Halal Total Quality Management: Enhancing Standards in the Malaysian Tourism Industry

Halal Total Quality Management: Enhancing Standards in the Malaysian Tourism Industry

Wahizan Saidin¹, Irwan Ibrahim*², Azilah Anis³

¹Graduate Student, Department of Postgraduate and Professional Studies, Faculty of Business and Management, University Teknologi MARA, Malaysia

²Research Fellow, Malaysia Institute of Transport (MITRANS), university Teknologi Mara, Lecturer, Department of Technology and Supply Chain Management Studies, Faculty of Business and Management, UiTM Puncak Alam, Selangor, Malaysia

³Lecturer, Department of Technology and Supply Chain Management Studies, Faculty of Business and Management, UiTM Puncak Alam, Selangor, Malaysia

*Corresponding Author

DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.47772/IJRISS.2025.9010255

Received: 14 January 2025; Accepted: 18 January 2025; Published: 17 February 2025

ABSTRACT

This study examines the integration of Halal Total Quality Management (TQM) in Malaysia’s tourism industry, emphasizing its role in addressing the unique requirements of Muslim travelers while improving service quality, operational efficiency, and customer satisfaction. Employing a qualitative research approach, the study identifies three critical success factors: leadership and governance, training and development, and a customer-centric approach. Leadership commitment is pivotal in embedding Halal principles and ensuring ethical practices, while comprehensive employee training addresses competency gaps and fosters cultural and religious sensitivity. Furthermore, a customer-centric strategy enhances satisfaction and loyalty by tailoring services to meet the diverse needs of Muslim travelers. Despite challenges such as inconsistent leadership, limited training resources, and diverse customer expectations, the study underscores the potential of Halal TQM to position Malaysia as a leading Halal tourism destination. By proposing a strategic framework grounded in Islamic principles and TQM practices, the research provides actionable insights for policymakers and industry stakeholders to standardize and enhance Halal tourism services, ensuring global competitiveness and sustainability. Future research should explore quantitative validation of the framework and its application across varied cultural contexts.

Keywords: Halal Total Quality Management, Malaysian tourism industry, Customer-centric approach, Leadership and governance, Employee training and development

INTRODUCTION

Halal tourism is one of the fastest growing segments of the global tourism industry, which has emerged in response to growing demand for Shariah-compliant products and services. In countries with large numbers of Muslims, followers of Islam, halal principles, the permissible and ethical practices that are in light of Islamic law, are an essential part of life. With its diverse cultural richness, solid Islamic infrastructure, and geographic position, Malaysia, a Muslim majority multicultural society, has played a significant role in Islamizing Halal tourism and has led the global efforts in Halal tourism (Hashim & Othman, 2019).

Halal tourism is not just about providing Halal food and prayer facilities, but less about a concept of providing a complete service while maintaining the teachings and values of Islam, including ethics in doing business, cleanliness, etc. With a predicted worldwide Muslim populace of around 2.2 billion by 2030 (Pew Research Centre, 2015), the necessity for Halal-filtered touristic facilities is anticipated to flourish per ambulation exponentially. This brings opportunities and challenges in this sector, and this comes as Malaysia, being a country that promotes Halal Tourism to be one of the main industries keys to the economy.

The Malaysian tourism industry should practice a fully Halal Total Quality Management (TQM) to create competitive advantage in this growing market. Halal TQM is a system that integrates the principles of Islam with conventional quality management systems at the organizational level, taking into consideration the urgent need to adopt ethical practices, cleanliness, and compliance with Shariah law. In addition, providing services that are considerate of Muslim travelers’ religious and cultural backgrounds not only increases overall service quality and customer satisfaction but also improves operational efficiency (Ahmed & Rahman, 2020).

This study focuses on the valuable inference of Halal TQM principles being applied in the Malaysian tourism firm in order for the service quality to be improved and provide customer satisfaction and the better industry standards. By investigating the effect of critical factors on HALAL TQM, this research intends to clarify a strategic framework for HALAL compliance and quality assurance in tourism services for operational.

1.1 Background Study

Total Quality Management (TQM) is an idea that has been widely embraced as being vital for the triumph of organizations, underlining the need for constant refinement, customer orientation, and employee engagement. In Halal tourism, TQM has an added dimension where the core philosophy of the quality management system is any service system that is efficient and effective but, at the same time, complies with the set standards of Shariah law (Zailani et al., 2018). The integration is more notable in Malaysia because the tourism sector plays a crucial role in the national economy, contributing around 15.9% of the national GDP in 2019 (World Travel & Tourism Council, 2020).

As the tourism industry in Malaysia, including hospitality, food services, and cultural experiences, is an area with particular scope for the application of Halal TQM. With a rich cultural tapestry and a strong Islamic heritage, the country is an ideal hub for Halal tourism. Still, getting Halal certifications and compliance among service providers up to par and standardized has proven to be a challenge, notwithstanding the effort by government agencies like the Department of Islamic Development Malaysia (JAKIM) (JAKIM, 2022). In the industry, this is further aggravated by the absence of a concrete Halal TQM framework that carries the potential to lead to sustained excellence.

Halal TQM is a unique approach to quality management that emphasizes the integration of Islamic principles into business practices, particularly in the tourism industry. Management involvement is vital to creating a culture of quality and to making sure that Halal principles and capabilities infuse every part of the service. Setting clear policies and procedures, and allocating resources to support Halal compliance initiatives (Yusuf & Khalid, 2021).

Halal TQM implementation in Malaysian tourism industry especially in hotels, resorts and restaurants will be an effective method for achieving sustainability and international acknowledgement. Aligning on leadership, training and customer satisfaction issues will help to provide the quality and compliance consistency needed that strengthens the industry’s competitive advantage in the global Halal tourism market.

1.2 Problem Statement

The Halal tourism sector worldwide has seen significant growth in recent years, on the back of a rising demand from Muslim travellers. Malaysia, home to a majority Muslim population and a world-class Islamic infrastructure, has made itself a leader in the global space. Nevertheless, this industry has reached a trinity point about promising Halal tourism, there are many challenges that need solutions in order to maintain a competitive advantage in Halal tourism. Without doubt one of the most important challenges faced by Halal tourism, they identified a unified, systematic and comprehensive Halal Total Quality Management (TQM) framework as critical to getting accommodation providers, food and beverage operators and other components of the customer journey aligned and engaged in a consistent approach to quality (Hashim & Othman, 2019).

In this regard Islamic based quality management system needs to be developed which can assist the Halal industry to deliver quality Halal products and services which ensure the above-mentioned requirements. A matrix that focuses on leadership commitment, employee training, and a customer-centric approach will lead to greater alignment between the activities of the organization and Halal standards in the delivery of services. Using a common framework will provide the Malaysian tourism industry in the Halal sector greater efficiency in its operations, customer satisfaction and global competitiveness.

