Telecommunication challenges and the path to integrating telemedicine in Nigeria’s healthcare system

Telecommunication Challenges and the Path to Integrating Telemedicine in Nigeria’s Healthcare System

Dike, Harcourt Whyte PhD

Rivers state University, Port Harcourt, Nigeria.

DOI: https://dx.doi.org/10.47772/IJRISS.2025.9010041

Received: 16 December 2024; Accepted: 23 December 2024; Published: 30 January 2025

ABSTRACT

This journal article delves into the complexities of telemedicine, focusing on the telecommunication challenges that hinder its effective implementation in Nigeria. Through an in-depth study, this article examines the state of telecommunication in Nigeria and its implications for telemedicine. Employing a mixed-methods research design, this study integrates qualitative and quantitative approaches to offer a comprehensive analysis of these challenges and their consequences. The research emphasizes both urban centers and rural areas with limited telecommunication infrastructure, targeting three key groups: healthcare providers, patients, and telecommunication experts. A purposive sampling technique was used to select 200 participants with relevant expertise and experience. Data collected through surveys, interviews, and secondary sources reveal significant barriers, including poor network coverage, limited broadband access, high internet costs, and erratic power supply. Over 70% of rural respondents reported inconsistent network availability, while broadband penetration in Nigeria remains at approximately 47%, disproportionately affecting rural areas. High internet costs were identified as a deterrent by 60% of healthcare providers and patients, and inadequate power supply further disrupts telecommunication systems, especially in rural regions. Quantitative and qualitative data highlight the impacts of these barriers, such as delayed medical consultations (experienced by 65% of respondents), reduced telemedicine utilization in rural areas (50% lower than urban areas), and a 40% failure rate in completing telemedicine sessions due to connectivity issues. The findings underscore the critical need for tailored interventions to address these barriers. Policymakers, telecommunications stakeholders, and healthcare providers must collaborate on strategic initiatives prioritizing infrastructure development, regulatory frameworks, and community engagement. A holistic approach integrating technological solutions with capacity building, public awareness campaigns, and policy reforms is essential for the successful integration of telemedicine in Nigeria. This research contributes to the broader discourse on telemedicine implementation in developing countries, offering actionable insights to navigate telecommunication barriers. By addressing these challenges, Nigeria can enhance healthcare delivery, position itself at the forefront of telemedicine innovation, and foster a resilient, inclusive, and responsive healthcare system that meets the diverse needs of its population.

Keywords: Telecommunication, Telemedicine, Healthcare, Nigeria, Infrastructure, Rural Health, Healthcare.

INTRODUCTION

The healthcare system in Nigeria faces a myriad of challenges, including inadequate access to medical services, particularly in rural and underserved areas. Telemedicine, the delivery of healthcare services through telecommunications technology, has emerged globally as a promising solution to bridge healthcare gaps. By leveraging technology, telemedicine enables users to access medical care remotely, mitigating geographical and infrastructural barriers. However, in Nigeria, the adoption of telemedicine is hindered by significant telecommunication barriers, which impede its integration into the healthcare system.

Telemedicine encompasses a wide range of applications, from basic consultations via telephone to advanced procedures like remote surgery. According to Bettey (2021), telemedicine ensures healthcare access regardless of distance, utilizing electronic and telecommunication technologies to exchange medical information. While the concept of telemedicine is not new—its first clinical reference dates back to the 1950s and 1960s its relevance has grown exponentially with advancements in communication technologies.

Despite its transformative potential, telemedicine also raises critical legal and ethical concerns. Issues such as data privacy, security, cross-border jurisdiction, and professional accountability need to be addressed for its effective implementation. Labisi (2021) emphasizes the necessity of a suitable legal framework to ensure that telemedicine functions seamlessly alongside traditional healthcare systems.

Nigeria, as the most populous nation in Africa, is characterized by a diverse population, economic challenges, and an uneven distribution of healthcare resources. These factors exacerbate the difficulty of providing adequate medical services, particularly in remote areas. Telemedicine offers an opportunity to overcome these barriers and enhance healthcare delivery. Oguntade (2020) posits that telemedicine can revolutionize Nigeria’s healthcare sector, addressing accessibility issues and improving the quality of medical services.

