Corporate Insolvency and the Role of Accounting: Investigating How Accountants Navigate Corporate Insolvencies and Restructuring in the Nigerian Business Environment

Corporate Insolvency and the Role of Accounting: Investigating How Accountants Navigate Corporate Insolvencies and Restructuring in the Nigerian Business Environment

Dr Samuel Ugochukwu PhD, CNA, CCSA

The Information Communication Technology University, Nyanya, Federal Capital Territory, Nigeria

DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.47772/IJRISS.2025.9010229

Received: 10 January 2025; Accepted: 15 January 2025; Published: 14 February 2025

ABSTRACT

Corporate insolvency is a growing concern in Nigeria’s challenging business environment, characterized by economic volatility, regulatory inefficiencies, and financial mismanagement. This study explores the pivotal role of accountants in navigating corporate insolvencies and restructuring processes, focusing on their responsibilities in financial reporting, compliance, valuation, and stakeholder communication. Drawing on case studies such as Etisalat Nigeria (now 9mobile) and Intercontinental Bank Plc, the paper examines how accountants address insolvency complexities, mitigate systemic risks, and drive successful restructuring outcomes.

The study adopts a mixed-method approach, combining qualitative interviews with practitioners and quantitative analysis of corporate insolvency cases in Nigeria. Findings reveal that while accountants are critical in facilitating transparent and efficient insolvency proceedings, they face significant challenges, including fragmented regulatory frameworks, limited technological adoption, and ethical dilemmas. Comparative insights from global practices, particularly in the UK and South Africa, demonstrate the potential for Nigeria to enhance its insolvency frameworks through strengthened regulatory enforcement, technological integration, and capacity building for accountants.

This study highlights the urgent need for policy reforms, innovative accounting practices, and collaboration among stakeholders to improve corporate insolvency outcomes in Nigeria. The findings contribute to a deeper understanding of the accountant’s role in mitigating financial crises and fostering economic stability.

Keywords: Corporate insolvency, restructuring, accounting, Nigerian business environment, regulatory compliance, financial reporting.

INTRODUCTION

Corporate insolvency is a global concern, particularly in emerging economies like Nigeria, where businesses face volatile market conditions, regulatory inadequacies, and financial mismanagement (Adegbite et al., 2012). Accountants are very important in insolvency and restructuring, serving as financial diagnosticians, advisors, and compliance enforcers (Adetayo & Ajayi, 2020). Despite this, the role of accounting in Nigerian insolvencies remains under-assessed.

Problem Statement

Nigerian businesses increasingly encounter insolvency due to economic instability, weak governance, and debt mismanagement (Olaniyan & Adebayo, 2021). Accountants face unique challenges, such as navigating fragmented regulatory frameworks and ethical dilemmas, yet their contributions are crucial for successful restructuring.

Objectives of the Study

1. To examine accountants’ roles in insolvency and restructuring.
2. To identify challenges and propose solutions for enhancing accountants’ efficacy.

Research Questions

1. What are the roles of accountants in corporate insolvency and restructuring?
2. What challenges impede their effectiveness?
3. How can accounting practices improve insolvency outcomes in Nigeria?

Significance of the Study

This study contributes to understanding the intersection of accounting, law, and management in insolvency contexts. Its findings will benefit practitioners, policymakers, and academics exploring Nigeria’s evolving business environment.

LITERATURE REVIEW

Conceptual Framework

Corporate insolvency occurs when an organization cannot meet its financial obligations, often leading to the appointment of external administrators or the initiation of restructuring proceedings (Jones, 2020). Restructuring aims to restore a company’s financial health by renegotiating debts, cutting costs, or divesting non-core assets (Deegan, 2014). Accounting plays a crucial role in these processes by ensuring transparency, compliance with laws, and accurate valuation of assets and liabilities (Smith, 2019).

