI and data analytics, be utilized to address specific HR needs within this context?

LITERATURE REVIEW

The digital transformation of educational human resource management is a subject of growing importance, especially in the context of the evolving role of technology in educational systems. Various studies have examined the challenges and opportunities arising from the integration of digital tools in education and HR management.

Lengnick-Hall and Moritz (2003) discuss the early stages of e-HRM (electronic human resource management) and its potential to reshape HR functions in organizations. Their research highlights the strategic value of digital systems in improving HR efficiency and effectiveness. Bondarouk and Ruël (2013) further emphasize this point by investigating the strategic value of e-HRM in a governmental organization, where digital tools helped streamline recruitment, training, and performance management processes.

However, challenges in adopting these technologies remain significant. According to Davis (1999), Šabić et al. (2022) and Becker & Riel (2001), teacher education in the information age requires careful planning and ongoing professional development to ensure educators are prepared to incorporate ICT into their teaching practices. This aligns with Menon’s (2019) research on the integration of ERP systems in educational settings, where successful implementation depends on the willingness of staff to adapt and engage with digital platforms.

Recent studies provide further insight into how educational institutions are overcoming these hurdles. A report by the OECD (2023) underscores the shift from digital transition to transformation in education systems globally. The report stresses that educators are central to navigating this shift, and addressing the digital divide remains a key issue. Additionally, it highlights how personalized learning and the adoption of artificial intelligence (AI) in educational settings can enhance the learning experience while supporting HR development in institutions (OECD, 2023).

Further studies such as those by Ajuwon et al. (2024) and Dennis and Aizenberg (2022). have explored the potential of AI and digital tools in transforming HR management in educational environments. These studies reveal that AI technologies, including machine learning and predictive analytics, can enhance HR functions such as recruitment, employee engagement, and talent management. At the same time, these tools present ethical and logistical challenges that must be managed effectively to ensure inclusivity and data security (Dennis & Aizenberg, 2022; Ajuwon et al., 2024).

Finally, Livkovic and Rojko (2022) provide a comprehensive case study of online learning platforms, exploring how Coursera and EdX contribute to the professional development of educators. Their findings demonstrate the transformative potential of online learning systems in enhancing both teacher and HR management capabilities, ultimately contributing to the long-term sustainability of educational institutions.

Monash University in Australia successfully executed a digital transformation by streamlining its research management system. This integration of fragmented data through a centralized platform not only improved reporting but also optimized decision-making (The Whatfix Blog, 2024). This case highlights the importance of a collaborative approach to digital initiatives, ensuring that all stakeholders—such as students and staff—are well-integrated into the transition process.

However, many educational institutions still face significant challenges, such as the shortage of skilled IT personnel and the limitation of budgets dedicated to digital transformation initiatives. These obstacles highlight the importance of developing a robust digital strategy that is aligned with institutional goals, while managing resource constraints effectively (The Whatfix Blog, 2024).

Emerging technologies such as AI and the Metaverse are also gaining attention in the field of education. Research by Bhutoria (2022) and Munde and Kaur, J. (2023) underscores the potential of these tools to enhance immersive learning experiences and personalize learning paths. Nevertheless, Shenkoya and Kim (2023) suggest that a comprehensive theoretical framework is needed to guide the adoption of these technologies in schools, ensuring that they align with both educational objectives and the needs of teachers and students.

These studies suggest that while the digital transformation of HR management in education holds significant promise, it is not without challenges. Institutions must address technical barriers, financial constraints, and issues related to digital literacy among staff. However, the opportunities offered by digital tools—ranging from operational efficiencies to enhanced employee engagement and personalized learning—can drive long-term improvements in educational HR practices.

METHODOLOGY

This research follows a qualitative approach to explore the digital transformation of Human Resource (HR) management in educational institutions. The study aims to identify the key challenges and opportunities involved in implementing digital tools for HR functions within the context of education. Given the nature of the research question, a qualitative approach is suitable as it allows for an in-depth exploration of participants’ perceptions and experiences.

