From Castle to Crypt: A Gothic Exploration of Shakespearean Drama and Victorian Fiction

From Castle to Crypt: A Gothic Exploration of Shakespearean Drama and Victorian Fiction

¹Tasmia Moslehuddin, ²Zareen Rafa Khan Aronee

¹Associate Professor, Manarat International University, MPhil Research Fellow, Bangladesh University of Professionals, Dhaka Bangladesh

²Assistant Teacher, Light Fair School, English Version, Dhaka, Bangladesh

DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.47772/IJRISS.2025.9020146

Received: 30 January 2025; Accepted: 05 February 2025; Published: 07 March 2025

ABSTRACT

This study critically examines the Gothic elements in two seminal Shakespearean tragedies, Macbeth and Hamlet, and two influential Victorian novels, Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre. It explores the interplay of Gothic themes, settings, and character development across these works, contextualizing them within the broader literary and historical frameworks of the Renaissance and Victorian eras. Employing a qualitative methodology that combines thematic and textual analysis, the research investigates the presence and evolution of critical Gothic motifs, including supernatural phenomena, psychological unrest, and moral decay. Through close analysis of these texts, the study elucidates how Gothic elements shape narrative atmosphere, influence character trajectories, and reflect broader cultural anxieties. The findings reveal how Gothic features persist across literary periods, evolving from the external, supernatural influences in Shakespeare’s plays to the more psychological and inward-focused Gothic elements in Victorian fiction. This comparative exploration enhances our understanding of the Gothic genre’s versatility and its continued relevance in addressing the darker facets of human experience.

Keywords: Gothic literature, Shakespearean tragedy, Victorian Gothic fiction, Supernatural elements, Psychological horror, Madness, Atmosphere and setting

INTRODUCTION

The Gothic genre has exerted a profound influence on literature since its inception, captivating audiences by delving into the darker facets of human nature, along with themes of the supernatural and psychological torment. Emerging in the 18th century with Horace Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto (1764), the Gothic tradition has evolved through various literary periods and across continents, leaving its imprint on both highbrow and popular literature. Characterized by eerie atmospheres, enigmatic settings, and a preoccupation with the macabre, the genre invites readers into a realm where terror, mystery, and the unknown are intricately interwoven into the narrative.

This study aims to reveal the intricate layers of Gothic elements found within these literary works, comparing the portrayal of the Gothic genre in both early modern and Victorian contexts. Through this analysis, we seek to deepen our understanding of the enduring appeal of Gothic literature and its significance in reflecting cultural and psychological concerns.

Background of the Study

The Gothic genre, celebrated for its exploration of eerie atmospheres, sinister landscapes, and the most disturbing facets of human existence, has enthralled readers and scholars for centuries. Its significance began with Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto, which introduced essential features of Gothic literature, such as haunted spaces, supernatural beings, and themes of decay and madness. Gothic literature frequently blurs the boundaries between the natural and the paranormal, delving into themes like madness, moral corruption, and the uncanny. This compels readers to confront their deepest anxieties and question the nature of reality.

This study investigates the manifestation of Gothic elements in two Shakespearean plays, Macbeth and Hamlet, as well as two Victorian novels, Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre. It aims to examine the evolution of Gothic literature from the Shakespearean era to the Victorian period, highlighting its adaptability and enduring significance. Through a comparative analysis of these texts, the study seeks to enhance our understanding of how Gothic elements shape the narratives and characters, reflecting the broader cultural and psychological concerns of their respective periods. This analysis will contribute to a more nuanced appreciation of Gothic literature’s influence on Shakespearean tragedy and Victorian fiction.

Statement of the Problem:

This research contrasts the representation of Gothic elements in two Shakespearean tragedies, Macbeth and Hamlet, with two Victorian novels, Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë and Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë. While Gothic literature has been widely studied, there is a gap in comparative analyses across these distinct literary periods.

The choice of the Shakespearean and Victorian eras is significant, as is the fascination with the Gothic marks. Shakespeare’s works explore themes of ambition, madness, and the supernatural, reflecting the anxieties of the Elizabethan era. In Macbeth, supernatural elements incite paranoia and guilt, while Hamlet’s ghost highlights themes of corruption and revenge.

Conversely, the Brontë sisters address the social and psychological constraints of their time in Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre. Their characters grapple with isolation, societal expectations, and a quest for autonomy within Gothic settings that symbolize emotional turmoil. The Brontës’ experiences of tragedy and struggle for independence resonate in their characters’ journeys through love and madness, intertwining with Gothic themes to critique societal structures regarding gender and class.

Thus, this study aims to critically examine the presence and significance of Gothic features in these four works.

Research Questions

The objective of this research is to investigate the following inquiries:

1. How do Gothic elements manifest in the selected works, and which specific aspects of the Gothic genre, such as the supernatural, madness, psychological horror, and atmosphere, are central to their narratives?
2. How do Gothic elements influence the overall atmosphere and setting of the works, and how do these elements contribute to the development of the characters and their psychological journeys within the narratives?
3. What are the key differences and similarities in portraying Gothic themes between the Shakespearean and Victorian periods, and how do these variations reflect the cultural, historical, and literary contexts of each era?

Objectives of the Study

The present study focuses on Macbeth and Hamlet as representative Shakespearean tragedies and Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre as Victorian novels. It aims to achieve the following objectives:

1. To analyze the presence of Gothic elements in selected works, focusing on motifs like the supernatural, madness, psychological torment, and atmospheric settings, and their contributions to the narrative and themes.
2. To evaluate how Gothic elements shape settings and character development, exploring their influence on the narrative’s physical and emotional landscapes and the psychological journeys of key characters.
3. To compare the representation of Gothic elements between the Shakespearean and Victorian eras, examining how cultural, historical, and social factors affect these motifs and their impact on narrative structure and themes.

The Rationale of the Study

Studying Gothic elements in literature is crucial for understanding how darkness, mystery, and the supernatural shape narratives and explore more profound psychological and societal issues. This research focuses on Shakespeare’s Macbeth and Hamlet, alongside the Victorian novels Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre, to compare their Gothic motifs and reveal how elements like supernatural forces, moral decay, and madness influence character and atmosphere in these works. By analyzing these texts across different literary periods, the study will enhance our understanding of the evolution of Gothic literature and its impact on storytelling.