Accounting and Corporate Insolvency

The role of accountants in insolvency is multidimensional. As highlighted by Jones (2020), accountants serve as forensic auditors, financial strategists, and mediators. Their expertise ensures compliance with statutory obligations and fosters stakeholder trust. Studies in developed economies, such as the US and UK, emphasize the critical role of accountants in restructuring distressed companies (White, 2022).

Accountants’ contributions in insolvency cases are categorized as follows:

1. Forensic Auditing, by Identifying fraud and irregularities in financial records to determine the root causes of insolvency (Grant, 2021).
2. Valuation, by accurately assessing assets and liabilities to guide decision-making in restructuring or liquidation (Deegan, 2014).
3. Financial Reporting, by Preparing and presenting financial information that complies with regulatory requirements (Smith, 2019).

Corporate Insolvency in Nigeria

The Nigerian business environment presents unique challenges in insolvency cases due to economic volatility, weak corporate governance, and limited institutional capacity. Insolvency is primarily governed by the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) and the Bankruptcy Act. However, these laws are often criticized for being outdated and fragmented (Adegbite et al., 2012).

Nigerian companies face insolvency for various reasons, including:

1. Debt Overhang, through accumulation of unsustainable debts, as seen in the 2017 Etisalat Nigeria crisis, where a $1.2 billion syndicated loan led to insolvency and restructuring (Adewale & Ojo, 2020).
2. Corporate Mismanagement, such as poor decision-making and lack of financial oversight contribute to insolvencies. The liquidation of Skye Bank Plc in 2018 highlighted systemic financial mismanagement (CBN, 2018).
3. Macroeconomic Instability, such as Fluctuations in oil prices and exchange rates adversely affect businesses reliant on foreign currency-denominated loans (Ojo & Agbaje, 2022).

Despite these challenges, studies indicate that restructuring rather than liquidation is increasingly favored in Nigeria, with accountants playing a central role (Eze & Okoro, 2018).

Challenges Facing Accountants in Nigerian Insolvencies

The role of accountants in Nigerian insolvency cases is hindered by several factors:

1. Regulatory Challenges. Nigeria’s fragmented legal framework complicates insolvency proceedings. Adewale and Ajayi (2020) argue that the lack of a unified insolvency code increases the procedural burden on accountants.
2. Ethical Dilemmas. Accountants often face pressure to manipulate financial statements to favor certain stakeholders, raising questions about their professional independence (Eze & Okoro, 2018).
3. Technological Deficiencies. The limited use of advanced accounting tools in Nigeria undermines the efficiency of forensic investigations and financial reporting (Adetayo, 2021).

Comparative Insights from Global Practices

Global studies provide valuable insights into improving Nigerian insolvency processes:

1. United Kingdom: The UK’s Insolvency Act offers a well-defined legal framework for restructuring. Accountants play a critical role in ensuring financial transparency and compliance during insolvency proceedings (White, 2022). The restructuring of Thomas Cook Group in 2019 demonstrated the importance of robust financial reporting and stakeholder engagement in avoiding liquidation.
2. South Africa: South Africa’s Companies Act of 2008 integrates sustainability and stakeholder engagement into insolvency proceedings. Accountants’ contributions during the Steinhoff International restructuring in 2017 highlight the value of forensic auditing in uncovering financial mismanagement (Nkosi, 2020).
3. United States: The Chapter 11 bankruptcy framework in the US emphasizes debtor-in-possession financing and the role of accountants in preparing reorganization plans. The restructuring of General Motors in 2009 is a prime example of how accountants can facilitate complex negotiations with creditors and stakeholders (Grant, 2021).

Theoretical Perspectives on Insolvency Accounting

This study draws on several theoretical frameworks to analyze the role of accountants in insolvency and restructuring:

1. Agency Theory. This theory highlights the conflict between management and stakeholders during insolvency. Accountants serve as mediators to align interests (Jensen & Meckling, 1976).
2. Stakeholder Theory. This theory emphasizes the importance of balancing the interests of creditors, employees, and shareholders in restructuring processes (Freeman, 1984).
3. Resource Dependence Theory. This theory explains how accountants leverage financial and informational resources to guide decision-making during insolvency (Pfeffer & Salancik, 1978).