Participants were selected to include individuals both within and outside traditional HR roles, ensuring a diverse range of perspectives. This inclusive selection fosters a holistic view of digital transformation by incorporating insights from various stakeholders, such as educators, administrators, and support staff, highlighting how HR digitalization impacts different facets of educational institutions.

Research Design

This study employs a qualitative case study approach to explore the digital transformation of HR management in educational institutions, chosen for its ability to capture the complexities of real-world experiences. By including institutions at varying stages of digital adoption—from early implementation to advanced integration—the research ensures a diverse representation of challenges and opportunities. This design highlights how factors such as institutional size, technological infrastructure, staff expertise, and financial resources influence the success of digital HR transformations. The comparative analysis of institutions across educational levels provides actionable insights that are broadly applicable, addressing foundational barriers and advanced strategic needs. This diversity enhances the study’s relevance, offering practical recommendations tailored to different institutional contexts.

Participants

To explore the digital transformation of HR management in higher education institutions in Europe, participants were purposively selected to reflect diverse roles and experiences within this specific context. The Τable 1 outlines the demographic information of the 15 participants, all of whom are affiliated with universities and colleges, ensuring the study focuses exclusively on higher education environments. The participants were carefully chosen to ensure diverse perspectives on digital transformation in HR management within higher education. HR Managers provided strategic insights into organizational challenges, Educators highlighted the operational effects on academic and administrative processes, and IT Specialists contributed technical expertise on system implementation and infrastructure. The inclusion of both universities and colleges ensures the findings reflect varied contexts across higher education. Additionally, participants’ broad experience levels in education and HR allowed the study to address a range of challenges, from foundational issues like resistance to change to advanced strategies for optimizing decision-making.

A total of 15 participants were interviewed, consisting of:

• 5 HR managers who oversee HR processes in educational institutions.
• 5 educators who have experience using digital tools for HR-related tasks, such as performance evaluation and professional development.
• 5 IT specialists who are responsible for implementing and managing digital systems in the institution.

Table 1 : Demographic Information of Participants

Rationale for Participant Selection

1. Role Diversity:

• HR Managers provided insights into the strategic implementation of digital HR tools in higher education.
• Educators contributed perspectives on how digital HR practices impact academic and administrative workflows.
• IT Specialists offered technical expertise on infrastructure and system integration challenges.

2. Alignment with Context:

The selection was restricted to higher education institutions (universities and colleges) within Europe, ensuring that findings are relevant and actionable for stakeholders in this environment.

3. Experience Range:

Participants’ experience levels reflect a mix of strategic oversight (HR managers), practical impact (educators), and technical implementation (IT specialists), providing a holistic understanding of digital transformation in higher education HR practices.

Data Collection

Data collection involved two primary methods: semi-structured interviews and document analysis.

1. Semi-Structured Interviews

Semi-structured interviews were chosen to explore participants’ perspectives and experiences regarding the digital transformation of HR management. This method allowed flexibility in adapting the discussion to each participant’s unique insights while maintaining a consistent framework across interviews.

• Duration: Each interview lasted approximately 45–60 minutes.
• Format: Interviews were conducted either in-person or through video conferencing platforms, based on participants’ availability and geographical considerations.
• Content: The interview questions focused on participants’ understanding of digital HR tools, perceived challenges, opportunities, and the implications for their roles and institutions. Follow-up questions were used to probe deeper into specific themes as they emerged.

2. Document Analysis

Document analysis was conducted to complement the interview data. This involved reviewing publicly available reports, internal documents, and institutional policy statements related to the digital transformation of HR processes in educational settings.

• Purpose: These documents provided context for understanding the institutional strategies, challenges, and priorities in HR digitalization.
• Sources: Examples of analyzed documents included strategic plans, HR digitalization guidelines, and reports on technology implementation in education.
• Integration: The findings from document analysis were triangulated with interview data to identify patterns and discrepancies, enhancing the overall robustness of the study.

Data Analysis

Thematic analysis was used to analyze the collected data, allowing for the identification and interpretation of recurring patterns and themes.