Additionally, this evaluation will assess the reception and adaptation of Gothic themes within their historical contexts, providing insights into the genre’s enduring appeal and relevance in literary studies today.

Limitations of the Study

This research analyzes Gothic elements in Macbeth, Hamlet, Wuthering Heights, and Jane Eyre while acknowledging limitations. It focuses on selected Victorian and Shakespearean works, which may restrict broader applicability and overlook other significant Gothic literature. The subjective nature of identifying Gothic features can lead to varying interpretations among researchers. Additionally, the distinct cultural contexts and languages of the works may introduce biases in understanding these elements.

Findings related to Shakespearean and Victorian contexts may not extend to other literary periods, and the study does not explore the historical reception of the chosen works. While primarily literary, this inquiry recognizes the transcultural and multidisciplinary nature of Gothic studies, allowing for connections to art and architecture. Limitations in available materials may also affect historical contextualization. This paper aims to acknowledge these challenges, offering a nuanced perspective on Gothic features in the selected texts.

LITERATURE REVIEW

The Gothic concept has sparked significant interest among researchers due to its profound influence on human consciousness through themes of mystery, darkness, and the supernatural. This critical literature review examines existing scholarship, focusing on the Gothic features in William Shakespeare’s Macbeth and Hamlet and the works of the Brontë sisters, Emily and Charlotte, including Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre.

The Emergence of Gothic Literature (Late 18th Century)

The Gothic literary genre emerged in the late 18th century, incorporating dark and supernatural elements to evoke mystery, horror, and societal taboos. Gothic motifs, including haunted castles, ghosts, gloom, death, and madness, are evident not only in dedicated Gothic novels but also in Shakespeare’s tragedies and the Victorian novels of the Brontë sisters. Analyzing these Gothic elements reveals their symbolic meanings, cultural contexts, and artistic purposes.

Gothic Elements in Shakespeare’s Works

The supernatural elements in Shakespeare’s Macbeth and Hamlet propel the narrative and deepen the tragedies. In Macbeth, the witches and ghosts create an atmosphere steeped in mystery and prophecy, tempting Macbeth to commit murder based on their foretelling of power. Both Macbeth and Lady Macbeth embody the archetype of the Gothic villain, showcasing how ambition can lead to corruption. In contrast, the ghost’s appearance in Hamlet forces Hamlet to confront mortality and pursue existential truths, another hallmark of Gothic literature. Furthermore, additional Gothic features—such as eerie settings, grotesque imagery (like Yorick’s skull), and themes of madness—enhance Shakespeare’s Gothicism, shedding light on his tragic vision and fascination with humanity’s moral failings.

In Ghostly Presences and the Gothic in Shakespeare’s Hamlet, Spadaccini (1979) explores the Gothic undertones in Hamlet by focusing on the ghostly figure of King Hamlet. He examines how the presence of the ghost disrupts the natural order and introduces elements of horror, death, and the supernatural. Spadaccini discusses how the ghost not only embodies the Gothic tradition of spectral appearances but also represents the psychological terror that Hamlet experiences as he grapples with questions of revenge, mortality, and the afterlife.

Punter (1996) in The Literature of Terror: A History of Gothic Fictions from 1765 to the Present Day, briefly touches upon Shakespeare’s works, including Macbeth. He highlights how the play prefigures later Gothic fiction by portraying psychological torment, unnatural occurrences, and a haunting atmosphere. Punter specifically examines Lady Macbeth’s descent into madness as an early example of Gothic horror, driven by guilt and an unraveling mind, aligning the play with the Gothic’s fascination with mental disintegration and the supernatural.

Bao-feng & Xu-Liang (2016) analyze Macbeth’s Gothic settings, characters, and plots, highlighting how darkness creates a foreboding atmosphere. They point out that significant events, such as murders and the ghost of Banquo, occur under gloomy circumstances, emphasizing Macbeth’s moral corruption.

ÖĞÜTCÜ (2017) explores the macabre elements in Hamlet, examining how Shakespeare utilizes auditory and visual techniques to evoke Gothic catharsis. The paper discusses how the ghost’s appearance and Hamlet’s fluctuating beliefs manipulate the audience’s emotions, leading them to confront the irrational aspects of fear.

Gothic Elements in the Brontë Sisters’ Novels

The Brontë sisters employ the Gothic genre more subtly, using it to explore themes of gender and psychological complexity. In Jane Eyre, Thornfield Manor is a site of Gothic mystery, notably through the character of Bertha Rochester, the “madwoman” in the attic. Jane’s Gothic dream imagery and her rejection of Victorian gender constraints reflect her rebellious spirit. In Wuthering Heights, the bleak manor setting and the forbidden love between Heathcliff and Catherine are Gothic components that critique societal repression.

Qiao (2019) dissects the Gothic aspects of Wuthering Heights, focusing on supernatural characters and dark moor settings. The article argues that the novel’s Gothic elements enhance its controversial status and contribute to its lasting appeal. HAQUE (2016) similarly examines Wuthering Heights through its supernatural elements, depicting Catherine as a ghost and Heathcliff as a demonic figure. The paper asserts that the novel employs Gothic tropes like darkness, doomed love, and revenge, solidifying its place as a classic.

Srivastava (2014) analyzes how Charlotte Brontë integrates Gothic elements into Jane Eyre, creating a symbolic language that empowers female expression in Victorian England. This study discusses how the oppressive domestic spaces and the character of Bertha Mason represent societal suppression of female identity, while the imagery of moonlight and dreams underscores themes of self-determination.

Comparison:

Božoki (2017) explores the theme of duality in Gothic literature, particularly in the works of Shakespeare and the Brontë sisters. This analysis examines the use of doppelgängers, name repetition, and the contrasting settings of Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange, highlighting how these elements contribute to exploring internalized evil and character transformation.

The analysis of Gothic features in Macbeth, Hamlet, Wuthering Heights, and Jane Eyre reveals the genre’s rich complexity and ability to comment on deeper societal issues, including ambition, madness, and gender dynamics. While Shakespeare employs overt Gothic elements, the Brontë sisters often present them more subliminally, stemming from their characters’ psychological turmoil and rebellion. Together, these works contribute to the ongoing discourse surrounding Gothic literature and its significance across different historical contexts.