However, the success of telemedicine in Nigeria is inextricably linked to the availability of robust telecommunication infrastructure. While the country has made strides in mobile technology and internet connectivity, disparities in telecommunication infrastructure, especially between urban and rural areas, persist. Adegoke and Ojo (2021) highlight the urban-rural divide as a major obstacle to the equitable delivery of telecommunication services. Ajayi et al. (2019) similarly note that telemedicine’s success hinges on reliable and accessible telecommunication networks—a challenge that remains unresolved in many parts of Nigeria.

This paper explores the telecommunication barriers impeding the advancement of telemedicine in Nigeria, analyzing their impact on healthcare delivery and proposing strategies to overcome these challenges. By addressing these barriers, Nigeria can better harness the potential of telemedicine to create a more inclusive and efficient healthcare system. This study sought to:

1. Examine the telecommunication infrastructure challenges affecting the adoption and implementation of telemedicine in Nigeria
2. Analyze the impact of telecommunication barriers on healthcare accessibility and the delivery of medical services through telemedicine in Nigeria
3. Propose actionable strategies for addressing telecommunication limitations to enhance the integration and effectiveness of telemedicine in Nigeria’s healthcare system

Theoretical Framework Diffusion of Innovations Theory (Everett Rogers)

The Diffusion of Innovations Theory explains how new ideas, practices, or technologies spread within a society or organization. It identifies key factors that influence the adoption process, including the innovation’s perceived relative advantage, compatibility with existing systems, complexity, trialability, and observability.

In the context of telemedicine in Nigeria, this theory highlights the challenges of introducing telemedicine as an innovation in healthcare. Telemedicine relies heavily on telecommunication infrastructure, which is not uniformly accessible across the country. According to Rogers, innovations like telemedicine are more likely to be adopted when they offer a clear advantage and align with societal values and infrastructure. However, telecommunication barriers, such as poor network coverage and limited internet access in rural areas, hinder the perceived compatibility and accessibility of telemedicine, slowing its diffusion. This theory underscores the need for addressing these barriers to increase the rate of telemedicine adoption and acceptance within Nigeria’s healthcare landscape.

Telecommunication Barriers in Underserved Regions of Nigeria

Access to healthcare is a fundamental right. The World Health Organization (WHO) Constitution (1946) states unequivocally that “The enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health is one of the fundamental rights of every human being without distinction of race, religion, political belief, economic or social condition.” The constitution acknowledging health as a human right recognizes a legal obligation on states to ensure access to timely, acceptable, and affordable health care, yet, in many rural areas in Nigeria, barriers to delivering medical consultations persist, basically due to inadequate telecommunication infrastructures. It becomes imperative to interrogate specific telecommunication barriers that impede telemedicine in rural Nigeria.

Bandwidth Limitations:

Nigeria has over ten internet and phone connectivity providers led by MTN, Globacom, 9Mobile, Airtel, SWIFT, Spectranet etc. Yet remote and underserved local government areas in Nigeria have very limited bandwidth. According to Statista-an online research and statistics company, as of January 2023, the internet penetration rate in Nigeria reached 55.4 percent. The indicator expresses the percentage of the total population that uses the internet. Unfortunately, this figure may be way lower considering multiple use or logins by individuals. Even worse is the fact that majority of these internet users are in the urban cities and this is a critical challenge that adversely affects the quality and reliability of telemedicine applications in rural Nigeria.

Bandwidth limitations impede the smooth communication of medical data and real-time intercourse between healthcare providers and patients (Ibrahim & Mohammed, 2018). As a result, individuals in areas with these limitations face obstacles in gaining access to telemedicine services, because remote consultations become compromised and ineffective.

Connectivity Issues:

Epileptic and unstable Internet connectivity worsens the challenges faced by healthcare practitioners or governments planning to employ telemedicine to breach the gaps in medical delivery to rural areas in Nigeria. According to Ukaoha and Egbokhare (2021), to enhance the application of telemedicine in healthcare, there ought to be access to fast and reliable internet infrastructure available to enable people in the rural areas join in benefitting from telemedicine. Unfortunately, such fast and dependable internet connection is not available in most rural and remote communities in Nigeria.