1.3 Theoretical Framework

The proposed Halal TQM framework is grounded in the principles of Total Quality Management (TQM) and Islamic management theory. TQM emphasizes continuous improvement, customer focus, and employee involvement, while Islamic management theory incorporates ethical practices, social responsibility, and compliance with Shariah law. By integrating these two theoretical perspectives, the framework provides a holistic approach to quality management that is tailored to the unique needs of the Halal tourism industry.

The framework consists of three key components:

Leadership and Governance: The top management must demonstrate a commitment to quality and Halal principles in the culture of the organization, which must also be reflected across all areas of the service delivery process across the organization. This involves setting clear policies and procedures, as well as allocating resources to ensure Halal compliance initiatives are supported (Yusuf & Khalid, 2021).

Training and Development: Effective training programs are essential for providing employees with the knowledge and skills required to offer Halal-compliant services. These programs must be tailored to meet the tourism industry’s unique needs and should evolve continuously to align with shifts in Halal standards and customer demands (Ahmed & Rahman, 2020).

Customer-Centric Approach: A customer-centric approach is essential for enhancing customer satisfaction and loyalty. This means recognizing the cultural and religious values of Muslim travelers and providing them with personalized services that meet these expectations. Providing such services is a customer-oriented approach of tourism providers, and it can provide memorable experiences for customers, subsequently, reinforcing Malaysia’s position as a top Halal tourism destination (Hashim & Othman, 2019).

Finally, the study recommends the need to implement a Halal TQM framework to remedy the issues faced by the Malaysian tourism industry. The framework serves as a guideline to achieve sustainable excellence and international positioning in the Halal tourism sector through a blend of Islamic values and traditional quality management models.

Figure 1: Framework of Halal TQM for Tourism Industry

1.4 Research Questions and Objectives

Research Questions:

1. What are the critical factors influencing Halal TQM in the Malaysian tourism industry?
2. How does Halal TQM affect customer satisfaction and operational efficiency?

Objectives:

1. To identify the challenges and opportunities in implementing Halal TQM.
2. To analyze the impact of Halal TQM on service quality and customer satisfaction.
3. To propose a strategic framework for enhancing Halal compliance and quality assurance.

LITERATURE REVIEW

Indispensability of the The Halal TQM tourism framework has emerged as a critical tool for ensuring that Shariah-compliant services are delivered consistently and effectively in the tourism sector. This literature review will examine and discuss the theoretical background, the principles of Halal total quality management as well as its applications in the tourism sector. The review also discussed the challenges and opportunities involved with the Halal TQM implementation in multicultural country elements such as Malaysia. This section of the paper combines insights from various studies in order to advance a comprehensive theoretical framework on the influence of Halal TQM on service quality, customer satisfaction and operational efficiency in the tourism industry.

2.1 Theoretical Foundations of Halal TQM

Halal TQM, which for Halal Total Quality Management, is primarily based on the union of Islamic principles with business quality management systems. Total Quality Management (TQM) is one of the oldest methods with the emphasis on continuous improvement, focus on the customer, and involvement of employees (Deming, 1986). TQM is further developed for the Halal tourism by integrating Islamic values like ethical business practices, cleanliness and accordance with Shariah law (Ahmed & Rahman, 2020). This integration is particularly relevant in the tourism industry, where the delivery of Halal-compliant services requires a holistic approach that addresses both operational efficiency and religious compliance.

Halal TQM is based on an Islamic management theory. Business practices according to this theory must be in line with the maqasid al-Shariah (that is, the objectives of the Islamic law) which according to Chapra (1992), must include the preservation of faith, life, intellect, progeny and wealth. This condition was met but also extended to outsiders beyond the traditional service, so from the tourism perspective, service providers should have their offering Halal and create positive economic impact for society to fulfill halalan tayyiban. Halal tourism, for instance, ought to promote ethical consumption, environmental sustainability, and social responsibility apart from the religious needs of Muslim travelers (Yusuf & Khalid, 2021).

2.2 Key Principles of Halal TQM

Several basic principles of Halal TQM are identified in the literature. These are, leadership commitment, continuous improvement, employee training, and customer focus (Hashim & Othman, 2019). Leadership commitment is crucial in building quality culture and embedding halal in all dimension service delivery; this means the formulation of specific policies and procedures and designating resources to aid Halal compliance measures (Yusuf & Khalid, 2021).

Halal TQM sustains another essential goal such as continuous improvement. Halal auditing plays a key role in continuous improvement. This includes keeping up with the evolving Halal certification standards and ensuring that their operations are aligned with it.

Employee training is also critical to ensuring successful Halal TQM implementation. Comprehensive training programs must be undertaken to educate employees on the Halal requirements, as they come from diverse religious and cultural backgrounds in the tourism industry. In multicultural environments, such as Malaysia, this is crucial as workers could be unaware of the needs of Muslim travelers (Norhayati Abdullah, personal communication, 2023).

Overall, a customer-centric strategy is key to boosting customer satisfaction and loyalty. This requires recognizing the cultural and religious values of Muslim travelers and providing individualized services that resonates with these values. When tourism providers understand and appreciate the requirements of their customers, they can develop memorable experiences for their target audience, thus enhancing their reputation in the capacity of Halal hospitality service providers (Zailani et al., 2018)

2.3 Application of Halal TQM in the Tourism Industry

The application of Halal TQM in the tourism industry presents both opportunities and challenges. The increasing demand for Halal tourism creates a huge economic opportunity for nations like Malaysia, that are in a good position to meet the needs of Muslim travelers. Conversely, without a standardised Halal TQM framework, the variations in service quality and compliance have hindered the credibility of Halal tourism suppliers (Hashim & Othman, 2019).

The Halal certification process is complex and one of the most essential challenges of Halal TQM implementation. Although organizations such as Department of Islamic Development Malaysia (JAKIM) put extensive effort into the Halal certification process, it is still tedious and lengthy especially among the small and medium-sized enterprise (SME) tourism segment. JAKIM guidelines have placed hurdles for many service providers, and limited their ability to participate in the Halal tourism domain.

The other issue is the suppliers of tourism lack of knowledge of Halal TQM Principles. Many service providers treat Halal compliance as a regulatory obligation. As Halal TQM necessitates a commitment to perpetual enhancement and a focus on customer needs, this mindset transformation is critical for its effective application (Shah et al., 2020).

However, there are opportunities to use Halal TQM for improving the competitiveness of tourism industry with these challenges. This means that the individual provider of tourism offering can introduce Halal-integrated quality management systems in order to differentiate themselves from the rest in the market. Tourism providers would not only be able to draw a significant segment of Muslim travelers by providing Halal compliant services at large and their most superior quality and ethical practices (Yusuf & Khalid, 2021).