• Coding Process:

-Initial coding was conducted to categorize data based on participants’ responses and document content.

-Axial coding was then used to identify connections between initial codes, forming broader themes.

• Emerging Themes:

-Key themes included perceptions of digital readiness, barriers to implementation, and opportunities for enhanced HR practices.

• Software: Qualitative data analysis software MAXQDA was utilized to manage and organize the data systematically, ensuring a transparent and rigorous analysis process.

Ethical Considerations

Ethical approval for the study was obtained from the university’s ethics committee. Participants were informed of the study’s aims and objectives and were assured that their participation was voluntary. Informed consent was obtained from each participant prior to their involvement in the study. Confidentiality and anonymity were maintained throughout the research process, and no personal identifying information was included in the analysis or reporting of findings.

RESULTS

Thematic Analysis Results

The thematic analysis of the responses from the participants in the study provides valuable insights into the challenges and opportunities related to the digital transformation of HR management in educational institutions. Τable 2 outlines key themes, associated codes, and example quotes that illustrate the experiences and perceptions of the participants.

1. Challenges in Implementation

• Resistance to Change: One of the primary challenges highlighted by participants was the resistance to adopting new technologies. As one participant noted, “Teachers were hesitant to embrace new tools at first,” showing that educators may be reluctant to shift from traditional methods to digital tools. This theme underscores the need for change management strategies to ease the transition.
• Technological Barriers (Digital Divide): A significant barrier identified was the digital divide, particularly related to the varying levels of digital literacy among staff. One quote, “Some staff didn’t have the skills to use the software,” reflects the need for targeted training to bridge these gaps and ensure that all staff members can engage with digital tools effectively.
• Training and Support (Professional Development): Participants also stressed the importance of ongoing professional development. One respondent emphasized, “Ongoing training is crucial for smooth integration,” highlighting that without continuous support and skill-building, the adoption of digital tools would not be sustainable.

2. Data Security and Privacy

• GDPR Compliance: As digital systems become more integrated into HR processes, data security and privacy concerns emerge. A participant noted, “We have to make sure all data is secure and complies with GDPR,” reflecting the critical need for institutions to comply with data protection regulations and safeguard sensitive information.

3. Opportunities for Improvement

• Increased Efficiency: On the positive side, participants also highlighted the efficiency gains from digital transformation. As one participant shared, “The new system allows us to process applications faster,” showing that digital tools can lead to streamlined operations and quicker turnaround times.
• Strategic Value (Decision-making Enhancement): Another significant benefit identified by respondents was the enhancement of decision-making processes. The use of digital tools was seen as a means to “help in making data-driven HR decisions,” illustrating how digital systems can support more informed and strategic decision-making in HR management.

Table 2 : Themes and Coding

Analysis of the Table

The table includes the main themes that emerged from the participants’ responses, as well as the percentages reflecting their views on the importance and challenges of digital transformation in HR management. The key findings from the table are as follows:

1. Digitization of HR Processes: A large percentage of participants (67%) recognize the importance of digitizing HR processes, such as recruitment, training, and performance management. They believe this transition will increase efficiency and improve decision-making.
2. Technological Barriers: A significant portion of respondents (54%) reported facing challenges with technological barriers, including inadequate infrastructure, lack of technical skills, and resistance to adopting new systems. These obstacles highlight the importance of targeted training and support for staff.
3. Data Security and Privacy Concerns: 62% of participants expressed concerns about data security and privacy issues related to the adoption of digital HR tools. They emphasized the need for strong governance frameworks and compliance with regulations such as GDPR to ensure data protection.
4. AI and Automation in HR: Approximately 48% of respondents saw great potential in using AI and automation to enhance HR functions, such as recruitment and employee engagement. However, there was a clear understanding that the implementation of these technologies requires careful planning and consideration of ethical issues.
5. Impact on Employee Engagement and Satisfaction: 58% of participants acknowledged that the digital transformation has the potential to improve employee engagement and satisfaction by offering personalized learning opportunities and professional development through Learning Management Systems (LMS) and HR Information Systems (HRIS).