Theoretical Framework:

This research investigates the Gothic elements in two Shakespearean tragedies, Macbeth and Hamlet, alongside two Victorian novels, Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre. The analysis is grounded in a multidisciplinary theoretical framework that integrates Gothic literary theory, psychoanalytic theory, and feminist theory. These perspectives will comprehensively explore how Gothic conventions reveal more profound cultural, psychological, and social anxieties across different historical periods.

Gothic Literary Theory

Gothic literature, a genre that emerged in the late 18th century, is characterized by an emphasis on terror, the supernatural, psychological horror, and a preoccupation with the irrational and unknown. The core aspects of Gothic literature include haunted spaces, decay, and the blurring of boundaries between reality and the supernatural. The foundational works of Gothic literature, including Horace Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto (1764) and Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818), provide a conceptual framework to understand the use of Gothic elements in later works.

In this research, Gothic literary theory will be applied to:

Analyze how Shakespeare’s tragedies anticipate Gothic themes, particularly their use of supernatural forces, psychological instability, and morally ambiguous characters.

Examine how the Brontë sisters’ Victorian novels incorporate and adapt Gothic conventions, particularly with settings, character psychology, and narrative structure.

Psychoanalytic Theory

This research focuses on the analysis of Gothic elements in Macbeth, Hamlet, Wuthering Heights, and Jane Eyre, while acknowledging its limitations. It centers on selected Victorian and Shakespearean works, which may restrict the broader applicability of its findings and potentially overlook other significant Gothic literature. The subjective nature of identifying Gothic features can lead to varying interpretations among scholars. Additionally, the distinct cultural contexts and languages of these works may introduce biases in understanding these elements.

The findings related to Shakespearean and Victorian contexts may not be generalizable to other literary periods, and this study does not examine the historical reception of the selected works. While primarily literary, this inquiry recognizes the transcultural and multidisciplinary nature of Gothic studies, enabling connections to art and architecture. Limitations in available resources may also impact historical contextualization. This paper seeks to acknowledge these challenges and provide a nuanced perspective on Gothic features in the texts under consideration.

Feminist Theory

Feminist literary theory, which critiques the representation of gender and power dynamics in literature, is particularly relevant to the Gothic tradition. Many Gothic texts feature heroines confined by patriarchal structures or haunted by oppressive male figures, and feminist theorists like Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar have analyzed how these narratives explore women’s roles, autonomy, and resistance.

In the context of this research, feminist theory will be applied to:

Explore how Shakespeare’s female characters, such as Lady Macbeth and Ophelia, navigate Gothic spaces of power and madness. The portrayal of women’s ambition and their subsequent psychological collapse will be analyzed as both a reflection of and a reaction to societal expectations of women.

Examine the female protagonists of Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre through a feminist lens, focusing on their struggles for agency within the Gothic framework. The haunted spaces and repressive forces that shape the lives of Catherine Earnshaw and Jane Eyre will be viewed as metaphors for the broader struggles of women in Victorian society.

Intersections of Gothic Elements across Periods

A critical component of this framework involves examining how Gothic elements evolve across different historical contexts. In Shakespeare’s early modern tragedies, Gothic elements such as the supernatural are employed to explore moral and existential dilemmas in the context of political instability. In the Victorian period, the Brontë sisters adapt these Gothic motifs to reflect their time’s social and psychological concerns, including the tensions between class, gender, and the individual’s place in society.

This historical lens will be used to:

Compare Shakespeare’s plays’ supernatural and psychological decay to the more intimate and psychological Gothic in the Brontë sisters’ novels.

Trace the thematic continuities between Shakespeare’s tragedies and the Brontës’ novels, highlighting how Gothic elements are reshaped to address evolving concerns about human nature and social order.

By integrating Gothic literary theory, psychoanalytic theory, and feminist theory, this framework provides a multi-dimensional approach to analyzing Gothic elements in Macbeth, Hamlet, Wuthering Heights, and Jane Eyre. It emphasizes how these texts, despite their historical and generic differences, engage with Gothic conventions to explore enduring themes of fear, identity, and power. The framework will allow for a nuanced understanding of how Gothic elements reflect and critique their respective periods’ anxieties while offering a broader insight into the human condition.

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

Research Design

This research employs qualitative techniques to explore the Gothic elements in Macbeth, Hamlet, Wuthering Heights, and Jane Eyre. Qualitative analysis focuses on understanding the underlying meanings and experiences within texts, allowing for an in-depth exploration of the nuances within Gothic literature and the settings depicted in these works.

Methods Used:

Textual Analysis: Examining the texts’ specific language, imagery, and structural features to reveal how these elements contribute to the overall atmosphere and meaning.

Thematic Analysis: Identifying and analyzing recurring themes and patterns within the texts to provide insight into Gothic elements’ broader cultural and psychological implications.

Comparative Analysis: A comparative examination will also investigate how Gothic outlines impact the selected works’ overall ambience, settings, and character arcs. This comparative method enhances understanding of the differences between Victorian and Shakespearean literature, shedding light on how the Gothic tradition evolves across different literary periods and responds to distinct societal and cultural contexts.

Sampling

This study adopts a qualitative approach with purposeful sampling to explore Gothic elements in Shakespearean drama and Victorian fiction.

Hypothesis Development: Initial research utilizes books and online sources to refine hypotheses and objectives.

Selection Criteria: Texts are selected for their embodiment of Gothic themes, ensuring a range of genre perspectives.

Shakespearean Works: Macbeth and Hamlet showcase Gothic traits through supernatural elements and dark atmospheres.

Victorian Works: Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre merge Gothic motifs with themes of love, passion, and societal constraints.

Instrumentation

The instrumentation for this research includes:

Internet Resources: Online platforms are essential for enhancing the literary base and expanding knowledge and contextual understanding. Scholarly discussions, critical analyses, and additional perspectives on Gothic themes in the selected texts are accessed through these resources.

Technological Tools: Tools such as spell checkers, MS Office, Grammarly, and paraphrasing applications are employed to enhance the quality of the research. These resources ensure the accuracy and clarity of the content while improving language, grammar, and presentation style.

Data Collection

This qualitative study aims to understand how Gothic elements are portrayed in Macbeth, Hamlet, Wuthering Heights, and Jane Eyre. The data collection process involves:

Primary Sources: Original texts provide substantial data for analysis. The exploration of atmospheres within these literary masterpieces allows a deeper understanding of the authors’ use of Gothic elements.