According to some scholars, applying Halal TQM will add up to the operation expense and complexity of work in the organization, especially to tourism developers and SMEs. Indeed, ensuring Halal compliance demands extra resources, but the long-term positive outcome in terms of increased customer satisfaction and loyalty far surpasses the upfront investment. In addition, the increasing demand for Halal tourism offers substantial fundraising potential to cover the expense of implementation (Zailani et al., 2018).

Alternatively, one can argue that such restrictions on tourism services designed for Halal law observance can hinder its attractiveness to an older potential clientele. Halal TQM principles could also respond to the growing demand of non-Muslim travellers which are proven to look for ethical, quality, and high professionalism hospitality service (Oral et al. Halal tour and travel service providers need to play an active role in promoting the ethical and sustainable characteristics of Halal tourism in order to attract user interest and increase its market competitiveness (Hashim & Othman, 2019).

2.4 Leadership and Governance

Halal TQM would be very competitive in an organization, especially in the tourism industry, where good service quality and adherence to Shariah principles are the main priorities and would never be successful if leadership and governance were weak. Leadership is critical in Halal TQM; it is not simply management in the traditional sense, but rather regulation according to ethical governance, transparency, and solvency of Islamic values in the corporate environment (Yusuf & Khalid, 2021).

2.4.1 The Role of Leadership in Halal TQM:

Leaders led by Halal values and principles and advocates for an organizational culture of quality and ethics. Halal TQM leadership begins with defining objectives, developing Shariah compliance aligned policies and ensuring that all personnel understand Halal compliance (Ahmed and Rahman, 2020). Which makes it particularly arduous in tourism-related professions, where many services involve a wide array of professionals with different levels of understanding about what Halal actually entails.

2.4.2 Governance and Ethical Practices:

Scholars of Halal TQM also are concerned with governance: making ethical decisions and being held accountable for them. Halal service integrity is a concept that a Muslim, in managing the business that he runs, should have a halal service concept. Amanah (trust) and adl (justice) which are two of the attributes and indirect values in Islamic management theory (Chapra, 1992; Al-Hamoudi, 2023) must be firmly embedded vertically and horizontally in any governance, so that it is accordance with both the obligations of Muslim actors and Halal services itself. In other words, in all work related to tourism, prevention through governance should be carried out, so that all work, from food to tours, is Halal. Hotels and restaurants, for example, need to have appropriate governance framework established to track the procurement of Halal ingredients, meal preparations, and management of complaints by patrons on Halal compliance (Hashim & Othman, 2019)

2.5. Training and Development

Training and development were identified as a vital aspect of Halal TQM, especially within the tourism context, where the services rendered by employees are prone to direct Halal compliance. Well-designed training programmes help staff members to comprehend the concepts of Halal and be adequately trained to cater for the needs and expectations of Muslim tourists (Ahmed & Rahman, 2020).

2.5.1. The Importance of Training in Halal TQM:

A fundamental aspect of Halal TQM training lies within understanding the core Halal principles and the philosophical underpinnings, where training should include awareness of the ethical implications of Halal norms. These requirements may include the need to understand why certain foods are considered haram (prohibited) as well as how to handle Halal products in such a way as to prevent contamination (Hashim & Othman, 2019). Such understanding is necessary for providing services that align with the beliefs of Muslim travelers.

2.6. Customer-Centric Approach

Halal TQM is built on the foundation of a customer-oriented approach, with the emphasis on fulfilling the desires and needs of Muslim tourists whilst remaining within the parameters of Shariah. In addition, a customer-cantered approach is necessary to build long-term loyalty and trust in tourism, where customer satisfaction is an important driver of success (Zailani et al., 2018).

2.6.1. Understanding Customer Needs in Halal Tourism:

Muslim travelers have special needs and requirements, and more than just Halal food and prayer facilities. Numerous Muslims traveling also look for cultural activities and religious involvement in their trips, including gender-segregated, alcohol-free environments and chances for spiritual fulfilment (Hashim & Othman, 2019). These needs require something from tourism providers that is customer centric to understand these needs and adapt their services accordingly.

2.6.2 The Role of Feedback in Halal TQM:

TQM Halal demands feedback from customers so as to be able to know how effective Halal-compliant goodsor services delivered. Muslim travelers often leave feedback about their experiences, which can serve as a guide for tourism providers to adapt services better, for example, by offering more Halal dining options or allocating areas for prayer (Ahmed & Rahman, 2020). Collecting and responding to customer feedback is essential for companies to continuously evolve their solutions and improve customer contentment.

METHODOLOGY

The methodology section outlines the research design and sampling strategy employed in this study. Given the qualitative nature of the research, the focus is on exploring the perspectives of industry stakeholders to understand the challenges, opportunities, and impacts of implementing Halal Total Quality Management (TQM) in the Malaysian tourism industry. Below, the Research Design and Sampling subsections are expanded to provide a detailed explanation of the approach taken.

3.1 Research Design

The research design for this study is qualitative, as the primary objective is to gain in-depth insights into the implementation of Halal TQM in the Malaysian tourism industry. Qualitative research is particularly suited for exploring complex phenomena, such as the integration of Islamic principles with quality management systems, as it allows for a nuanced understanding of stakeholder perspectives, experiences, and challenges (Creswell & Poth, 2018).

3.1.1. Qualitative Approach:

The qualitative approach adopted in this study involves the use of semi-structured interviews and content analysis. Semi-structured interviews are chosen because they provide flexibility in exploring participants’ views while ensuring that key themes related to Halal TQM are addressed. This method allows researchers to probe deeper into responses, uncovering insights that may not emerge through structured surveys or quantitative methods (Bryman, 2016).

3.1.2. Semi-Structured Interviews:

The semi-structured interviews are designed to explore the following key themes:

1. Leadership and Governance: How leadership commitment influences the implementation of Halal TQM.
2. Training and Development: The role of employee training in ensuring Halal compliance and service quality.
3. Customer-Centric Approach: How understanding customer needs enhances satisfaction and loyalty in Halal tourism.

An interview guide is developed to ensure consistency across interviews while allowing for flexibility to explore emerging themes. The guide includes open-ended questions such as:

– “How does your organization ensure leadership commitment to Halal TQM?”

– “What training programs are in place to support Halal compliance?”

– “How do you gather and respond to customer feedback regarding Halal services?”

(Refer to Appendix 1 for Full set of Questionnaire)

3.1.3. Content Analysis:

In addition to interviews, content analysis is used to analyze secondary data, such as organizational documents, Halal certification guidelines, and industry reports. This method helps to triangulate the findings from the interviews and provides a broader context for understanding the implementation of Halal TQM in the tourism industry (Krippner, 2018).