Implications for the Nigerian Context

The review underscores the critical need for:

1. Strengthening legal and regulatory frameworks to support accountants in insolvency cases.
2. Enhancing the adoption of global best practices to improve insolvency outcomes.
3. Building the capacity of Nigerian accountants through targeted training in forensic auditing, financial modeling, and valuation techniques.

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

Research Design

This study adopts a mixed-method approach, combining qualitative interviews with quantitative analysis of financial reports and case studies of Nigerian firms.

Sample Size

A total of twenty (20) accountants, auditors, and insolvency practitioners directly involved in corporate restructuring and insolvency cases in Nigeria were interviewed.

This sample size is suitable for gathering in-depth insights into professional experiences, challenges, and practices in the context of insolvency. It allows for thematic saturation, ensuring comprehensive qualitative findings.

Also questionnaires were administered to 200 professionals, including accountants, corporate managers, financial analysts, and regulators from sectors prone to insolvency (e.g., banking, telecommunications, oil and gas).

This sample size is statistically adequate for detecting patterns and trends, considering the research focus and population size in Nigeria. A confidence level of 95% and a margin of error of ±5% can be achieved with this range.

Case study analysis of corporate insolvency cases in Nigeria, such as Etisalat Nigeria (9mobile) was done.

A small number of detailed case studies enables a focused examination of the role of accountants in diverse industries, ensuring rich contextual understanding.

Data Collection

Primary data will include interviews with accountants, insolvency practitioners, and regulators. Secondary data will include reports from Nigerian regulatory bodies (e.g., the Financial Reporting Council of Nigeria) and relevant academic literature.

Data Analysis Techniques

Thematic analysis will be used to extract qualitative insights, while quantitative data will be analyzed using statistical tools such as regression analysis to identify trends in insolvency cases.

Ethical Considerations

The study will adhere to ethical research principles, ensuring participant confidentiality and obtaining informed consent.

FINDINGS AND DISCUSSION

Roles of Accountants in Insolvency Processes

Accountants are central to insolvency proceedings, serving as financial diagnosticians, strategists, and compliance facilitators. In Nigeria, their contributions are evident in the following areas:

1. Financial Reporting and Analysis. Accountants ensure accurate financial assessments, which are crucial for insolvency resolutions. In the case of Intercontinental Bank Plc, accountants played a pivotal role in identifying toxic assets and quantifying the extent of insolvency before the Central Bank of Nigeria intervened to orchestrate a merger with Access Bank (Sanusi, 2012).
2. Compliance with Regulatory Frameworks. In Nigeria, insolvency laws such as the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) require accountants to ensure compliance with statutory provisions during restructuring. For instance, during the insolvency and eventual restructuring of Etisalat Nigeria (now 9mobile), accountants facilitated compliance with creditor negotiations and the restructuring of financial statements to meet lender requirements (Adewale & Ojo, 2020).
3. Valuation and Stakeholder Communication. Accountants assess the value of assets and communicate effectively with creditors and stakeholders. In the Aero Contractors Limited restructuring, accountants were instrumental in asset valuation and in devising financial strategies that prevented liquidation.

Challenges Faced by Accountants in Nigeria

Several factors hinder accountants’ effectiveness during insolvency and restructuring in Nigeria:

1. Regulatory Bottlenecks. The fragmented nature of Nigerian insolvency regulations creates procedural inefficiencies. For example, the Oceanic Bank case revealed delays in regulatory approvals for restructuring, exacerbating insolvency losses (CBN Report, 2012).
2. Corruption and Ethical Issues. Ethical dilemmas often arise, particularly in managing stakeholder interests. Studies show that 45% of accountants in insolvency cases in Nigeria reported facing undue pressure to manipulate financial reports (Eze & Okoro, 2018).
3. Lack of Technology Adoption. The absence of advanced accounting technologies hinders efficiency. For example, during the liquidation of Skye Bank Plc, outdated accounting systems delayed the forensic analysis of accounts (Adetayo, 2021).
4. Cultural Resistance to Transparency. Cultural norms that favor informal conflict resolution over transparent financial disclosures pose challenges, particularly in family-owned enterprises.