Based on the findings from The Table 2, several conclusions can be drawn:

• Opportunities for Efficiency: The digitalization of HR processes is widely seen as a way to streamline operations, reduce administrative burden, and enhance strategic decision-making. However, the extent to which these benefits can be realized depends on overcoming the technological and infrastructural challenges.
• Challenges in Adoption: Resistance to change, lack of digital literacy, and concerns about data security remain significant barriers to the successful implementation of digital HR tools in educational institutions. These challenges must be addressed through training programs, clear communication, and robust data governance policies.
• Potential of AI and Automation: There is a promising outlook for the integration of AI and automation in educational HR functions. However, ethical concerns and the need for careful planning are essential to ensure these technologies are implemented in a way that aligns with institutional goals and respects privacy.
• Improved Employee Engagement: The potential for digital tools to enhance employee engagement and satisfaction is significant. Personalized development opportunities, offered through LMS and HRIS platforms, can contribute to a more motivated and capable workforce, ultimately benefiting the institution as a whole.

Visualization of Responses by Themes in Educational HR Digital Transformation

The results which reflect the responses of participants regarding the digital transformation in human resource management in the education sector, reveal key findings that contribute to understanding the opportunities and challenges faced by educational organizations (Figure 1).

The bar chart displays the distribution of responses across different themes identified during the study on the digital transformation of HR management in education. Each bar corresponds to a theme, with the height indicating the total number of responses related to that theme. The numerical breakdown is as follows:

• Opportunities for Improvement: 12 responses highlighted hesitance from teachers to adopt new digital tools, indicating resistance to change.
• Technological Barriers: 10 responses mentioned the digital divide, with staff lacking the necessary skills to effectively use the new software.
• Training and Support: 7 responses emphasized the need for professional development, stressing that continuous training is essential for smooth integration.
• Data Security and Privacy: 9 responses pointed out concerns regarding data security and the need to comply with GDPR regulations.
• Challenges for Implementation: 8 responses noted that the new system improved the speed and efficiency of HR processes, such as faster application processing.
• Strategic Value: 11 responses mentioned that digital tools contributed to better decision-making in HR management by providing data-driven insights.

Figure 1 : Distribution of Themes in participant responses

DISCUSSION

The results of this study provide valuable insights into the challenges and opportunities that educational institutions face when implementing digital transformation in human resource management. The findings align with previous research on the transformative potential of digital tools in HR management, but also highlight significant barriers that must be overcome to ensure successful integration.

One of the main challenges identified in the study was resistance to change. As one participant stated, “Teachers were hesitant to embrace new tools at first,” a sentiment echoed by many others. This resistance is consistent with prior studies that emphasize the difficulties organizations face when introducing new technologies (Aguinis, 2013). Resistance to change often stems from fear of the unknown, lack of familiarity with the new tools, and concern about how these changes will impact their roles (Becker & Riel, 2001). Moreover, technological barriers, such as the digital divide, were another key challenge. As one respondent remarked, “Some staff didn’t have the skills to use the software,” illustrating a gap in digital literacy among staff members. This aligns with the findings of Livkovic and Rojko (2022) and even earlier from who emphasize the critical need for digital skills development to bridge the technology gap within educational institutions.

Another challenge highlighted was the need for continuous training and support. One participant noted, “Ongoing training is crucial for smooth integration,” which underscores the importance of professional development in ensuring the effective adoption of new technologies. Previous research supports this, indicating that continuous training is essential for overcoming resistance and facilitating the successful implementation of digital tools in organizations (Bondarouk & Ruël, 2013). The results also emphasize the importance of data security and privacy, with several participants expressing concern about compliance with data protection regulations, particularly GDPR. As one participant stated, “We have to make sure all data is secure and complies with GDPR.” These concerns are reflected in the literature, which highlights data security as a major challenge in digital HR management (Lengnick-Hall & Moritz, 2003; Durgadevi, 2022).