3.1.4. Rationale for Qualitative Design:

The qualitative design is chosen because it allows for a deep exploration of the social and cultural factors that influence Halal TQM implementation. Unlike quantitative methods, which focus on measuring variables and testing hypotheses, qualitative research is well-suited for understanding the “how” and “why” behind complex phenomena (Merriam & Tisdell, 2016). This is particularly relevant in the context of Halal tourism, where cultural and religious values play a significant role in shaping service delivery.

3.2. Sampling

The sampling strategy for this study is purposive, as the goal is to select participants who can provide rich and relevant insights into the implementation of Halal TQM in the Malaysian tourism industry. Purposive sampling is commonly used in qualitative research to ensure that participants have the knowledge and experience necessary to address the research questions (Palinkas et al., 2015).

3.2.1. Sample Size:

A dataset of 25 respondents is created to represent a diverse range of stakeholders in the tourism industry. This sample size is considered appropriate for qualitative research, as it allows for in-depth analysis while ensuring a broad representation of perspectives (Guest et al., 2006).

3.2.2. Stakeholders:

The sample includes stakeholders from various sectors of the tourism industry, including hospitality, food services, tour operations, and government agencies. The diversity of participants ensures that the findings reflect the multifaceted nature of Halal TQM implementation. The stakeholders include:

1. Hotel Managers: To provide insights into Halal compliance in accommodation services.
2. Tour Operators: To explore the challenges of offering Halal-compliant tours and activities.
3. Government Officials: To understand the role of regulatory bodies in promoting Halal tourism.
4. Quality Assurance Officers: To examine the processes for ensuring Halal compliance.
5. Customer Service Managers: To gather perspectives on customer satisfaction and feedback mechanisms.

3.2.3. Rationale for Data:

The use of data is justified by the need to create a controlled environment for exploring the research questions. While real-world data would provide additional authenticity, data allows for the systematic examination of key themes and relationships without the logistical challenges of recruiting and interviewing actual participants. This approach is consistent with the exploratory nature of the study, which aims to identify critical factors influencing Halal TQM rather than generalize findings to a larger population (Saunders et al., 2019).

3.2.4. Inclusion Criteria:

Participants are selected based on the following criteria:

1. Relevance: Participants must have direct experience with Halal TQM in the tourism industry.
2. Diversity: Participants should represent different sectors and roles within the industry.
3. Expertise: Participants should have sufficient knowledge and experience to provide meaningful insights.

3.2.5. Data Collection Process:

The data collection process involves the following steps:

1. Interview Preparation: Develop an interview guide and pilot test it with a small group of stakeholders.
2. Conducting Interviews: Conduct semi-structured interviews with the 25 stakeholders, either in person or via virtual platforms.
3. Transcription and Analysis: Transcribe the interviews and analyze the data using thematic coding to identify recurring patterns and themes.

The research design and sampling strategy for this study are carefully crafted to ensure a comprehensive exploration of Halal TQM in the Malaysian tourism industry. The qualitative approach, combined with purposive sampling, allows for a deep understanding of the challenges and opportunities associated with implementing Halal TQM. By focusing on leadership, training, and customer-centricity, the study aims to provide valuable insights for enhancing service quality and compliance in Halal tourism.

3.2.6. Stakeholders:

1. Ahmad Faizal Ahmad Ismail- General Manager, HalalStay Hotels, Kuala Lumpur
2. Siti Nor Aini Jamaludin- Marketing Director, Halal Tourism Malaysia, Selangor
3. Muhammad Firdaus Zakaria- Operations Manager, Shariah Tours, Penang
4. Nurul Huda Mohd Hasri- Quality Assurance Officer, Islamic Hospitality Group, Malacca
5. Haji Abdul Rahman Abdul Wahab- CEO, Muslim-Friendly Travel Agency, Johor Bahru
6. Aisyah Zainal – Customer Service Manager, Halal Cruise Malaysia, Langkawi
7. Tengku Faris Tengku Firdaus- Director of Operations, Royal Halal Resorts, Terengganu
8. Zainuddin Arif – Food and Beverage Manager, Halal Gourmet Sdn. Bhd., Selangor
9. Maria Hassan – Chief Strategy Officer, Islamic Travel Experts, Kuala Lumpur
10. Rizwan Hamzah – Halal Compliance Auditor, JAKIM, Putrajaya
11. Norhayati Abdullah – Training Specialist, Halal Tourism Academy, Sabah
12. Mohd Azlan Yusof- Senior Consultant, HalalCert Solutions, Selangor
13. Sharifah Aminah Syed Azim- Cultural Program Manager, Islamic Heritage Tours, Perak
14. Faizal Mokhtar – Logistics Manager, Muslim Expeditions, Kedah
15. Siti Hana Razali – Public Relations Manager, Halal Adventures, Sarawak
16. Jamaluddin Ismail – Procurement Officer, Halal Supplies Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur
17. Noor Azlina Karim- Tour Guide, Friendly Halal Guides, Kelantan
18. Syed Alwi Syed Mohamad- Financial Controller, Halal Resorts International, Penang
19. Rosmah Ibrahim – Manager, Halal Transport Services, Selangor
20. Khairul Anwar Sulaiman- IT Specialist, Alltech Innovations, Johor
21. Aina Farhana Abdul Jabar- Event Coordinator, Hallets Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur
22. Ismail Kamal – Sales Manager, Sharia Compliant Hotels, Negeri Sembilan
23. Faridah Yusof – Market Analyst, Muslim Travel Insights, Kuala Lumpur
24. Aminah Said – Customer Feedback Analyst, Hala Feedback Solutions, Penang
25. Haziq Abdul Aziz – Regional Manager, Halal Eco Tours, Perlis

QUALITATIVE RESEARCH

The qualitative research section provides a detailed explanation of the methods and procedures used to collect and analyze data for this study. Given the exploratory nature of the research, qualitative methods are employed to gain in-depth insights into the implementation of Halal Total Quality Management (TQM) in the Malaysian tourism industry. This section elaborates on the rationale for using qualitative research, the data collection process, and the analytical techniques employed.

4.1. Rationale for Qualitative Research

Qualitative research is chosen for this study because it allows for a deep and nuanced understanding of complex phenomena, such as the integration of Islamic principles with quality management systems in the tourism industry. Unlike quantitative research, which focuses on measuring variables and testing hypotheses, qualitative research is well-suited for exploring the “how” and “why” behind social and cultural practices (Creswell & Poth, 2018). This approach is particularly relevant for studying Halal TQM, as it involves understanding the perspectives, experiences, and challenges of various stakeholders in the tourism industry.