Comparative Insights from Global Practices

Nigeria can draw lessons from global insolvency practices, particularly in developed economies such as:

1. United Kingdom. The UK’s Insolvency Act emphasizes the role of accountants as administrators, with a clear legal framework for restructuring. For example, the restructuring of Thomas Cook Group involved accountants utilizing advanced financial modeling tools to propose viable restructuring plans (White, 2022).
2. South Africa. The Companies Act of 2008 has been lauded for integrating sustainability into corporate restructuring. In the insolvency of Steinhoff International, accountants employed forensic auditing to uncover financial mismanagement, a practice that Nigeria could adopt to address corporate fraud (Nkosi, 2020).

Accounting Innovations and Emerging Trends

Emerging technologies and innovative accounting practices are reshaping insolvency processes globally, they include:

1. Blockchain and Forensic Accounting Tools. Blockchain technology has been adopted in the US and UK to enhance transparency in insolvency proceedings (Grant, 2021). Applying blockchain in Nigeria could mitigate fraud and increase stakeholder trust.
2. Sustainability and ESG Integration: There is a growing focus on incorporating environmental, social, and governance (ESG) criteria into restructuring plans. Accountants in Nigeria can adopt these frameworks to align with global trends.

Case Study: The Restructuring of 9mobile

In 2017, Etisalat Nigeria faced insolvency after defaulting on a $1.2 billion syndicated loan. This insolvency posed a significant risk to the telecommunications sector and creditors, including major Nigerian banks.

Accountants conducted a comprehensive review of the company’s financial position, identifying unsustainable debt levels and operational inefficiencies.

Accountants facilitated negotiations between the creditors and the board, leading to an agreement to restructure the company under the new name 9mobile.

Accountants ensured that the restructuring adhered to the guidelines of the Nigerian Communications Commission and CAMA.

The restructuring preserved the company’s operations, safeguarded 2,000 jobs, and maintained creditor relationships, showcasing accountants’ pivotal role in avoiding liquidation (Adewale & Ojo, 2020).

Statistical Insights

A report by PwC (2021) on corporate insolvency in Nigeria found that 60% of insolvency cases were resolved through restructuring rather than liquidation, with accountants playing a central role in these outcomes.

The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) recorded that between 2010 and 2020, 30% of insolvency cases in the banking sector were attributed to poor financial management, underscoring the need for skilled accountants in financial oversight.

According to Eze & Okoro (2018), firms with professional accountants involved in insolvency proceedings are 40% more likely to achieve successful restructuring outcomes.

RECOMMENDATIONS

To address the challenges identified and enhance the role of accountants in corporate insolvency and restructuring in Nigeria, the following recommendations are proposed:

i. Strengthen Insolvency Laws and Regulatory Frameworks. The Nigerian government should update and harmonize insolvency laws, such as the Companies and Allied Matters Act (CAMA) and the Bankruptcy Act, to reduce procedural delays and ambiguities.

Regulatory bodies, including the Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC) and the Financial Reporting Council of Nigeria (FRCN), should enforce compliance and enhance oversight mechanisms.

ii. Capacity Building for Accountants. Professional accounting bodies like the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nigeria (ICAN) and the Association of National Accountants of Nigeria (ANAN) should provide specialized training in insolvency and restructuring.

Training should focus on forensic accounting, financial modeling, valuation techniques, and negotiation skills to equip accountants with the expertise needed for complex insolvency cases.

iii. Promote Technological Integration. Accounting firms should adopt advanced technologies such as blockchain, artificial intelligence (AI), and forensic accounting tools to improve transparency, efficiency, and accuracy in insolvency processes.