Focus Areas: The settings, characters, themes, actions, and relationships within the selected works are examined closely to gather primary data, facilitating an in-depth analysis of Gothic portrayals by Shakespeare and the Brontë sisters.

Secondary Sources: Academic journals, online articles, and general internet searches supplement primary data. This dual-source approach ensures a balanced subject analysis, providing background, academic interpretations, and contemporary perspectives on Gothic elements in the selected texts.

Data Analysis Process

Using a qualitative approach, this thesis delves into the Gothic characteristics of Macbeth, Hamlet, Wuthering Heights, and Jane Eyre. The data analysis process involves a comprehensive method, including:

Close Readings: Conduct thorough readings of significant passages, character dialogues, and thematic developments to extract qualitative insights into how Gothic elements manifest.

Thematic Coding: Applying thematic coding to classify and analyze recurring Gothic themes within the texts, identifying specific elements like the supernatural, madness, and macabre. This process enables a nuanced understanding of how these themes contribute to the Gothic atmosphere and narrative trajectory.

Character Analysis: Focusing on key characters in the selected works to explore how Gothic elements influence their development. This includes examining character interactions with Gothic settings and the impact of these environments on their psychological and emotional journeys.

Comparative Analysis: Comparing Gothic principles across Shakespearean plays and Victorian novels, highlighting parallels and differences in depicting Gothic themes, atmosphere, and character dynamics. This relative analysis facilitates a deeper understanding of the evolution and interpretation of the Gothic genre across different literary periods.

Cultural Contextualization: Examining the historical and cultural contexts of the Victorian and Shakespearean eras to situate Gothic elements within their appropriate frameworks. This qualitative investigation will illuminate how cultural values, norms, and beliefs influence certain Gothic representations in the selected texts.

Through these qualitative approaches, this research aims to uncover the nuances and complexities of Gothic elements in the chosen works, providing a critical overview that extends beyond superficial genre characteristics.

ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION

The chosen works—Macbeth, Hamlet, Wuthering Heights, and Jane Eyre—are analyzed through the lens of Gothic themes, providing the foundation for this thesis. Utilizing a qualitative study methodology, this examination aims to uncover profound insights regarding the expression of Gothic traits and their impact on the overall atmosphere and character development in each narrative.

Thematic Analysis

Examination of Gothic Themes

Macbeth and Hamlet

The play Macbeth’s setting—marked by stormy nights, eerie castles, and unnatural darkness—enhances the Gothic ambiance. It starts with thunder and lightning:

“[A wasteland near the royal castle at Fores. Thunder and lightning, enter the three Witches.]

First Witch

Where hast thou been, sister?

Second Witch

Killing swine.

Third Witch

Sister, where thou?”  (Macbeth, 1.1.1-3)

Then, when the witches meet Macbeth:

“First Witch

All hail, Macbeth. Hail to thee, Thane of Glamis.

Second Witch

All hail, Macbeth. Hail to thee, Thane of Cawdor.

Third Witch

All hail, Macbeth, that shalt be king hereafter. “ (Macbeth, 1.1.48-50)

The play’s Gothic elements are rooted in themes of ambition, fate, and the supernatural. The witches represent harbingers of doom, with their prophecies propelling Macbeth toward his moral disintegration. The witches’ cryptic prophecies serve as supernatural forces that manipulate Macbeth’s ambition, embodying the Gothic theme of predestined doom. Their eerie presence and chant-like speech create an ominous and unsettling atmosphere that reinforces the play’s supernatural undercurrents.

His ambition, stirred by their cryptic foretelling, leads to a psychological unraveling, with key moments such as Lady Macbeth’s sleepwalking scene reflecting a Gothic obsession with guilt and madness (Li & Zhao, 2016), as it is stated in the text:

LADY MACBETH

Out, damned spot! out, I say!—One: two: why, then, ’tis time to do’t.—Hell is murky!—Fie, my lord, fie! A soldier, and afeard? What need we fear who knows it, when none can call our power to account?—Yet who would have thought the old man to have had so much blood in him? ((Macbeth, 5.1.25-30)

Lady Macbeth’s sleepwalking scene vividly demonstrates Gothic themes of guilt and madness; she obsessively reenacts the crime, tormented by imaginary bloodstains that she cannot erase. Her descent into insanity aligns with the Gothic fascination with moral decay and psychological breakdown as consequences of unchecked ambition.

Through a psychoanalytic lens, Macbeth’s hallucinations of the dagger and Banquo’s ghost suggest a struggle with his subconscious guilt, illustrating Freud’s notion of repressed desires manifesting in grotesque, symbolic forms. This reflects classic Gothic tropes, wherein characters experience horrifying visions that blur the boundaries of reality. His increasing paranoia, insomnia, and erratic behavior intensify the sense of psychological torment and fear, which are hallmarks of Gothic narratives. Macbeth’s dagger hallucination scene is one of the most iconic Gothic moments in Macbeth, embodying supernatural horror, psychological torment, and fate as it is seen:

Is this a dagger which I see before me, The handle toward my hand? Come, let me clutch thee! I have thee not, and yet I see thee still. Art thou not, fatal vision, sensible To feeling as to sight? or art thou but A dagger of the mind, a false creation, Proceeding from the heat-oppressed brain? (Macbeth, 2.1.33-39)

Macbeth’s descent into madness is highlighted as he hallucinates Banquo’s ghost, symbolizing his guilt.

Macbeth: “Thou canst not say I did it. Never shake thy gory locks at me!” (Macbeth, 3.4.50-51)

Feminist theory effectively examines Lady Macbeth’s bold challenge to traditional gender roles, as she skillfully manipulates Macbeth to attain power. Yet, her tragic descent into madness serves as a chilling reminder of the Victorian notion of hysteria, which punished female ambition. Lady Macbeth’s sleepwalking and anguished confessions embody a relentless Gothic fixation on guilt and psychological anguish. Her desperate need to admit her sins in a delirious state epitomizes the Gothic motif of an unburied crime haunting the guilty conscience. The phrase “Hell is murky!” powerfully encapsulates her entrapment in a nightmarish existence filled with sin and ceaseless torment, underscoring Gothic themes of punishment and moral decay.