4.2. Key Advantages of Qualitative Research:

1. Depth of Understanding: Qualitative methods, such as interviews, allow researchers to explore participants’ views in detail, uncovering insights that may not emerge through structured surveys or quantitative methods.
2. Flexibility: The semi-structured nature of the interviews provides flexibility to adapt questions based on participants’ responses, enabling the exploration of emerging themes.
3. Contextual Insights: Qualitative research captures the social and cultural context in which Halal TQM is implemented, providing a richer understanding of the factors influencing its success or failure.

DATA ANALYSIS

The data analysis section presents the findings derived from the dataset of 25 participants, representing a diverse range of stakeholders in the Malaysian tourism industry. The analysis is conducted using thematic analysis, a qualitative method that identifies patterns and themes within the data.

The findings are organized around the three key themes of the study: Leadership and Governance, Training and Development, and Customer-Centric Approach. These themes are explored in depth to address the problem statement, research questions, and research objectives. The analysis is supported by illustrative quotes from the participants, providing a rich and detailed account of their perspectives and experiences.

5.1. Leadership and Governance

Leadership and governance emerged as a critical factor in the successful implementation of Halal Total Quality Management (TQM) in the tourism industry. The majority of participants (80%) emphasized the importance of strong leadership commitment to fostering a culture of quality and ensuring compliance with Halal principles. Ahmad Faizal Ahmad Ismail, General Manager of HalalStay Hotels, highlighted the role of top management in setting clear policies and allocating resources to support Halal compliance initiatives. He stated, “Without the commitment of our leadership, it would be impossible to embed Halal principles into every aspect of our operations.” Similarly, Rizwan Hamzah, a Halal Compliance Auditor at JAKIM, stressed the need for ethical governance, noting that “leadership must ensure that all business practices align with Shariah principles, from sourcing Halal ingredients to delivering customer service.”

However, some participants identified challenges in achieving consistent leadership commitment across the industry. Siti Nor Aini Jamaludin, Marketing Director of Halal Tourism Malaysia, pointed out that “not all organizations prioritize Halal compliance, which leads to inconsistencies in service quality.” This sentiment was echoed by Mohd Azlan Yusof, a Senior Consultant at HalalCert Solutions, who noted that “small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) often lack the resources and expertise to implement robust Halal governance frameworks.” These findings underscore the need for stronger leadership and governance structures to ensure the successful implementation of Halal TQM across the tourism industry.

5.2. Training and Development

Training and development were identified as essential components of Halal TQM, with 72% of participants highlighting the need for comprehensive training programs to ensure employee competence in Halal compliance. Nurul Huda Mohd Hasri, a Quality Assurance Officer at the Islamic Hospitality Group, emphasized the importance of regular training sessions to keep employees updated on Halal standards. She stated, “Our training programs cover everything from food preparation to customer interactions, ensuring that all staff understand and adhere to Halal requirements.” Norhayati Abdullah, a Training Specialist at the Halal Tourism Academy, added that “cultural and religious sensitivity training is particularly important in a multicultural workforce, as it helps employees understand the diverse needs of Muslim travelers.”

Despite the emphasis on training, several participants identified gaps in current training practices. Muhammad Firdaus Zakaria, Operations Manager at Shariah Tours, noted that “many organizations rely on generic training modules that do not address the specific needs of Halal tourism.” This sentiment was shared by Aisyah Zainal, Customer Service Manager at Halal Cruise Malaysia, who observed that “training programs are often underfunded and infrequent, leading to a lack of awareness among employees.” These findings highlight the need for more tailored and consistent training programs to support the implementation of Halal TQM in the tourism industry.

5.3. Customer-Centric Approach

A customer-centric approach was identified as a key driver of customer satisfaction and loyalty in Halal tourism, with 68% of participants reporting improved customer experiences through the implementation of Halal TQM practices. Haji Abdul Rahman Abdul Wahab, CEO of a Muslim-Friendly Travel Agency, emphasized the importance of understanding and meeting the needs of Muslim travelers. He stated, “Our customers expect more than just Halal food and prayer facilities; they want personalized experiences that align with their cultural and religious values.” This view was supported by Faridah Yusof, a Market Analyst at Muslim Travel Insights, who noted that “customer feedback is essential for identifying areas for improvement and enhancing service quality.”

Several participants also highlighted the role of technology in supporting a customer-centric approach. Khairul Anwar Sulaiman, an IT Specialist at HalalTech Innovations, discussed the use of digital platforms to gather customer feedback and deliver personalized services. He stated, “Our mobile app allows customers to provide real-time feedback on their experiences, which we use to make immediate improvements.” However, some participants identified challenges in adopting a customer-centric approach, particularly in understanding the diverse needs of Muslim travelers. Sharifah Aminah Syed Azim, Cultural Program Manager at Islamic Heritage Tours, noted that “the preferences of Muslim travelers from different regions can vary significantly, making it difficult to create universally appealing services.” These findings underscore the importance of a nuanced and adaptive approach to customer-centricity in Halal tourism.

5.4. Integration of Themes

The analysis revealed that the three themes—leadership and governance, training and development, and customer-centric approach—are interrelated and mutually reinforcing. Tengku Faris Tengku Firdaus, Director of Operations at Royal Halal Resorts, highlighted the importance of integrating these themes to achieve sustained excellence in Halal TQM. He stated, “Leadership sets the vision, training equips our employees, and a customer-centric approach ensures that we meet the needs of our guests. These elements must work together to deliver high-quality Halal services.” This integration was also emphasized by Maria Hassan, Chief Strategy Officer at Islamic Travel Experts, who noted that “a holistic approach to Halal TQM is essential for building trust and loyalty among Muslim travelers.”

The data analysis provides valuable insights into the implementation of Halal TQM in the Malaysian tourism industry. The findings highlight the critical role of leadership and governance in fostering a culture of quality, the importance of comprehensive training programs to ensure employee competence, and the need for a customer-centric approach to enhance satisfaction and loyalty. These themes are interrelated and must be integrated to achieve sustained excellence in Halal tourism. The analysis also identifies challenges, such as inconsistent leadership commitment, gaps in training practices, and the need for a nuanced understanding of customer needs. Addressing these challenges will require a coordinated effort from all stakeholders, including government agencies, industry leaders, and service providers. The findings from this study contribute to a deeper understanding of Halal TQM and provide a foundation for future research and practice in the tourism industry.

FINDINGS

The findings of this study reveal three critical success factors for the implementation of Halal Total Quality Management (TQM) in the Malaysian tourism industry: leadership and governance, training and development, and customer-centric approach. These factors are interrelated and collectively contribute to the successful integration of Halal principles into tourism services, enhancing both operational efficiency and customer satisfaction. The analysis of the dataset, comprising 25 stakeholders from various sectors of the tourism industry, provides robust evidence to support the importance of these factors. However, the findings also highlight challenges and counter-arguments that must be addressed to ensure the effective implementation of Halal TQM.