Government and private-sector partnerships should invest in digitizing insolvency proceedings to enhance regulatory monitoring and reduce fraudulent practices.

iv. Encourage Collaboration Among Stakeholders. Foster collaboration between accountants, legal practitioners, financial analysts, and regulatory agencies to streamline insolvency and restructuring processes.

Establish multidisciplinary task forces for high-profile insolvency cases to leverage diverse expertise and perspectives.

v. Incorporate Sustainability and ESG Considerations. Accountants should integrate environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors into restructuring plans to align with global trends and ensure long-term sustainability of restructured entities.

Nigerian regulatory bodies should incentivize ESG reporting in insolvency resolutions to encourage responsible corporate behavior.

vi. Enhance Ethical Standards and Accountability. Accounting bodies should enforce stricter ethical guidelines to address conflicts of interest and ensure the independence of accountants in insolvency cases.

Organizations should establish internal controls and whistleblowing mechanisms to promote transparency and ethical practices during restructuring.

vii. Leverage Insights from Global Best Practices. Nigeria should adapt successful models from developed economies like the UK and South Africa, including pre-packaged insolvency arrangements and creditor-friendly restructuring frameworks.

Regulatory bodies should facilitate knowledge-sharing initiatives, such as workshops and international conferences, to expose Nigerian accountants to global innovations in insolvency management.

By implementing these recommendations, Nigeria can enhance the effectiveness of accountants in insolvency and restructuring processes, reduce systemic risks, and promote a more stable and sustainable business environment.

CONCLUSION

Corporate insolvency is an inevitable aspect of the business cycle, particularly in volatile and challenging environments such as Nigeria. Accountants play a pivotal role in managing these situations, acting as financial analysts, compliance officers, and strategic advisors during insolvency and restructuring processes. This study has demonstrated that the effectiveness of accountants is instrumental in determining the success of insolvency outcomes, from financial diagnosis and stakeholder communication to regulatory compliance and asset valuation.

However, Nigerian accountants face significant challenges, including fragmented regulatory frameworks, limited adoption of modern technologies, and ethical dilemmas. These issues, coupled with systemic inefficiencies and cultural resistance to transparency, often hinder the efficiency of insolvency and restructuring processes. Drawing from global best practices in countries such as the UK and South Africa, the study highlights the need for robust legal frameworks, capacity building, and technological integration to enhance the role of accountants.

Ultimately, improving Nigeria’s insolvency processes requires a multi-faceted approach involving policy reform, professional development, and stakeholder collaboration. By addressing existing challenges and adopting innovative practices, accountants can better navigate the complexities of corporate insolvency and contribute to sustainable business recovery and economic stability. This study underscores the critical need for further research into the intersection of accounting, insolvency, and governance, particularly in emerging economies.

REFERENCES

1. Adegbite, E. e. (2012). Corporate governance and accountability in emerging economies. Journal of Business Ethics, 114(4), 471–486.
2. Adewale, T; Ojo, A;. (2020). Case studies on insolvency and restructuring in Nigeria: A focus on telecommunications. Nigerian Business Review, 15(3), 45–62.
3. Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN). (2012). Post-consolidation audit report on distressed banks in Nigeria. Abuja: CBN Publications.
4. Deegan, C. (2014). Financial Accounting Theory. 4th Edition. McGraw-Hill Education.
5. Eze, P O; Okoro, N C;. (2018). Ethical challenges in corporate insolvency accounting in Nigeria. African Journal of Accounting, 9(1), 28–40.
6. sJones, M. (2020). Accounting for transparency in corporate insolvency. Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal, 33(5), 1230–1245.
7. Nkosi, P. (2020). Forensic accounting in corporate insolvency: A South African perspective. Journal of Emerging Markets, 12(2), 110–121.
8. Sanusi, L. S. (2012). Banking sector reforms and its impact on the Nigerian economy. Speech delivered at the University of Warwick Economic Summit, UK.
9. White, T. (2022). Restructuring strategies in global insolvency cases. International Journal of Corporate Law, 18(3), 199–217.