Unreliable connectivity hampers the establishment of the type of connections required for telemedicine consultations to occur. In the words of Adegoke and Ojo (2021), Patients may experience disruptions, making it difficult to engage in meaningful and effective telemedicine without a stable connectivity.

Bandwidth limitations pose a significant challenge to the seamless operation of telemedicine applications. According to worlddata, Nigeria comes 104th with a download speed of 22.47 Mbit/second. The upload speed of around 10 Mbit was enough for 87th place. One of the objectives of broadband networks is to let users access the Internet at a speed of at least 1 Mbps and throughput of 300 mbps (Kuboye 2017). The quality and reliability of virtual consultations become compromised when the bandwidth needed to allow for a hitch-free communication is absent. This happens to occur mostly in rural areas that are always with inadequate bandwidth which in turn, impacts the effectiveness of telemedicine services. “Bandwidth limitations not only affect the real-time communication between healthcare providers and patients but also hinder the delivery of high-quality telemedicine services” (Ibrahim & Mohammed, 2018).

Technological Disparities:

Apart from infrastructural barriers, technological differences and low digital literacy contribute to the complexity of telemedicine adoption. Osagie (2022) opines that technological disparities and insufficient digital literacy are critical factors that must be addressed to ensure widespread and effective use of telemedicine technologies in Nigeria. The availability of smartphones and the ability of both healthcare providers and patients to navigate digital platforms play a fundamental role in the successful implementation of telemedicine.

The truth is still that citizens in rural areas are the ones who dearly need telemedicine because most rural communities hardly have well equipped medical centers of hospitals to take care of their medical needs. Unfortunately, just like they lack hospitals and medical centers, they also lack adequate technology that will enable them to get help through telemedicine. Ordinarily, one would expect that government would look in that direction, knowing that with the availability of adequate communication technology that supplies the adequate bandwidth, citizens in rural areas can leverage on telemedicine. Nevertheless, the Internet providers in Nigeria are all private businesses who focus more on supplying services in the cities.

Limited Digital Literacy:

Information and communication technology effectively debuted in Nigeria in 200, that notwithstanding, digital literacy is still below average. The National Information Technology Development Agency (NITDA) was setup by the Federal Ministry of Information and Communication with the mission “We commit to the promotion of digital literacy as a cornerstone of empowerment, enabling every citizen to embrace technology with confidence” the agency had set a target of 60% digital literacy between 2020-2025. (National Digital Literacy Framework 2023) This clearly means that the digital literacy level as at 2020 was nowhere near 60% majority of Nigerians are either not digitally literate of they just know the basics. This Insufficient digital literacy compounds the telecommunication barriers in underserved and rural areas in Nigeria. Individuals may lack the knowledge and skills needed to navigate telemedicine platforms effectively. This limitation in digital literacy further restricts the ability of users to engage in virtual consultations, hindering their access to essential healthcare services (Osagie, 2022).

Research Design

This study adopts a mixed-methods research design, combining qualitative and quantitative approaches to comprehensively investigate the telecommunication barriers affecting telemedicine advancement in Nigeria. Mixed-methods design ensures a holistic understanding of the challenges, impacts, and actionable solutions by integrating data from various sources Smith, (2021).

Study Area

The research focuses on Nigeria, a country with a diverse healthcare landscape and varying levels of telecommunication infrastructure across its urban and rural regions. Specific emphasis is placed on both urban centers like Port Harcourt in Rivers State, Uyo in Akwa Ibom State, and rural areas with limited telecommunication facilities like Abua in Rivers State and Mbo in Akwa Ibom State all in Nigeria during the period October 2023 to Septober 2024

Population and Sampling

The study targeted three key groups:

Healthcare Providers – Doctors, nurses, and telemedicine operators.

Patients – Individuals who have used or are potential users of telemedicine services.

Telecommunication Experts – Professionals involved in the development and management of telecommunication infrastructure.