Both Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are inexorably haunted by their immoral acts; they experience spectral visions and unnatural events that lay bare their profound guilt. Central to Gothic literature is the theme of moral decay leading to destruction and death, where characters are often subjected to the agonizing consequences of their psychological unraveling.

Themes of death, vengeance, and madness infuse the narrative with a sense of Gothic dread in the tragedy Hamlet. Hamlet’s encounter with the ghost places him in a moral quandary, and his philosophical musings reflect Gothic preoccupations with existential uncertainty and mortality. The play evokes fear through both auditory and visual techniques (Öğütcü, 2017), with the supernatural presence of King Hamlet’s ghost amplifying Hamlet’s psychological turmoil. As it is found in the text:

The bell then beating one…

Enter Ghost.    (1.1.46)

Barnardo: “In the same figure, like the King that’s dead.” (Hamlet, 1.1.48)

Then the speech of Horatio also creates fear in the audience:

Horatio: Most like. It (harrows) me with fear and wonder. (Hamlet, 1.1.51)

Then in another scene,

Barnardo: How now, Horatio, you tremble and look pale.

Is not this something more than fantasy? (Hamlet, 1.1.64)

From these lines it gets clear that the ghost of King Hamlet appears to the guards, establishing an ominous Gothic atmosphere. The appearance of King Hamlet’s ghost exemplifies a quintessential element of Gothic literature, skillfully crafting an atmosphere filled with fear, uncertainty, and the supernatural. Horatio’s reaction—“it harrows me with fear and wonder”—powerfully illustrates that ghosts in Gothic narratives often represent unresolved issues, trauma, and the quest for divine justice.

The anxious and trembling Horatio, a figure embodying rationality, underscores how the supernatural disrupts the normal world—a defining characteristic of Gothic horror. Furthermore, the chilling setting of a misty night on the castle ramparts intensifies the eerie and ominous tone typical of Gothic scenarios, reminiscent of haunted castles and forsaken ruins.

The existence of ghost is found when Hamlet along with the Queen sees the Ghost:

Hamlet:  On him, on him! Look you how pale he glares.

His form and cause conjoined, preaching to stones, Would make them capable.

[To the Ghost. ] Do not look upon me (Hamlet, 3.4.142-145)

In this pivotal moment, Hamlet encounters the ghost, while Queen Gertrude remains oblivious to its presence. This discrepancy raises a profound Gothic question: is the ghost a genuine supernatural being, or is it simply a figment of Hamlet’s deteriorating mind? The ghost’s stark, pale visage serves as a striking reflection of Hamlet’s psychological unraveling, underscoring the Gothic theme of the indistinct boundary between sanity and madness.

The ghost’s eerie presence—not only speaks to Hamlet but also warns and commands him—instills a sense of horror and existential uncertainty that is integral to Gothic literature. The ghost functions as an omen of doom, much like supernatural entities in Gothic literature that appear as harbingers of fate, guilt, or unresolved vengeance.

From a Gothic literary theory perspective, the ghost functions as a device to explore the tensions between the known and the unknown. Psychoanalytically, Hamlet’s vacillation between action and inaction can be seen as the manifestation of an internal struggle with his Oedipal complex and moral conscience.

Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre

The moors in Wuthering Heights act as a Gothic backdrop, mirroring the turbulent emotions of its characters. Heathcliff’s obsessive love for Catherine transcends death, and her spectral return highlights themes of eternal love and revenge (Fu, 2013).

Through a historical lens, Heathcliff’s outcast status can be seen as a critique of Victorian society’s rigid class structures, while psychoanalytically, his fixation on Catherine suggests unresolved desires and traumas from his childhood abandonment.

At the very beginning, the ghost is seen by Lockwood, the novel’s narrator. Lockwood, staying overnight at Wuthering Heights, is in a bedroom that once belonged to Catherine Earnshaw. He finds old books with her name inscribed and begins reading. As he dozes off, he has a terrifying dream in which Catherine’s ghost appears outside the window, pleading:

Catherine’s ghost: “Let me in—let me in! I’m come home: I’d lost my way on the moor!” (Brontë, Ch. 3)

This invocation of her restless spirit exemplifies the Gothic motif of haunting and the interplay between love and mortality. Catherine’s spectral wandering across the moors serves as a potent metaphor for an overwhelming love that surpasses the boundaries of death. The representation of the restless dead resonates with central Gothic themes, invoking both fear and a poignant sense of longing.

Chapter 29 captures Heathcliff’s profound obsession: “I cannot live without my life! I cannot live without my soul!” (Brontë, Ch. 29). His fixation on Catherine endures even after her death, collapsing the distinctions between romantic devotion and the macabre. His intense grief and his fervent desire for reunion, even in death, reflect a gothic fascination with death-driven romance and psychological anguish. The act of exhuming Catherine’s body and his yearning for her spirit encapsulate a fixation on decay, loss, and spectral love prevalent in Gothic literature.

Heathcliff’s subsequent vision of Catherine’s ghost further accentuates this theme: “I tell you I have nearly attained my heaven, and that of others is altogether unvalued and uncovered by me!” (Brontë, Ch. 34). His longing to achieve a metaphysical union with the dead illustrates the Gothic trope of doomed passion and supernatural preoccupation. This is reinforced when Heathcliff cries:

“Be with me always—take any form—drive me mad! Only do not leave me in this abyss, where I cannot find you!” (Brontë, Ch. 16),

The encapsulating motifs of psychological torment, possession, and supernatural entrapment can be found through this speech.

In Jane Eyre, the Gothic setting of Thornfield Hall, with its hidden secrets and the character of Bertha Mason, symbolizes the repressive forces Jane faces. Bertha, often viewed through a feminist lens, represents the “madwoman in the attic,” embodying the repressed desires and fears of Victorian women (Griesinger, 1989).
The Gothic tension between Jane’s quest for autonomy and the oppressive, mysterious atmosphere of Thornfield reflects a broader struggle for female independence within a patriarchal society.

In Chapter 26, Jane’s depiction of Bertha underscores the Gothic archetype of the ‘madwoman in the attic’:

“In the deep shade, at the farther end of the room, a figure ran backward and forwards. What it was, whether beast or human being, one could not at first sight tell.” (Brontë, Ch. 26).