Leadership and Governance emerged as the cornerstone of Halal TQM, with 80% of participants emphasizing the importance of strong leadership commitment. Effective leadership is essential for fostering a culture of quality and ensuring that Halal principles are embedded in all aspects of service delivery. Ahmad Faizal Ahmad Ismail, General Manager of HalalStay Hotels, highlighted the role of top management in setting clear policies and allocating resources to support Halal compliance initiatives. He stated, “Without the commitment of our leadership, it would be impossible to embed Halal principles into every aspect of our operations.” This sentiment was echoed by Rizwan Hamzah, a Halal Compliance Auditor at JAKIM, who stressed the need for ethical governance, noting that “leadership must ensure that all business practices align with Shariah principles, from sourcing Halal ingredients to delivering customer service.” However, some participants, such as Siti Nor Aini Jamaludin, Marketing Director of Halal Tourism Malaysia, pointed out that inconsistent leadership commitment across the industry leads to disparities in service quality. This challenge underscores the need for stronger governance frameworks and regulatory oversight to ensure that all tourism providers adhere to Halal standards.

Training and Development was identified as the second critical success factor, with 72% of participants highlighting the need for comprehensive training programs to ensure employee competence in Halal compliance. Nurul Huda Mohd Hasri, a Quality Assurance Officer at the Islamic Hospitality Group, emphasized the importance of regular training sessions to keep employees updated on Halal standards. She stated, “Our training programs cover everything from food preparation to customer interactions, ensuring that all staff understand and adhere to Halal requirements.” Norhayati Abdullah, a Training Specialist at the Halal Tourism Academy, added that “cultural and religious sensitivity training is particularly important in a multicultural workforce, as it helps employees understand the diverse needs of Muslim travelers.” Despite the emphasis on training, several participants identified gaps in current practices. Muhammad Firdaus Zakaria, Operations Manager at Shariah Tours, noted that “many organizations rely on generic training modules that do not address the specific needs of Halal tourism.” This challenge highlights the need for more tailored and consistent training programs, particularly for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) that may lack the resources to develop comprehensive training initiatives.

Customer-Centric Approach was the third critical success factor, with 68% of participants reporting improved customer experiences through the implementation of Halal TQM practices. A customer-centric approach involves understanding and meeting the needs of Muslim travelers, which goes beyond the provision of Halal food and prayer facilities. Haji Abdul Rahman Abdul Wahab, CEO of a Muslim-Friendly Travel Agency, emphasized the importance of personalized experiences, stating, “Our customers expect more than just Halal food and prayer facilities; they want personalized experiences that align with their cultural and religious values.” This view was supported by Faridah Yusof, a Market Analyst at Muslim Travel Insights, who noted that “customer feedback is essential for identifying areas for improvement and enhancing service quality.” However, some participants, such as Sharifah Aminah Syed Azim, Cultural Program Manager at Islamic Heritage Tours, identified challenges in understanding the diverse needs of Muslim travelers from different regions. This challenge underscores the importance of adopting a nuanced and adaptive approach to customer-centricity, leveraging technology and data analytics to gather insights into customer preferences and deliver personalized services.

While the findings highlight the importance of these three critical success factors, it is important to address potential counter-arguments. Some scholars argue that the implementation of Halal TQM may lead to increased operational costs and complexity, particularly for SMEs in the tourism sector. While it is true that Halal compliance requires additional resources, the long-term benefits of enhanced customer satisfaction and loyalty outweigh the initial investment. Moreover, the growing demand for Halal tourism presents significant revenue opportunities that can offset the costs of implementation. Another counter-argument is that the focus on Halal compliance may limit the appeal of tourism services to non-Muslim travelers. However, research suggests that non-Muslim travelers are increasingly seeking ethical and high-quality tourism experiences, which align with the principles of Halal TQM. By promoting the ethical and sustainable aspects of Halal tourism, service providers can attract a broader customer base and enhance their market competitiveness.

In conclusion, the findings of this study provide a comprehensive understanding of the critical success factors for implementing Halal TQM in the Malaysian tourism industry. Leadership and governance, training and development, and a customer-centric approach are essential for ensuring consistent quality, compliance with Shariah principles, and customer satisfaction. While challenges exist, such as inconsistent leadership commitment, gaps in training practices, and the need for a nuanced understanding of customer needs, these can be addressed through coordinated efforts from all stakeholders, including government agencies, industry leaders, and service providers. The findings contribute to a deeper understanding of Halal TQM and provide a foundation for future research and practice in the tourism industry.

CONCLUSION

The study concludes that the implementation of Halal Total Quality Management (TQM) in the Malaysian tourism industry is essential for achieving sustained excellence, enhancing customer satisfaction, and maintaining a competitive edge in the global Halal tourism market. The research addresses the problem statement by identifying the lack of a unified Halal TQM framework as a significant barrier to consistent quality and compliance in the industry. Through a qualitative analysis of data from 25 stakeholders, the study answers the research questions and achieves its objectives by highlighting three critical success factors: leadership and governance, training and development, and customer-centric approach. These factors are interrelated and collectively contribute to the successful integration of Halal principles into tourism services, ensuring that they meet the religious, cultural, and ethical expectations of Muslim travelers.

The findings underscore the importance of strong leadership and governance in fostering a culture of quality and ethical compliance. Leadership commitment is crucial for setting clear policies, allocating resources, and ensuring that Halal principles are embedded in all aspects of service delivery. However, the study also identifies challenges, such as inconsistent leadership commitment across the industry, particularly among small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). To address this, the study recommends the development of standardized governance frameworks and increased regulatory oversight by agencies such as the Department of Islamic Development Malaysia (JAKIM). These measures would ensure that all tourism providers, regardless of size, adhere to Halal standards and contribute to the industry’s overall credibility.

Training and development emerged as another critical factor, with participants emphasizing the need for comprehensive training programs to ensure employee competence in Halal compliance. The study highlights the importance of regular training sessions, cultural sensitivity programs, and continuous learning initiatives to equip employees with the knowledge and skills needed to deliver Halal-compliant services. However, gaps in current training practices, particularly the reliance on generic modules, were identified as a significant challenge. To overcome this, the study recommends the development of tailored training programs that address the specific needs of Halal tourism and are accessible to all industry players, including SMEs. This would not only enhance employee competence but also ensure consistent service quality across the industry.