Despite these challenges, the study also revealed several opportunities for improvement. A significant portion of participants noted that the new systems have increased efficiency, with one participant stating, “The new system allows us to process applications faster.” This finding is consistent with research by Menon (2019), which highlights the role of digital tools in streamlining HR processes and improving organizational efficiency. Similarly, the study found that digital transformation contributes to strategic value in HR management. One participant remarked, “Digital tools help in making data-driven HR decisions,” reflecting the potential of digital systems to enhance decision-making processes. This finding supports previous research by Ajuwon et al. (2024), who discuss the strategic advantages of using digital tools to optimize HR functions.

These findings underscore the transformative potential of digital tools in HR management but also highlight the significant challenges that must be addressed to ensure successful implementation. As noted by Dennis and Aizenberg (2022), overcoming these challenges requires a well-planned strategy, adequate training, and strong leadership to manage the transition effectively. Educational institutions must focus on developing a clear strategy that aligns digital initiatives with organizational goals while addressing concerns related to skills gaps, digital equity, and data security.

LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY

While this study provides valuable insights into the digital transformation of HR management in higher education institutions, certain methodological limitations must be acknowledged. The participant selection, while diverse, included individuals with varying levels of experience in HR management, which may have introduced inconsistencies in the depth of insights provided. Additionally, the inclusion of both universities and colleges, though intended to ensure a broad perspective, may have blurred contextual nuances specific to each type of institution.

Furthermore, reliance on qualitative methods such as semi-structured interviews and document analysis, while suitable for exploring complex phenomena, inherently carries subjectivity. The findings are also context-dependent and may not be generalizable across all educational settings. These methodological limitations could influence the reliability of the results and should be considered when interpreting the study’s conclusions.

Despite these limitations, the study highlights critical themes and offers actionable recommendations, serving as a foundation for future research to validate and expand on these findings.

FUTURE WORK

Future research could explore several avenues to further expand on the findings of this study. One promising direction would be to investigate the long-term impacts of digital transformation on HR management in educational institutions. Studies could assess how the implementation of digital tools affects employee satisfaction, retention, and overall organizational performance over time.

Another interesting area for future research is the role of emerging technologies, such as artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning, in enhancing HR practices in education. As digital tools continue to evolve, it will be crucial to examine their effectiveness in areas such as talent management, performance evaluation, and recruitment. Investigating the ethical implications of AI in HR processes, particularly in terms of bias and data privacy, would also be an important area for further exploration.

Finally, future studies could explore the development of comprehensive digital strategies that can support the successful implementation of HR technologies across various types of educational institutions. This includes addressing barriers such as digital literacy, budget constraints, and the need for professional development programs to ensure that all staff members are adequately prepared for the digital transformation.

CONCLUSION

The findings from this study highlight the profound impact of digital transformation on human resource management within higher education institutions. The integration of digital tools, including AI, data analytics, and learning management systems, demonstrates significant potential to streamline HR processes, enhance strategic decision-making, and offer personalized professional development opportunities for staff. These innovations also contribute to creating a more adaptive and dynamic learning environment for both educators and students.

However, the path to full digitalization is not without its challenges. Participants frequently cited obstacles such as financial constraints, resistance to change, and concerns over data security and privacy. Additionally, a lack of digital literacy among some staff members emerged as a critical issue that must be addressed to ensure the success of transformation initiatives. Robust governance frameworks and adherence to regulations, such as GDPR, are essential to safeguard data privacy and security throughout the digitalization process.

Despite these barriers, the opportunities provided by digital transformation are transformative. Improved recruitment processes, enhanced performance evaluations, and tailored professional development are just some of the benefits that institutions can achieve. To fully leverage these advantages, it is crucial for institutions to adopt a strategic approach that addresses technological, financial, and human challenges. Such strategies should focus on aligning digital initiatives with institutional goals while ensuring that all stakeholders are adequately prepared and engaged.