Bertha symbolizes repressed female rage and embodies the Victorian anxieties surrounding hysteria. Her ambiguous characterization introduces a sense of monstrosity, reinforcing themes of social confinement and hidden horrors, which are hallmarks of Gothic fiction. The Gothic architecture of Thornfield Hall itself embodies these themes through its concealment of dark secrets that jeopardize Jane’s autonomy.

Bertha’s climactic act of arson, setting Thornfield ablaze, further amplifies Gothic motifs of vengeance, destruction, and the disintegration of patriarchal structures.

Chapter 11 features Jane’s unsettling encounter:

“While I paced softly on, the last sound I expected to hear in so still a region, a laugh, struck my ear.” (Brontë, Ch. 11).

This disembodied laughter contributes to the oppressive atmosphere of Thornfield Hall, employing a classic Gothic device that evokes fear and uncertain dread. It signals the presence of an unseen force within the estate, ominously foreshadowing Bertha Mason’s revelation and Jane’s subsequent psychological confrontation.

Rochester’s symbolic remark regarding Thornfield’s curse,

“I am no better than the old lightning-struck chestnut tree in Thornfield orchard.” (Brontë, Ch. 23), further highlights Gothic fatalism. The tree’s dramatic destruction mirrors the impending doom following Jane’s acceptance of Rochester’s proposal, reinforcing the motifs of destruction and unnatural forces.

Both Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre employ these Gothic motifs to explore themes of death, obsession, psychological horror, supernatural visitations, and the entrapment of women within oppressive societal structures, thereby solidifying their significance in the Gothic literary canon.

Impact of Gothic Themes on Character Journeys and Story Development

Macbeth and Hamlet

Macbeth’s ambition drives him into a Gothic spiral of guilt and paranoia. His visions of Banquo’s ghost and the witches’ prophecies signify a blurring of reality and illusion, illustrating how the supernatural elements are closely tied to his psychological degradation (Mydla, 2009).
Hamlet’s internal conflict escalates under the ghost’s demands, leading him into madness and existential despair. His soliloquies reflect his profound Gothic struggle with death, vengeance, and his sense of self (Townshend, 2008). The spectral presence of his father serves as a constant reminder of the unresolved past and the ambiguity of revenge.

Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre

Heathcliff’s journey is driven by his obsessive, Gothic love for Catherine. The moors reflect his emotional volatility and descent into a destructive passion. His eventual demise underscores the Gothic theme of love as a force that transcends life and death, but one that is also self-destructive (Panait-Ioncică, 2022).
Jane’s quest for independence in the face of Gothic challenges at Thornfield Hall underscores the transformative power of the Gothic. Bertha Mason’s presence represents both the literal and symbolic barriers to Jane’s autonomy, and her ability to escape these constraints reflects the novel’s engagement with feminist themes (Srivastava, 2014).

Parallels and Differences in Gothic Themes across Periods

Shakespearean Gothic:

In Macbeth and Hamlet, supernatural forces like witches and ghosts function as key Gothic elements that mirror the characters’ inner moral and existential struggles. The psychological complexity of these characters reflects the Elizabethan preoccupation with fate and power, with Gothic elements highlighting their moral decay (Li & Zhao, 2016).

Victorian Gothic:

In contrast, the Gothic in Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre shifts to personal and societal conflicts, especially those surrounding identity, madness, and repression. The role of the Gothic in these works critiques the social constraints of the time, particularly regarding gender roles and class structures. While Shakespearean Gothic emphasizes existential dread, Victorian Gothic focuses more on individual and societal struggles (Mourra, 2017; Galani, 2022).

Cultural and Literary Contexts

Shakespearean Period:

Gothic themes in Macbeth and Hamlet reflect the societal anxieties of the Elizabethan era, where ambition, power, and the supernatural were sources of fascination and fear. The plays grapple with the darker aspects of human nature, with ghosts and witches serving as representations of these anxieties.

Victorian Period:

Victorian Gothic literature, as seen in Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre, mirrors the cultural and social upheavals of the 19th century. Themes of isolation, madness, and repressed emotions speak to the period’s concerns about gender roles, class, and the constraints of societal expectations. The supernatural in these novels often symbolizes the characters’ inner struggles against these societal forces.

Textual Analysis

Macbeth and Hamlet:

The eerie Scottish moors and supernatural elements like the witches create a pervasive Gothic atmosphere, with Macbeth’s hallucinations illustrating his psychological descent. The Gothic tension between fate and free will is central to the play’s atmosphere (Li & Zhao, 2016).
Elsinore Castle, with its ghostly presence and themes of betrayal, amplifies Hamlet’s inner turmoil. The Gothic setting of the castle reflects the decay and corruption within the royal family, mirroring Hamlet’s own psychological conflict (Öğütcü, 2017).

Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre:

The moors surrounding Wuthering Heights mirror the Gothic emotional landscape of the characters. The supernatural appearance of Catherine’s ghost heightens the Gothic atmosphere, with love and obsession driving Heathcliff’s destructive actions (Fu, 2013).

Thornfield Hall’s oppressive atmosphere reflects the Gothic struggle for identity and freedom. Bertha Mason’s presence embodies the Gothic theme of repressed desires and societal constraints on women, with Jane’s journey toward independence symbolizing the triumph over these forces (Griesinger, 1989).

The juxtaposition of Shakespeare’s Gothic motifs with those utilized by Emily and Charlotte Brontë unveils significant contrasts and continuities in the exploration of human nature and societal issues across distinct literary contexts. In Shakespeare’s works, particularly in Macbeth and Hamlet, Gothic elements are predominantly framed by external influences such as ambition, fate, supernatural phenomena, and moral ramifications. The texts are steeped in the Elizabethan preoccupation with the macabre, where spectral apparitions, prophetic insights, and ominous portents function as catalysts for narrative progression and reflections of ethical dilemmas. Shakespeare’s deployment of Gothicism accentuates the tension between human agency and divine orchestration, crafting a universe wherein characters grapple with haunting external forces and the consequential weight of their decisions.