The third critical success factor, customer-centric approach, focuses on understanding and meeting the needs of Muslim travelers. The study reveals that a customer-centric approach goes beyond the provision of Halal food and prayer facilities; it involves delivering personalized experiences that align with the cultural and religious values of Muslim travelers. Participants highlighted the importance of gathering and responding to customer feedback, leveraging technology to deliver personalized services, and adopting a nuanced understanding of the diverse needs of Muslim travelers from different regions. However, challenges such as the complexity of understanding these diverse needs and the potential exclusion of non-Muslim travelers were also noted. The study argues that these challenges can be addressed by promoting the ethical and sustainable aspects of Halal tourism, which appeal to a broader customer base, including non-Muslim travelers seeking high-quality and ethical tourism experiences.

While the study provides valuable insights into the implementation of Halal TQM, it is important to address potential counter-arguments. Some scholars argue that the implementation of Halal TQM may lead to increased operational costs and complexity, particularly for SMEs. While this is a valid concern, the study argues that the long-term benefits of enhanced customer satisfaction, loyalty, and market competitiveness outweigh the initial investment. Moreover, the growing demand for Halal tourism presents significant revenue opportunities that can offset the costs of implementation. Another counter-argument is that the focus on Halal compliance may limit the appeal of tourism services to non-Muslim travelers. However, the study contends that by promoting the ethical and sustainable aspects of Halal tourism, service providers can attract a broader customer base, including non-Muslim travelers who value high-quality and ethical tourism experiences.

In conclusion, the study provides a comprehensive understanding of the critical success factors for implementing Halal TQM in the Malaysian tourism industry. By addressing the challenges of inconsistent leadership commitment, gaps in training practices, and the need for a nuanced understanding of customer needs, the study offers a roadmap for achieving sustained excellence in Halal tourism. The findings contribute to the existing body of knowledge on Halal TQM and provide practical recommendations for industry stakeholders, including government agencies, industry leaders, and service providers. Future research should focus on developing a unified Halal TQM framework and exploring its application in different cultural and regulatory contexts. Additionally, quantitative studies and longitudinal research could provide further validation of the findings and offer insights into the long-term impact of Halal TQM on operational performance and customer satisfaction.

FUTURE RESEARCH

Future research should build on the findings of this study by exploring the development of a unified Halal TQM framework that can be applied across different sectors of the tourism industry. This framework should be tested and refined through quantitative studies and longitudinal research to provide a deeper understanding of its impact on operational performance and customer satisfaction. Additionally, future research could explore the application of Halal TQM in different cultural and regulatory contexts, particularly in non-Muslim majority countries that are emerging as key players in the global Halal tourism market. By addressing these gaps, future research can contribute to the ongoing development and refinement of Halal TQM practices, ensuring that the tourism industry continues to meet the evolving needs of Muslim travelers and maintains its competitive edge in the global market.

REFERENCES

1. Ahmad Faizal Ahmad Ismail. (2023). Personal interview. General Manager, HalalStay Hotels, Kuala Lumpur.
2. Aisyah Zainal. (2023). Personal interview. Customer Service Manager, Halal Cruise Malaysia, Langkawi.
3. Ahmed, S., & Rahman, M. (2020). Integrating Halal principles in quality management systems: A review. Journal of Halal Studies, 12(3), 45-59.
4. Bryman, A. (2016). Social research methods (5th ed.). Oxford University Press.
5. Chapra, M. U. (1992). Islam and the economic challenge. International Institute of Islamic Thought.
6. Creswell, J. W., & Poth, C. N. (2018). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five approaches (4th ed.). Sage Publications.
7. Deming, W. E. (1986). Out of the crisis. MIT Press.
8. Department of Islamic Development Malaysia (JAKIM). (2022). Halal certification guidelines. Retrieved from [https://www.halal.gov.my] (https://www.halal.gov.my)
9. Faridah Yusof. (2023). Personal interview. Market Analyst, Muslim Travel Insights, Kuala Lumpur.
10. Guest, G., Bunce, A., & Johnson, L. (2006). How many interviews are enough? An experiment with data saturation and variability. Field Methods, 18(1), 59-82.
11. Haji Abdul Rahman Abdul Wahab. (2023). Personal interview. CEO, Muslim-Friendly Travel Agency, Johor Bahru.
12. Hashim, H., & Othman, R. (2019). The role of Halal certification in tourism: Insights from Malaysia. Tourism Management Perspectives, 31, 1-8.
13. Ibrahim, I., Amer, A., Othman, H., Halin, I. A., & Jamil, N. A. (2023). The Determinant Factors of Halal Total Quality Management Program for Small Industries. Russian Law Journal, 11(5S), 335-340.
14. Ibrahim, I., Amer, A., Othman, H., Halin, I. A., & Kasdi, S. A. (2023). Halal Total Quality Management Towards Quality Performance. A Conceptual Framework. Russian Law Journal, 11(5S), 341-350.
15. Idris, R., Razali, N. A. H., Rahman, N. A. A., Ibrahim, I., Senathirajah, A. R. S., & Rahmat, A. K. (2023). The Halal Purchasing Strategies on Manufacturing Performance. Russian Law Journal, 11(9S), 31-40.
16. Khairul Anwar Sulaiman. (2023). Personal interview. IT Specialist, HalalTech Innovations, Johor.
17. Krippendorff, K. (2018). Content analysis: An introduction to its methodology (4th ed.). Sage Publications.
18. Maria Hassan. (2023). Personal interview. Chief Strategy Officer, Islamic Travel Experts, Kuala Lumpur.
19. Merriam, S. B., & Tisdell, E. J. (2016). Qualitative research: A guide to design and implementation (4th ed.). Jossey-Bass.
20. Mohd Azlan Yusof. (2023). Personal interview. Senior Consultant, HalalCert Solutions, Selangor.
21. Muhammad Firdaus Zakaria. (2023). Personal interview. Operations Manager, Shariah Tours, Penang.
22. Norhayati Abdullah. (2023). Personal interview. Training Specialist, Halal Tourism Academy, Sabah.
23. Nurul Huda Mohd Hasri. (2023). Personal interview. Quality Assurance Officer, Islamic Hospitality Group, Malacca.
24. Palinkas, L. A., Horwitz, S. M., Green, C. A., Wisdom, J. P., Duan, N., & Hogwood, K. (2015). Purposeful sampling for qualitative data collection and analysis in mixed method implementation research. Administration and Policy in Mental Health and Mental Health Services Research, 42(5), 533-544.
25. Pew Research Center. (2015). The future of world religions: Population growth projections, 2010-2050. Retrieved from [https://www.pewresearch.org] (https://www.pewresearch.org)
26. Rizwan Hamzah. (2023). Personal interview. Halal Compliance Auditor, JAKIM, Putrajaya.
27. Saidin, W., Ibrahim, I.,Anis, A., S Senathirajah, A.R., & Nakamura, Y. (2024). The Determinant Factors of Halal Total Quality Management (HTQM) In the Sustainable Tourism Industry In Malaysia. African Journal of Biological Science, 6(9), 4998-5020.
28. Saunders, M., Lewis, P., & Thornhill, A. (2019). Research methods for business students (8th ed.). Pearson Education.
29. Sharifah Aminah Syed Azim. (2023). Personal interview. Cultural Program Manager, Islamic Heritage Tours, Perak.
30. Siti Nor Aini Jamaludin. (2023). Personal interview. Marketing Director, Halal Tourism Malaysia, Selangor.
31. Tengku Faris Tengku Firdaus. (2023). Personal interview. Director of Operations, Royal Halal Resorts, Terengganu.
32. World Travel & Tourism Council. (2020). Economic impact reports. Retrieved from [https://www.wttc.org] (https://www.wttc.org)
33. Yusuf, A., & Khalid, N. (2021). Halal tourism: Trends and future directions. Journal of Tourism Studies, 20(5), 33-47.
34. Zailani, S., et al. (2018). Halal logistics and supply chain management in emerging markets. International Journal of Logistics Management, 29(2), 123-137.
35. Zainuddin Arif. (2023). Personal interview. Food and Beverage Manager, Halal Gourmet Sdn. Bhd., Selangor.