A purposive sampling technique was employed to select participants with relevant experience and knowledge. A total of 200 participants were included in the study, divided as follows:

100 patients (50 urban, 50 rural)

60 healthcare providers (30 urban, 30 rural)

40 telecommunication experts

Table 1: Participant Demographics

Table 2: Telecommunication Infrastructure Challenges Affecting Telemedicine Adoption

Table 3: Impact of Telecommunication Barriers on Healthcare Accessibility and Delivery

FINDINGS/DISCUSSIONS

Telecommunication Infrastructure Challenges Affecting the Adoption and Implementation of Telemedicine in Nigeria

Data on telecommunication infrastructure challenges were collected through surveys, interviews, and secondary sources. Key challenges identified include:

1. Poor network coverage was identified as a major challenge. Over 70% of respondents in rural areas reported inconsistent network availability, making telemedicine consultations unreliable.
2. Limited broadband access was also identified as another major challenge as statistics indicate that broadband penetration in Nigeria is approximately 47% (as of 2023), with rural areas significantly underrepresented.
3. Another major challenge that was identified was high cost of Internet services. 60% of healthcare providers and patients identified the high cost of internet subscriptions as a deterrent to telemedicine adoption.
4. Inadequate power supply was also identified by respondents as a major challenge. Telecommunication systems in Nigeria and particularly in rural areas, are frequently disrupted due to erratic power supply, which hampers digital health solutions.

This study on telecommunication infrastructure challenges affecting the adoption and implementation of telemedicine in Nigeria has revealed significant impediments that need to be addressed to enhance the effectiveness of telemedicine services. Data collected through surveys, interviews, and secondary sources have highlighted four primary challenges: poor network coverage, limited broadband access, high cost of internet services, and inadequate power supply.

Firstly, poor network coverage emerged as a major challenge, particularly in rural areas. Over 70% of respondents from these areas reported inconsistent network availability, which renders telemedicine consultations unreliable. This finding aligns with previous research that underscores the disparity in network infrastructure between urban and rural regions in Nigeria (Adebayo, 2022).

Limited broadband access was also identified as a significant obstacle. As of 2023, broadband penetration in Nigeria stands at approximately 47%, with rural areas being significantly underrepresented (NCC, 2023). This limited access hampers the deployment of telemedicine services, which rely heavily on stable and high-speed internet connections. Similar conclusions were drawn in studies by Oluwatobi et al. (2022), which emphasized the correlation between broadband access and the adoption of digital health solutions.

Another critical challenge is the high cost of internet services. Approximately 60% of healthcare providers and patients reported that the high cost of internet subscriptions deters the adoption of telemedicine. This barrier is consistent with the findings of Ilesanmi and colleagues (2021), who highlighted the financial burden of internet costs on both providers and patients, thereby affecting the scalability of telemedicine services. Inadequate power supply was cited by respondents as a major challenge. Telecommunication systems in Nigeria, especially in rural areas, are frequently disrupted due to erratic power supply, which hampers digital health solutions (Eze, 2021). This challenge is critical because reliable power is essential for maintaining the infrastructure necessary for telemedicine.

The findings indicate that addressing these telecommunication infrastructure challenges is crucial for the successful adoption and implementation of telemedicine in Nigeria. Efforts should be focused on improving network coverage, expanding broadband access, reducing internet costs, and ensuring a stable power supply to facilitate effective digital health solutions.

Impact of Telecommunication Barriers on Healthcare Accessibility and the Delivery of Medical Services through Telemedicine in Nigeria

Quantitative and qualitative data reveal that telecommunication barriers significantly affect healthcare accessibility and delivery. The study found the following:

1. One of the major impacts of telecommunication barriers on healthcare accessibility is delayed medical consultations. 65% of respondents experienced delays in receiving telemedicine services due to unstable internet connectivity.
2. Rural respondents reported a 50% lower utilization of telemedicine compared to urban areas, attributed to poor telecommunication infrastructure.
3. Approximately 40% of patients who attempted telemedicine consultations did not complete their sessions due to connectivity failures.

Case Studies:

1. A case study of a rural healthcare center showed a failure rate of 30% for telemedicine consultations due to insufficient network bandwidth.
2. In urban centers, telemedicine adoption was higher, with better connectivity facilitating smoother service delivery.