Conversely, the Gothic narrative in the works of Emily and Charlotte Brontë—exemplified in Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre—redirects focus toward the internal psychological and emotional realms of its characters. The Brontës adeptly employ Gothic tropes—such as desolate settings, brooding protagonists, and motifs of madness and entrapment—to excavate the complexities of identity, trauma, and societal repression. In Wuthering Heights, Emily Brontë embodies a vortex of raw emotionality and primal drives, integrating Gothic themes with the untamed natural environment and the intricacies of interpersonal dynamics. Conversely, Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre harnesses Gothic conventions—evident in the mysterious ambiance of Thornfield Hall and the enigmatic figure of Mr. Rochester—to interrogate themes of autonomy, ethical integrity, and the quest for self-actualization against a backdrop of social stratification.

While Shakespearean Gothic is characterized by the influence of external supernatural forces and the repercussions of moral transgressions, the Brontës’ interpretation skews towards introspection, foregrounding the psychological distortions and emotional fallout stemming from societal constraints and personal trauma. While spectral hauntings and prophetic visions torment Shakespeare’s tragic figures, the protagonists in the Brontë narratives grapple with the burdens of their histories, desires, and the oppressive frameworks surrounding them. Despite these divergent emphases, both Shakespeare and the Brontës adeptly wield Gothic elements to elucidate the darker dimensions of human experience—be it through the external specters of fate and retribution or the internal shadows of the psyche. Collectively, their oeuvres exemplify the enduring adaptability of Gothic literature as a vehicle for probing the complexities of human existence, effectively bridging the dichotomies of external and internal, past and present, and the universal versus the particular.

FINDINGS AND RESULTS

Gothic Features in Macbeth and Hamlet

Both Macbeth and Hamlet feature Gothic themes that significantly enhance their atmospheric tension and thematic depth.

The supernatural elements are evident, mainly through the presence of the three witches who prophesy Macbeth’s rise to power. Their unsettling presence and cryptic predictions create a palpable sense of dread throughout the play. Macbeth’s visions, particularly the ghost of Banquo, symbolize his moral depravity and descent into madness.

The appearance of King Hamlet’s ghost drives the plot forward, prompting Hamlet to seek revenge for his murder. The dark atmosphere of Elsinore Castle enhances the themes of death, madness, and corruption. Hamlet’s frequent contemplation of mortality, especially in his soliloquies, adds to the Gothic sensibility of the narrative.

Gothic Elements in Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre

In the Victorian novels Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre, Gothic elements are integral to their narrative structures and thematic explorations.

The remote, desolate setting of the Yorkshire moors contributes to the novel’s bleak atmosphere. Ghostly apparitions especially that of Catherine, reinforce haunting and eternal love themes. Heathcliff’s brooding, nearly satanic character embodies the Byronic archetype, heightening the Gothic appeal.

The mysterious setting of Thornfield Hall, with its hidden secrets and the presence of Bertha Mason, creates a definitive Gothic atmosphere. Themes of madness, isolation, and supernatural occurrences contribute to the overall Gothic tone of the narrative.

Impact of Gothic Elements on Atmosphere and Character Development

The Gothic elements in these works significantly shape their atmospheres and influence character development.
The pervasive dread and supernatural circumstances highlight Macbeth’s moral decline and eventual downfall. The Gothic atmosphere amplifies the tragic trajectory of the protagonist, illustrating the corrupting power of unchecked ambition.
The Gothic ambiance underscores themes of death and decay. The ghost’s presence and Hamlet’s musings on mortality deepen his existential crisis, contributing to the play’s exploration of madness and revenge.

The Gothic landscape serves as a reflection of the tumultuous emotions and destructive relationships of the characters. The wild moors embody Heathcliff’s ferocity and the tragic love shared between him and Catherine, deepening the novel’s exploration of vengeance and madness. Similarly, the Gothic settings and enigmatic elements of Thornfield Hall are crucial to Jane’s journey of self-discovery and empowerment. The oppressive atmosphere tests her morals and ultimately fosters her growth and assertion of identity.

Similarities and Differences in Gothic Depictions

The Shakespearean plays and Victorian novels display both parallels and differences in their depiction of Gothic themes.

Both Macbeth and Hamlet feature supernatural elements that drive the narrative and develop the characters, creating an atmosphere of fear and uncertainty. Similarly, Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre incorporate ghostly apparitions and supernatural occurrences that shape the characters’ experiences and plotlines (Desmet & Williams, 2009).

Shakespeare’s Gothic elements often explore themes of ambition, vengeance, and the supernatural’s influence on human fate, reflecting the Elizabethan interest in metaphysical and moral implications of power (Taylor, 2019).

In contrast, the Victorian Gothic, as seen in Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre, emphasizes psychological depth, exploring themes of madness, repression, and the struggle for identity within a rapidly changing society. This form of Gothic often critiques social morals, gender roles, and the effects of industrialization (Wolfreys, 2006).

Cultural and Literary Impact of Gothic Themes

The Gothic elements in these works have profoundly influenced the culture and literature of their respective eras.

Elizabethan Era and Victorian Era:

Shakespeare’s use of Gothic themes in Macbeth and Hamlet contributes to exploring human nature, ambition, guilt, and vengeance, resonating with contemporary audiences and influencing subsequent literature. His integration of supernatural and psychological elements laid the groundwork for dramatic works that followed.

The Gothic features in Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre reflect and respond to societal anxieties during significant social and technological change. Their examination of psychological trauma, the supernatural, and critiques of societal norms contributed to the evolution of Gothic literature, emphasizing themes of madness, identity, and the uncanny. This focus on the inner worlds and the darker aspects of human nature resonated with readers and solidified the enduring popularity of Gothic literature.

Hence, this thesis employed a qualitative research method to explore Gothic features in two Shakespearean plays—Macbeth and Hamlet—and two Victorian novels—Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre. The analysis focused on the impact of Gothic elements on atmosphere, setting, character development, and the distinct portrayals of Gothic themes across these different literary periods.

The investigation revealed that in both the Shakespearean and Victorian works, Gothic elements play a pivotal role in shaping the narrative’s mood and the psychological depth of the characters. Macbeth and Hamlet emphasize supernatural occurrences and moral dilemmas, while Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre focus on emotional conflicts, societal constraints, and identity struggles. The interplay of Gothic motifs—from ghostly apparitions and isolated settings to themes of madness and ambition—demonstrates the genre’s adaptability and capacity to reflect individual and societal concerns.

Overall, this thesis demonstrated how Gothic features enrich these works’ narrative complexity and thematic depth. By tracing the transformation of the Gothic genre across literary periods, the findings highlight its enduring appeal and relevance, proving that Gothic literature remains a powerful tool for exploring the darker aspects of the human experience.