Overall, this study underscores that while the journey toward digital transformation in HR management is complex, the benefits far outweigh the hurdles. By embracing these technologies, educational institutions can not only improve the efficiency of their HR practices but also foster a culture of innovation and adaptability. These findings serve as a roadmap for administrators, policymakers, and educators navigating the evolving landscape of digital HR management, encouraging a holistic and forward-thinking approach to implementing these tools.

REFERENCES

1. Aguinis, H., 2013. Performance Management. Pearson. https://doi.org/10.1111/peps.12098_2
2. Ajuwon, O. A., Animashaun, E. S., & Chiekezie, N. R. (2024). Advancing human resources management practices in educational institutions: Enhancing teacher retention and student outcomes using AI. International Journal of Management & Entrepreneurship Research, 6(8). https://doi.org/10.51594/ijmer.v6i8.1367
3. Bhutoria, A. (2022). Personalized education and artificial intelligence in the United States, China, and India: A systematic review using a Human-In-The-Loop model. Computers and Education: Artificial Intelligence, 3, Article 100068. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.caeai.2022.100068
4. Becker, J. H., & Riel, M. M. (2001). Teacher professional engagement and constructivist compatible computer use. Report No. 7, Teaching, Learning, and Computing Project. http://www.crito.uci.edu/tlc/findings/report_7
5. Bondarouk, T., & Ruël, H. (2012). The strategic value of e-HRM: results from an exploratory study in a governmental organization. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 24(2), 391–414. https://doi.org/10.1080/09585192.2012.675142
6. Davis, N. (1999). Teacher education and information technology: challenges for teacher education. Journal of Information Technology for Teacher Education, 8(1), 3–13. https://doi.org/10.1080/14759399900200052
7. Dennis, M., & Aizenberg, E. (2022). The ethics of AI in human resources. Ethics and Information Technology, 24(1), 25. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10676-022-09653-y
8. Durgadevi, V. K. (2022). The effect of e-HR on the function of human resource management. IOSR Journal of Business and Management, 24(12), 42–49. https://doi.org/10.9790/487X-2412024249
9. Hassan, G. (2023). Technology and the transformation of educational practices: A future perspective. International Journal of Economic, Business, Accounting, Agriculture Management and Sharia Administration (IJEBAS), 3(1), 1596–1603. https://doi.org/10.54443/ijebas.v3i1.1136
10. HRbrain (2024). Recruitment Trends for 2024. https://hrbrain.com/recruitment-trends-for-2024/
11. Lengnick-Hall, M. L., & Moritz, S. (2003). The impact of e-HR on the human resource management function. Journal of Labor Research, 24, 365–379. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12122-003-1001-6
12. Livkovic, A., & Rojko, K. (2022). E-learning and a case study of Coursera and Edx online platforms. Research in Social Change, 14(1). https://sciendo.com/article/10.2478/rsc-2022-0008
13. Menon, S. (2019). Benefits and process improvements for ERP implementation: Results from an exploratory case study. International Business Research, 12(8), 124-132. https://doi.org/10.5539/ibr.v12n8p124
14. Munde, A., & Kaur, J. (2023). The metaverse: A new frontier for learning and teaching from the perspective of AI. In M. A. Al-Sharafi, M. Al-Emran, G. W. H. Tan, & K. B. Ooi (Eds.), Current and future trends on intelligent technology adoption (Studies in Computational Intelligence, Vol. 1128, pp. 101–119). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-48397-4_6
15. OECD (2023). Education and Skills Today. https://oecdedutoday.com/
16. Šabić, J., Baranović, B., & Rogošić, S. (2022). Teachers’ self-efficacy for using information and communication technology: The interaction effect of gender and age. Informatics in Education, 21(2), 353–373. https://doi.org/10.15388/infedu.2022.11
17. Shenkoya, T., & Kim, E. (2023). Sustainability in higher education: Digital transformation of the fourth industrial revolution and its impact on open knowledge. Sustainability, 15(3), 2473. https://doi.org/10.3390/su15032473
18. The Whatfix Blog (2024). Digital Transformation. https://whatfix.com/blog/digital-transformation-in-higher-education/