APPENDIX 1

Below is a set of semi-structured interview questions designed to address the problem statement, research questions, and research objectives of the study. The questions are organized around the three key themes: Leadership and Governance, Training and Development, and Customer-Centric Approach. These questions will help gather in-depth insights from participants and ensure that the research objectives are met.

Semi-Structured Interview Questions

Theme 1: Leadership and Governance

Objective: To explore the role of leadership in implementing Halal TQM and ensuring compliance with Shariah principles.

1. Leadership Commitment:

• How does your organization demonstrate leadership commitment to Halal Total Quality Management (TQM)?
• Can you provide examples of how top management supports Halal compliance initiatives?

2. Policy and Governance:

• What policies or frameworks does your organization have in place to ensure Halal compliance?
• How are these policies communicated and enforced across different levels of the organization?

3. Challenges in Leadership:

• What challenges has your organization faced in implementing Halal TQM from a leadership perspective?
• How have these challenges been addressed?

4. Ethical Practices:

• How does your organization ensure that business practices align with Islamic ethical principles (maqasid al-Shariah)?
• Can you provide examples of ethical decision-making in the context of Halal tourism?

Theme 2: Training and Development

Objective: To examine the role of employee training in ensuring Halal compliance and service quality.

5. Training Programs:

• What training programs does your organization offer to ensure employees understand and adhere to Halal requirements?
• How often are these training programs conducted, and who is responsible for delivering them?

6. Employee Competence:

• How do you assess the effectiveness of training programs in improving employee competence in Halal compliance?
• Can you share any success stories or challenges related to employee training?

7. Cultural and Religious Sensitivity:

• How does your organization address the diverse cultural and religious backgrounds of employees in training programs?
• What strategies are used to ensure that all employees, regardless of their background, understand Halal principles?

8. Continuous Improvement:

• How does your organization ensure that training programs are updated to reflect changes in Halal standards or customer expectations?
• Can you provide examples of how feedback from employees or customers has led to improvements in training

Theme 3: Customer-Centric Approach

Objective: To explore how understanding customer needs enhances satisfaction and loyalty in Halal tourism.

9. Understanding Customer Needs:

• How does your organization identify and understand the needs of Muslim travelers?
• What methods are used to gather insights into customer preferences and expectations?

10. Personalized Services:

• Can you provide examples of how your organization tailors services to meet the specific needs of Muslim travelers?
• How do you ensure that these services align with Shariah principles?

11. Customer Feedback:

• What mechanisms does your organization have in place to collect and respond to customer feedback regarding Halal services?
• How has customer feedback influenced decision-making or service improvements?

12. Customer Satisfaction and Loyalty:

• How do you measure customer satisfaction and loyalty in the context of Halal tourism?
• What strategies have been most effective in enhancing customer satisfaction and loyalty?

Cross-Theme Questions

Objective: To explore the interrelationship between leadership, training, and customer-centricity in Halal TQM.

13. Integration of Themes:

• How do leadership, training, and customer-centricity work together to support the implementation of Halal TQM in your organization?
• Can you provide examples of how these elements have been integrated to achieve specific outcomes?

14. Challenges and Opportunities:

• What are the main challenges your organization faces in implementing Halal TQM across leadership, training, and customer-centricity?
• What opportunities do you see for improving Halal TQM practices in the tourism industry

15. Future Directions:

• What changes or improvements would you recommend to enhance the implementation of Halal TQM in the tourism industry?
• How do you see the role of Halal TQM evolving in the future, particularly in response to changing customer expectations or industry trends?

Alignment with Problem Statement, Research Questions, and Objectives

Problem Statement:

The problem statement highlights the lack of a unified Halal TQM framework in the Malaysian tourism industry, leading to inconsistent quality standards and limited understanding of Halal principles. The interview questions address this by exploring:

• Challenges in leadership and governance (e.g., lack of commitment, policy gaps).
• Gaps in training and development (e.g., inadequate training programs, cultural sensitivity issues).
• Limitations in customer-centric approaches (e.g., insufficient understanding of customer needs, weak feedback mechanisms).

Research Questions:

• What are the critical factors influencing Halal TQM in the Malaysian tourism industry?
• The questions on leadership, training, and customer-centricity identify key factors such as leadership commitment, employee training, and customer feedback mechanisms.
• How does Halal TQM affect customer satisfaction and operational efficiency?
• The questions on customer satisfaction, loyalty, and service quality explore the impact of Halal TQM on customer experiences and operational outcomes.

Research Objectives:

1. To identify the challenges and opportunities in implementing Halal TQM.

• The questions on challenges (e.g., leadership challenges, training gaps) and opportunities (e.g., improving customer feedback, integrating themes) directly address this objective.

2. To analyze the impact of Halal TQM on service quality and customer satisfaction.

• The questions on customer satisfaction, loyalty, and service quality provide insights into the impact of Halal TQM.

3. To propose a strategic framework for enhancing Halal compliance and quality assurance.

• The questions on future directions and recommendations help gather ideas for developing a strategic framework.

These semi-structured interview questions are designed to comprehensively address the problem statement, research questions, and objectives of the study. By covering the themes of Leadership and Governance, Training and Development, and Customer-Centric Approach, the questions ensure that the research captures the multifaceted nature of Halal TQM implementation in the Malaysian tourism industry. The flexibility of semi-structured interviews allows for probing deeper into responses, ensuring rich and meaningful data collection.