CONCLUSION

This analysis offers a polished examination of the essential role that Gothic elements play in Shakespeare’s Macbeth and Hamlet, as well as in the Victorian classics Wuthering Heights and Jane Eyre. It effectively demonstrates how these features not only shape the atmosphere but also enhance characters’ psychological development and deepen thematic resonance. Shakespeare’s exploration of ambition, vengeance, and the supernatural aligns with the Elizabethan preoccupation with fate and moral accountability, while the Victorian Gothic skillfully navigates the intricate complexities of psychological trauma and identity in a rapidly evolving society.

Through a comparative lens, it becomes apparent that Shakespeare grapples with external forces such as destiny, the supernatural and divine justice. In contrast, the Victorian Gothic delves into the internal struggles of the human psyche and the constraints of societal expectations. Ultimately, Gothic literature emerges as a powerful and adaptable medium, capable of unraveling the intricacies of human nature while reflecting the anxieties of its time. Its enduring significance lies in its ability to transcend eras, evolving in response to diverse cultural contexts while continuing to resonate with universal truths about the human condition.

REFERENCES

1. Appel, I. S. (2003). “Present fears” and “horrible imaginings”: Gothic elements in Shakespearean tragedy.
2. Božoki, B. (2017). The Gothic literary complex in Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights (Doctoral dissertation, University of Rijeka, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Department of English Language and Literature).
3. Brontë, C. (1847). Jane Eyre: An autobiography. Smith, Elder & Co.
4. Brontë, E. (1847). Wuthering Heights. Smith, Elder & Co.
5. Desmet, C., & Williams, A. (2009). Shakespearean Gothic. University of Wales Press.
6. Diederich, N. A. (2010). Gothic doppelgangers and discourse: Examining the doubling practice of (re)marriage in Jane Eyre. Nineteenth-Century Gender Studies, 6(3).
7. Fu, H. (2013). An interpretation of Emily Brontë’s Gothic complex in Wuthering Heights. Studies in Literature and Language, 6(3), 53-59.
8. Galani, N. (2022). Jane Eyre as a female Gothic novel. Vidhyayana: An International Multidisciplinary Peer-Reviewed E-Journal, 8(2).
9. Griesinger, E. A. (1989). Before and after Jane Eyre: The female Gothic and some modern variations (Doctoral dissertation). Vanderbilt University.
10. Groom, N. (2014). The English literary tradition: Shakespeare to the Gothic. In A companion to J.R.R. Tolkien (pp. 286-302).
11. Haque, F. (n.d.). Wuthering Heights represents the perfect theme of Gothic novel by Emily Brontë.
12. Hamlet (Full text). (n.d.). Acadia University. Retrieved from https://socrates.acadiau.ca/courses/engl/rcunningham/resources/Shpe/Hamlet.pdf
13. Hewitt, N. A. (2013). “Something old and dark has got its way”: Shakespeare’s influence in the Gothic literary tradition.
14. Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë. (1847, December 21). Full Text Archive. Retrieved from https://www.fulltextarchive.com
15. Li, B. F., & Zhao, X. L. (2016). An analysis of Gothic features in Macbeth. Sino-US English Teaching, 13(12), 971-976.
16. Macbeth (Full text). (n.d.). Retrieved from https://shakespeare.mit.edu/macbeth/full.html
17. Massé, M. A. (2012). Psychoanalysis and the Gothic. In A new companion to the Gothic (pp. 307-320).
18. Moura, C. N. D. (2017). A walk with Catherine and Jane: The exposure of Gothic conventions in Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights and Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre.
19. Mulvey-Roberts, M. (Ed.). (1998). The handbook to Gothic literature. NYU Press.
20. Mydla, J. A. (2009). Spectres of Shakespeare: Appropriations of Shakespeare in the early English Gothic (No. 2680). Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Śląskiego.
21. Öğütcü, M. (2017). The ‘Gothic’ in Hamlet: The role of the macabre in creating cathartic horror. DTCF Journal, 57(1), 138-156.
22. Panait-Ionciucă, D. (2022). Gothic structures of being in Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights. Dialogos, 23(39), 196-204.
23. Punter, D. (1996). The literature of terror: A history of Gothic fictions from 1765 to the present day (2nd ed.). Routledge.
24. Qiao, W. (2019). How is Wuthering Heights a Gothic novel? International Journal of English, Literature and Social Sciences, 4(5), 1578-1583.
25. Serra Ros, X. (2016). Shakespeare as predecessor of Gothic fiction: The female figures in Hamlet.
26. Skjaldardóttir, G. (2012). Elements of the Gothic: Falling from nature in Wuthering Heights (Doctoral dissertation).
27. Smith, A. (2013). Gothic literature. Edinburgh University Press.
28. Snodgrass, M. E. (2014). Encyclopedia of Gothic literature. Infobase Publishing.
29. Spadaccini, N. (1979). Ghostly presences and the Gothic in Shakespeare’s Hamlet. Shakespeare Studies Journal, 17, 25-42.
30. Srivastava, A. (2014). Jane Eyre as a female Gothic novel. Inquiries Journal, 6(4).
31. Stupňanová, J. (n.d.). Gothic elements in Scottish literature.
32. Taylor, G. (2019). Shakespeare’s early Gothic Hamlet. Critical Survey, 31(1-2), 4-25.
33. Tine, E. P. (2024). Gothic experiences in Jane Eyre, Wuthering Heights, and The Tenant of Wildfell Hall. ESI Preprints, 20(11), 69-69.
34. Townshend, D. (2008). Gothic and the ghost of Hamlet. In Gothic Shakespeares (pp. 78-115). Routledge.
35. Wagner, T. (2013). Gothic and the Victorian home. In The Gothic world (pp. 110-120). Routledge.
36. Wiśniewska, D. J. (2002). Supernatural agents of the unconscious mind: The Gothic mode in Hamlet and Macbeth. Acta Universitatis Lodziensis. Folia Litteraria Anglica (5).
37. Wolfreys, J. (2006). Victorian Gothic. In Teaching the Gothic (pp. 62-77). London: Palgrave Macmillan UK.
38. Wuthering Heights. (1995). Emily Brontë. UBS Publishers’ Distributors Ltd.