Actionable Strategies for Addressing Telecommunication Limitations to Enhance the Integration and Effectiveness of Telemedicine in Nigeria’s Healthcare System

Based on stakeholder input, expert interviews, and best practices from other nations, the following strategies were identified and proposed:

1. Expansion of broadband networks in underserved rural areas to improve telecommunication access.
2. Collaborations between the government and telecommunication companies to reduce the cost of data plans for healthcare services.
3. Leveraging solar power solutions to ensure uninterrupted telecommunication services in areas with erratic power supply.
4. Training healthcare providers and patients in the use of telemedicine platforms to enhance user experience and confidence.

The impact of telecommunication barriers on healthcare accessibility and the delivery of medical services through telemedicine in Nigeria is significant, as evidenced by both quantitative and qualitative data. The study revealed several key issues affecting the effectiveness of telemedicine:

One of the most significant impacts of telecommunication barriers is the delay in medical consultations. According to the study, 65% of respondents experienced delays in receiving telemedicine services due to unstable internet connectivity. This finding is consistent with previous research, which has highlighted the importance of stable internet connectivity for timely and effective telemedicine consultations (Adebayo, 2022).

The study also found that rural respondents reported a 50% lower utilization of telemedicine compared to urban areas, which is attributed to poor telecommunication infrastructure. This disparity is a critical concern, as it suggests that individuals in rural areas have less access to telemedicine services, exacerbating healthcare inequalities. Similar observations were made by Eze et al. (2021), who noted that telecommunication infrastructure is often less developed in rural regions, leading to reduced adoption of telemedicine.

Approximately 40% of patients who attempted telemedicine consultations did not complete their sessions due to connectivity failures. This high rate of incomplete sessions underscores the challenges posed by unreliable internet connectivity, which can disrupt the continuity and quality of care provided through telemedicine. This finding aligns with the conclusions drawn by Ilesanmi and colleagues (2021), who emphasized the detrimental impact of connectivity issues on the effectiveness of telemedicine services.

These findings highlight the urgent need to address telecommunication barriers to improve healthcare accessibility and the delivery of medical services through telemedicine in Nigeria. Enhancing internet connectivity, particularly in rural areas, and ensuring reliable telecommunication infrastructure are essential steps toward realizing the full potential of telemedicine in improving healthcare outcomes.

CONCLUSION

This paper has sought to illuminate the multifaceted challenges and barriers that impede the advancement of telemedicine in the unique healthcare landscape of Nigeria. The empirical insights drawn from the case study underscore the critical importance of addressing telecommunication barriers to unlock the full potential of telemedicine in the country. It has become obvious that a complex interplay of factors, ranging from inadequate telecommunication infrastructure to socioeconomic disparities and regulatory gaps are the culprits in the difficulties faced by practitioners. The limited accessibility to reliable and high-speed internet, particularly in rural areas, emerges as a significant bottleneck in the widespread adoption of telemedicine services. Moreover, this paper emphasizes the need for tailored interventions that account for the diverse demographic and cultural aspects of Nigeria’s population. As we navigate the ever-evolving landscape of healthcare, it is imperative to recognize telemedicine as a transformative force with the potential to bridge gaps in access to quality medical care. However, the successful integration of telemedicine hinges on addressing the barriers identified in this paper. Policymakers, telecommunications stakeholders, and healthcare providers must collaborate to implement strategic initiatives that prioritize infrastructure development, regulatory frameworks, and community engagement.

Furthermore, this paper underscores the urgency of a holistic approach that integrates technological solutions with capacity building, public awareness campaigns, and policy reforms. By doing so, Nigeria can not only overcome the existing barriers but also position itself at the forefront of telemedicine innovation, fostering a healthcare system that is resilient, inclusive, and responsive to the diverse needs of its population. In essence, this research contributes to the broader discourse on telemedicine implementation in developing countries, offering actionable insights for stakeholders to navigate the complexities of telecommunication barriers. As we look toward the future, it is our hope that the recommendations outlined in this paper serve as a catalyst for transformative change, ushering in an era where telemedicine plays a pivotal role in enhancing healthcare delivery and outcomes across Nigeria.

RECOMMENDATIONS 

This paper has identified the critical need for targeted interventions to overcome telecommunications and propel the advancement of telemedicine in Nigeria’s healthcare landscape. Recognizing the complex interplay of infrastructure, regulatory, and societal challenges, the following recommendations are proposed to create an enabling environment for the seamless integration of telemedicine into the national healthcare system.

Substantial investments in telecommunication infrastructure are paramount to overcoming connectivity challenges, especially in rural areas. Government initiatives and collaborations with private telecommunication providers can facilitate the expansion of high-speed internet services, ensuring a reliable and robust network across diverse geographical regions. The establishment of telecommunication infrastructure should prioritize underserved areas, addressing the existing urban-rural divide in internet accessibility.

A comprehensive strategy to enhance digital literacy is essential to foster the adoption of telemedicine platforms. Community-based programs and nationwide awareness campaigns can empower healthcare professionals and the public alike to navigate and leverage telehealth technologies effectively. Such initiatives should focus on demystifying digital tools, instilling confidence, and cultivating a culture of acceptance and understanding of telemedicine. Finally, the development and implementation of clear regulatory frameworks tailored to telemedicine are crucial. Collaborative efforts between healthcare regulators, telecommunication authorities, and policymakers are needed to establish guidelines that address licensing, data privacy, and legal responsibilities. Clarity in regulations will instill confidence among healthcare providers and patients, fostering a conducive environment for the growth of telemedicine.

REFERENCES

1. Adebayo, T. (2022). Network Infrastructure Disparities in Nigeria. Journal of Telecommunication Studies, 15(3), 45-60.
2. Adegoke, A., & Ojo, O. (2021). Bridging the Healthcare Gap: Telemedicine and Telecommunication Infrastructure in Nigeria. International Journal of Scientific & Technology Research, 10(7).
3. Ajayi, I. O., Sowemimo, I. O., Akpa, M. O., and Ossai, N. E. (2019). Telemedicine in Nigeria: A Panacea for Improved Healthcare Services. Journal of Health Informatics in Developing Countries, 13(2).
4. Bettey, A. (2021). Telemedicine: Ensuring healthcare access through technology. Journal of Medical Innovations, Volume 6 (4), 128-144. https://doi.org/[DOI]
5. Eze, O. (2021). Power Supply Challenges in Rural Nigeria. Energy and Technology Journal, 12(4), 72-85.
6. Ibrahim, M., & Mohammed, I. (2018). Telemedicine in Nigeria: Prospects and Challenges Journal of the Nigerian Medical Association, 109(4).
7. Ilesanmi, O. et al. (2021). The Financial Burden of Internet Costs on Healthcare. Health Economics Review, 23(2), 101-112.
8. Labisi O. E. (2021) The legal framework of telemedicine in Nigeria retrieved from https://www.researchgate.net/publication/353664869
9. NCC. (2023). Broadband Penetration in Nigeria. Nigerian Communications Commission. Retrieved from https://www.ncc.gov.ng
10. Oguntade, A. O. (2020). The Role of Telemedicine in Enhancing Healthcare Delivery in Nigeria. Nigerian Medical Journal, 61(3).
11. Oluwatobi, K., & Adewale, J. (2022). The Impact of Broadband Access on Telemedicine Adoption. Digital Health Journal, 8(1), 33-48.
12. Osagie, E. (2022). Telemedicine Adoption in Nigeria: Exploring the Impact of Technological Disparities. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare, 28(1).
13. Smith, J. (2021). Mixed-methods research in healthcare: Bridging gaps and ensuring actionable solutions. Journal of Health Research Methods, 34(2), 45-60
14. Worlddata (2017) Telecommunication in Nigeria retrived at www.worlddata.info.com
15. WHO (1946) WHO Constitution retrieved from www.who.int.com
16. Ukaoha, K. O. and Egbokhare F (2021) ://www.researchgate.net/publication/272877000_Prospects_and_challenges_of_telemedicine_in_Nigeria [accessed Dec 02 2023].
17. National Information Technology Development Agency (2023) Digital Literacy Framework retrieved from https//www.nitda.gov.ng/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Digital-Literacy-Framework